|Artist battles Alabama over football paintings|
Daniel Moore, an artist, is photographed at his office in Hoover, Ala., Saturday March 12, 2005. The University of Alabama has sued Moore, claiming that some of his famous paintings depicting Alabama football over the past 26 years violate trademark law by showing Crimson Tide uniforms and logos. Moore, who has filed a countersuit against the university, said Tuesday, March 22, his paintings depict Alabama in a positive light and are protected by the Constitution's guarantees of freedom of speech and expression. AP Photo/The Birmingham News, Steve Barnette.
By: Greg Bluestein, Associated Press
ATLANTA (AP).- Daniel Moore made a name for himself drawing iconic images of famous University of Alabama sporting events. But his work has also drawn the ire of school administrators, who claim his artistry violates the trademark rights they jealously work to protect.
The 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta heard arguments on Thursday in the case, part of an ongoing legal feud between universities seeking greater control over their copyright rights and artists who claim free speech rights.
Moore, who lives in Birmingham, Ala., has long worked with the school to draw iconic images that commemorate some of Alabama's biggest sporting events. But the school and Moore broke ties after a falling out around 2000, and five years later Alabama brought the case to federal court by suing Moore.
The school said it was forced to target Moore and his company, New Life Art, in 2005 because the artist profited from the university's name by refusing to pay licensing fees that fund student scholarships. At Thursday's hearing, the university argued its right to protect its trademark should trump Moore's First Amendment rights to paint scenes from Alabama football games.
Moore and his attorneys countered that his artwork, which includes paintings, prints and drawings on coffee mugs, is protected free speech and shouldn't be restricted by trademark law. He hasn't stopped his work, and is now working on a painting called "The Shutout" from Alabama's 21-0 victory last month over LSU in the national championship game.
A federal judge reached a split decision in 2009. The judge found that Moore's larger prints are protected by free speech rights, but that mini-prints on coffee mugs and calendars were not. Both sides promptly appealed, setting the stage for Thursday's arguments.
The three-judge panel didn't immediately issue a ruling on Thursday, and any decision it makes will be closely watched by university officials, media organizations and intellectual property attorneys, who all have a stake in the outcome.
Some 27 universities filed court briefs backing Alabama's stance, arguing that licensing programs are necessary to protect trademarks and provide an important source of revenue at a time of budget cuts.
"A bedrock principle of trademark law is an owner's right to control the use of its marks," the schools said in the brief.
Media organizations have flocked to Moore's defense. A friend-of-the-court brief filed by the American Society of Media Photographers and the Alabama Press Association claimed Moore was expressing the culture of his surroundings, much like Claude Monet was inspired by water lilies in France and Pieter Bruegel was moved to portray peasants in Belgium.
"Daniel Moore lives in Alabama; he paints football," the brief said. "To say football is special in Alabama is to understate the state's passion for and interest in it not by inches, but by yards."
Copyright 2012 The Associated Press.
February 6, 2012
Gris, Van Gogh, Signac & Miro lead Christie's auction of Impressionist and Modern Art
United States Archives unveils Magna Carta in a specially humidified glass and metal case after repairs
Alec Soth's compelling series "Broken Manual" on view at Sean Kelly Gallery in New York
Two new exhibitins open at the Andy Warhol Museum: "Warhol and Cars" and " About Face"
MoMA makes major acquisitions of iconic works by Valie Export, Sigmar Polke, and Martha Rosler
Post-Impressionist masters seize the moment with new handheld cameras in exhibition at the Phillips Collection
To See as Artists See: American Art from The Phillips Collection brings important works to the Frist Center
Yvonne Rainer" Space, Body, Language on view at Kunsthaus Bregenz
Major retrospective of video and new works by Santiago Sierra at Lisson Gallery
RAY 2012 to present outstanding international positions of contemporary photography and video art in Frankfurt
Matthew Day Jackson's first major solo European exhibition opens at The Hague's GEM museum
Thomas Paul Fine Art presents the photographic work of John Reiff Williams in "The Edge of Collapse"
Zaha Hadid Architects and Central Bank of Iraq sign agreement for new headquarters in Baghdad
San Francisco's Dogpatch pier district braces for renewal
Artist battles Alabama over football paintings
Beirut Art Fair unveils in its cultural program, the diversity of contemporary art
Three solo exhibitions by women artists at the Musée d'art contemporain de Montréal
Design chosen for NYC AIDS memorial park
Most Popular Last Seven Days
1.- A second life for the 'blue gold' that once brought riches to France's southwest
2.- Britain's WWII tunnels rediscovered after six decades buried as a forgotten time capsule
3.- Chinese dissident artist Ai Weiwei arrives in Germany, says Britain restricted his visa
4.- 'Feeding the Empire: Tales of food from Rome and Pompei' on view at Ara Pacis Museum
5.- Exhibition celebrates the 150th anniversary of the publication of Alice in Wonderland
6.- British actress and singer Jane Birkin asks Hermes to take name off crocodile handbag
7.- Smithsonian Institution reveals identities of four lost leaders of Jamestown
8.- Rare medieval panel purchased by the National Gallery thanks to Ronald S Lauder
9.- Teen finds 560,000 year-old tooth in one of the world's most important prehistoric sites
10.- Exhibition presents all 17 works by Hopper in the Carnegie Museum of Art's collection
Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .
|Royalville Communications, Inc|