The First Art Newspaper on the Net   Established in 1996 United States Saturday, April 21, 2018

Swedish artist Jonas Dahlber's landscape memorial to Breivik victims sparks outrage in Norway
This recent handout photo shows a model of Memory Wound, the winning entry for the memorial by the Swedish artist Jonas Dahlberg depicting a 3,5 metre wide slit into the Sorbraten peninsula, which faces the island of Utoya, where Anders Behring Breivik killed 69 people AFP PHOTO / NTB scanpix /Jonas Dahlberg Studio.

By: Pierre-Henry Deshayes

OSLO (AFP).- A controversial memorial project for the victims of Norwegian mass murderer Anders Behring Breivik near the site of the massacre has sparked anger among relatives and locals.

Called "Memory Wound", the project by Swedish landscape artist Jonas Dahlber carves a three-and-half meter wide slit through a small peninsula facing the island of Utoeya, where the right-wing extremist killed 69 people, mostly teenagers, on July 22, 2011.

Names of the victims would be engraved into one side of the peninsula's symbolic wound, with a observation gallery installed into the facade on the opposite side.

The jury which selected the proposal describe it as "a wound or a cut within the landscape" which symbolises "something being taken away".

The idea was hailed when it was chosen in late February --but since then the criticism has grown.

Families of some of the victims complain they were never consulted on the avant-garde installation, while residents say that it scars the landscape and experts argue that it's technically not viable.

"I'm not against the monument in itself. It's the way that it was chosen and the location that poses a problem for me," said Vanessa Svebakk, the mother of the youngest victim, aged 14.

Breivik is serving out a 21-year prison sentence for the murder of a total of 77 people in a rampage which also saw eight people die in a bomb attack outside a government building in Oslo.

"Since the process started at the end of 2012, we who were closest to the victims, the most affected, have been kept in the dark," Svebakk told AFP.

"It's arrogant to use the names of our children without asking us. The fact that they are dead does not make them any less our children."

She said it was out of the question that her daughter's name should appear several hundred metres away from the island where she was killed.

Svebakk and several other families want to see a complete overhaul of the memorial project.

Tourist attraction
They have been joined by people who live nearby the planned site.

"It's a bit hard to accept that we'll be reminded of (the massacre of) July 22 every day for the rest of our lives," said local Ole Morten Jensen.

"I don't need those kinds of reminders. I had enough of them already," he told public broadcaster NRK.

Opponents of the memorial have started a social media campaign on Facebook -- which has attracted almost 900 members -- with some condemning the project as a "rape of nature", and a "tourist attraction" that runs the risk of becoming a pilgrimage site for Breivik admirers.

Further complicating the memorial, a geologist, Hans Erik Foss Amundsen, pointed out that the rock foundation at the project site is porous and the facade planned for the victim names would crumble into the sea.

"It's like digging in a pile of gravel," he said.

Nonetheless, the backers of the project -- which is due to be inaugurated on July 22, 2015 -- are confident that it will go ahead.

"Public art always attracts a multitude of viewpoints, especially when it concerns a work that commemorates a drama like Utoeya," said Svein Bjoerkaas, director of Koro, the Norwegian organisation responsible for public art.

"But from past experience, after some time the criticism dwindles," he told AFP.

"Let's keep in mind that this memorial is not only for those -- relatively few -- who are against it, but also the many who are in need of it."

In a statement, the chairman of the selection jury, Joern Mortensen, answered all the criticism firmly.

"The location of the memorial? It was imposed from the start by the state," he said.

"The opinion of close relatives? The vice-president of the support group of the victims' families was a member of the selection committee," he added.

Mortensen also said victims could remain anonymous and that "technical solutions exist" for any problems regarding the crumbling rock terrain.

It was possible to attract visitors and maintain the dignity of the site as shown by the Vietnam Veterans Memorial in Washington DC, Mortensen said.

"Our mission is to create a place of memory, not a place of forgetting."

© 1994-2014 Agence France-Presse

Today's News

March 20, 2014

160 works by Frida Kahlo on display for the first time in Italy at the Scuderie del Quirinale

Recent acquisitions take the spotlight alongside European masters at The Phillips Collection

Christie's New York to sell trove of rare maps and globes from Kenneth Nebenzhal, Inc.

Swedish artist Jonas Dahlber's landscape memorial to Breivik victims sparks outrage in Norway

Exhibition of early works by Peter Doig opens at Michael Werner Gallery in London

Christie's dominates market in Middle East with $10.6 million auction total; Increase of 65% on last year’s sale

The British Library acquires two rare manuscripts preventing them from leaving the UK

Strong results lift the market for Modern and Contemporary South Asian art

Signings of times: United States archives shows more than 100 signatures of figures

Exhibition of paintings by New York artist Stone Roberts opens at Hirschl & Adler Modern

Library charting half a millenium of British exploration to be auctioned at Sotheby's

Exhibition of five large-scale photographs by Chen Jiagang opens at Galerie Edwynn Houk in Zurich

Islamic beauty sells for £1 million in South African Art Sale at Bonhams in London

Michael Rudokas "Terrible Shadow" opens at Denny Gallery

Artworks by some of the most famous names in Contemporary and Modern art to be offered at A.B. Levy's

Alison Jacques Gallery opens third solo show with artist Tomory Dodge

Highlight's first solo exhibition with Australian artist Ben Barretto opens in San Francisco

Francois Linke bibliotheque leads Bonhams auction in San Francisco

Columbus Museum Director Tom Butler announces retirement

"Crossing Borders" opens at Stockholm's Arlanda airport

French police recover Rembrandt stolen 15 years ago

Most Popular Last Seven Days

1.- John Surtees' one-owner 1957 BMW 507 to be offered for the first time at Bonhams Festival of Speed sale

2.- Antiques looted in Libya by IS sold in Spain, two experts arrested

3.- The world's oldest bridge to be preserved by the British Museum's Iraq Scheme

4.- Exquisite jewels dazzle in historic Cartier exhibition at the National Gallery of Australia

5.- Now showing in US cinemas: "Hitler VS Picasso and The Others" directed by Claudio Poli

6.- New York's Metropolitan Museum of Art returns stolen idols to Nepal

7.- Glasgow starts a year of celebration as Charles Rennie Mackintosh exhibition opens

8.- Very rare Qing Dynasty bowl sells for $30.4 million

9.- Gardner Museum publishes "Stolen" book about 13 works in 1990 theft

10.- Royal Ontario Museum announces appointment of Curator, Islamic Art & Culture

Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .


Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher:Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez

Royalville Communications, Inc
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
to a Mexican poet.

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful