The First Art Newspaper on the Net Established in 1996 United States Wednesday, August 27, 2014


Statement from the Guggenheim about the current lawsuit regarding the Peggy Guggenheim Collection
Peggy Guggenheim Collection (right) on the Grand Canal in Venice. Photo: David M. Heald © The Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation, New York.
NEW YORK, NY.- Peggy Guggenheim donated her Venice home (the Palazzo Venier dei Leoni) to the Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation in 1970 and donated her art collection to the Foundation in 1976. She stated only one purpose for these donations in her deeds of gift: “to demonstrate her admiration for the activities carried out by ‘The Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation’… concerning the study, the divulgation and the knowledge of works of art, in particular modern works of art, and with the purpose of expanding and fostering such activities in Italy."

For more than thirty years, the Foundation has faithfully carried out these wishes. Entirely at its own expense, because no endowment was attached to Peggy Guggenheim’s gifts, the Foundation has:

• extensively repaired and renovated the palazzo, both to preserve a structure that had suffered from deferred maintenance and to enable the building to function as a public museum, as Peggy Guggenheim had wished;

• maintained her collection of artworks intact in the palazzo, conserving them to the highest museum standards and never disposing of a single piece;

• and fulfilled Peggy Guggenheim’s wish to make these works more widely known and appreciated.

The Peggy Guggenheim Collection today is the most visited museum of modern art in Italy and in 2013 was the second most visited museum in Venice, exceeded only by the Doge’s Palace. Operating as a not-for-profit institution, the Peggy Guggenheim Collection maintains the collection, palazzo and gardens and provides an ongoing schedule of exhibitions and programs, including extensive educational offerings.

A recent lawsuit against the Foundation filed by one faction of Peggy Guggenheim’s descendants misrepresents both the purpose of Peggy Guggenheim’s gift to the Foundation and the Foundation’s record of achievement. Reports in the media that uncritically repeat the baseless allegations made by the plaintiffs in this lawsuit are erroneous.

The Foundation wishes to draw attention to these facts:

1. The two grandsons of Peggy Guggenheim who with their children have filed the current lawsuit, Sandro Rumney and Nicolas Hélion, are descendants of Peggy Guggenheim but are not her heirs and were not mentioned in her will. Peggy Guggenheim left her entire estate to her son Sindbad Vail, who was also her sole executor. Mr. Rumney and Mr. Hélion are the sons of Peggy Guggenheim’s only other child, Pegeen Vail.

2. The children of Sindbad Vail are not participating in this lawsuit. They have expressed disappointment about its having been initiated and have endorsed the Foundation’s record of achievements in Venice.

3. Three of Peggy Guggenheim’s grandchildren and one of her great-grandchildren have written letters of support in this case for inclusion in the Foundation’s brief in which they express their belief that the Foundation has honored their grandmother’s wishes.

4. The complaints in the current lawsuit are essentially the same as those that were put forward, and rejected, in a 1992 lawsuit brought by Mr. Rumney and Mr. Hélion (and their late brother, David Hélion) before the same court in Paris. In that earlier lawsuit, the plaintiffs incorrectly alleged that Peggy Guggenheim had placed “precise conditions” on her gifts concerning the manner in which the collection was to be maintained and exhibited, with the palazzo being kept unaltered as a memorial and a house museum.

5. In December 1994, the Tribunal de Grande Instance de Paris (Paris District Court) totally rejected the 1992 allegations, finding that “the only legally applicable deeds [of gift] do not subject Peggy Guggenheim’s gifts to the foundation to any special conditions” and that “the author herself did not specify the inviolable character of the organization and presentation of her collection in the gift deeds.” The court dismissed the case and sentenced Sandro Rumney and Nicolas and David Hélion to pay damages to the Foundation, in addition to court costs.

6. Rumney and Hélion subsequently appealed the court’s decision. Rather than continue to bear the considerable trouble and cost of frivolous litigation, which the Foundation did not deem to be a proper use for a not-for-profit’s resources, the Foundation offered a settlement agreement, which was signed in December 1996. In the settlement, the Foundation agreed to no financial payment other than a contribution of up to $30,000 toward the attorneys’ fees for the plaintiffs’ failed lawsuit. In the settlement agreement, Sandro Rumney and Nicolas Hélion explicitly acknowledged “the exclusive right of the Foundation to the exercise of its control over conservation of the Collection and exhibition of the works of art in the Palace” and that the Foundation “will continue its efforts to present from time to time the greatest possible number of works of the Collection that it should judge, at its sole discretion, to be the optimum number for presentation of the Collection.”

7. The settlement agreement provided for the creation of a Peggy Guggenheim Collection Family Committee, which, as stated in the agreement, “will have a purely symbolic function” and “will not hold formal meetings.”

8. Sandro Rumney and Nicolas Hélion and their children have now entered a new lawsuit against the Foundation in the Tribunal de Grande Instance de Paris, on grounds that the same court has already found to be baseless, and that the plaintiffs themselves abandoned in the 1996 settlement agreement.

9. By their own actions, the plaintiffs have repeatedly contradicted their own position.

• They insist that no works other than Peggy Guggenheim’s be exhibited in the palazzo or the garden. Yet between 1999 and 2013, they were instrumental in organizing fourteen exhibitions of works entirely foreign to the Peggy Guggenheim Collection that were shown in the palazzo, on the Grand Canal terrace of the palazzo or in the garden.

• They object to works other than those donated by Peggy Guggenheim being kept and exhibited at the museum in Venice. Yet they themselves have donated multiple works to be kept and exhibited at the Peggy Guggenheim Collection.

• They luridly mischaracterize the receptions held in the garden as a “desecration” of Peggy Guggenheim’s grave. Yet these events carry forward Peggy Guggenheim’s own tradition of sociability in the garden. They are held with great consideration and respect for the quiet corner of the garden in which Peggy Guggenheim’s urn is interred. And Mr. Rumney and Mr. Hélion themselves have participated in garden events many times over the years.

Despite the frivolous lawsuit and misleading reports in the media, the Foundation has worked to make the name of Peggy Guggenheim and the renown of her achievements more celebrated than ever before and will continue to ensure that Peggy Guggenheim’s collection is honored and preserved.



Today's News

May 17, 2014

National Park Service reopens Washington Monument after $15 million earthquake repairs

De La Warr Pavilion commemorates World War One with exhibition of works by Otto Dix

Metropolitan Museum initiative provides free access to 400,000 digital images

Statement from the Guggenheim about the current lawsuit regarding the Peggy Guggenheim Collection

Sotheby's Paris anounces its June Sale of Impressionist and Modern Art led by Modigliani painting

Documents from the Royal Family's private archive go on display at Windsor Castle

Museum of Contemporary Art, San Diego opens "Treasures of the Tamayo, Mexico City"

Antik A.S. to offer famous Turkish artist Osman Hamdi Bey masterpiece in Istanbul

France mourns slain photojournalist Camille Lepage cut down in Central African Republic

"Urbes Mutantes: Latin American Photography 1944-2013" opens at the International Center of Photography

The Irvine Museum celebrates 100 years of Plein Air painting with new exhibition

Ceremonial swords achieve top price in record-breaking Bonhams £1.5 million Japanese Art Sale

Rare Aston Martin Ulster set to break world record at the Goodwood Festival of Speed Sale

The Metamorphosis: Twenty-five years of Russian artists' books at the Van Abbemuseum

Matthew Barton Ltd announces bi-annual Auction of Decorative Works of Art

Major exhibition honors influential and seminal New Jersey artist

The El Paso Museum of Art announces "Saint Francis of Assisi and Saint Francis of Paola"

Jeffrey S. Evans & Associates to auction part II of the Hulsebus Collection

From licks to clicks, performance artist battles attention spans

"Ramiro Llona: Utopia: Works from the 80s" opens at Nohra Haime Gallery

Most Popular Last Seven Days



1.- Mystery over massive Alexander the Great-era tomb unearthed in northern Greece

2.- An ancient money box containing a large rare hoard of coins found in Israel

3.- Robin Williams' portrait installed today at the National Portrait Gallery in Washington

4.- The Baltimore Museum of Art announces three new contemporary exhibitions in fall

5.- New Aspen Art Museum designed by architect Shigeru Ban opens to the public

6.- New York's Metropolitan Museum of Art launches 82nd & Fifth app in 12 languages

7.- MoMA online-only publication features new research on Pablo Picasso and Cubism

8.- Volunteers needed for massive Smithsonian digitization project

9.- Tate Britain welcomes home John Everett Millais's Ophelia and Rossetti’s The Beloved

10.- Bogart estate: Hollywood golden age icon Lauren Bacall dead at 89 in New York



Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 

Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Rmz. - Marketing: Carla Gutiérrez
Special Contributor: Liz Gangemi - Special Advisor: Carlos Amador
Contributing Editor: Carolina Farias

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org theavemaria.org juncodelavega.org facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site