Elliott Carter's early flops reveal a budding musical master
The First Art Newspaper on the Net    Established in 1996 Thursday, November 14, 2024


Elliott Carter's early flops reveal a budding musical master
A scene from “The Minotaur,” by the company that would become the New York City Ballet in 1947. Elliott Carter, who wrote the score for “The Minotaur,” was a composer of famously thorny music had two failed forays into ballet, given fresh reconsideration on a new album. Larry Colwell via The New York Times.

by Joshua Barone



NEW YORK (NYT NEWS SERVICE).- Composer Elliott Carter, looking back on his early ballet “Pocahontas,” wrote that it was “full of suggestions of things that were to remain important to me, as well as others which were later rejected or completely transformed.”

“Rejected” is putting it lightly. The approachable “Pocahontas” — one of Carter’s first scores, from the late 1930s — bears almost no resemblance to the thorny and unpredictable works that would come to define his long career, which continued until shortly before his death in 2012, at 103.

Carter, a composer who always seemed more interested in the future than the past, was no champion of “Pocahontas,” which despite its likability quickly fell into obscurity — never a repertory staple and never recorded. That is, until now, with the release of a new album by the Boston Modern Orchestra Project that also includes “The Minotaur” (1947), Carter’s only other ballet.

The recording offers an opportunity to reconsider what on the surface were early failures. “Pocahontas,” written for Lincoln Kirstein’s touring Ballet Caravan, was panned by New York Times dance critic John Martin for a score that was “so thick it is hard to see the stage through it.”

“The Minotaur” was meant to be choreographed by George Balanchine for the company that would become New York City Ballet. But instead the job fell to John Taras, and — as David Schiff, composer and former Carter student, observes in the album’s liner notes — the mythological work was overshadowed by Balanchine’s similarly minded collaborations with Igor Stravinsky, which became classics.

After “The Minotaur,” Carter was on the cusp of both a crisis and a breakthrough with his First String Quartet (1950-51).

“I had felt that it was my professional and social responsibility to write interesting, direct, easily understood music,” he wrote. “With this quartet, however, I decided to focus on what had always been one of my musical interests, that of ‘advanced’ music, and to follow out, with a minimal concern for their reception, my own musical thoughts along these lines.”

Carter didn’t care to dwell on his early period, but if there’s an ensemble up to the task of making a fresh case for “Pocahontas” and “The Minotaur,” it’s the Boston Modern Orchestra Project, which in the past decade has released nearly 100 recordings of both premieres — including Andrew Norman’s “Play” — and overlooked gems. (It’s something like classical music’s equivalent of New York Review Books.)

“In both of these ballets, the sophisticated use of harmony and rhythm foreshadows the stuff to come,” Gil Rose, the group’s artistic director and conductor, said in a recent interview. “He’s obviously a brilliant composer.”

Rose took a break from editing an album of John Adams’ two chamber symphonies to discuss the ballets — their importance within Carter’s output and what they share with his later masterworks. Here are edited excerpts from the conversation.

Q: What are the hallmarks of Carter’s early sound?




A: His music had not become as stark. “The Minotaur” isn’t so much padded with a sonic cushion, but “Pocahontas” is. He could really write a lush orchestration, and with a big string section. In that way its inspiration is more a romantic ballet than a 20th-century ballet. So it’s more like Prokofiev than anything else — nothing like the neoclassical stuff that does take him by storm down the road. “The Minotaur” is more like that. There’s a big pas de deux in it that could have come out of any middle-period Stravinsky ballet.

Q: What does looking at these ballets together reveal about Carter’s progression as a composer?

A: His sound gets more angular. That’s probably also because a lot of Stravinsky’s middle-period works start to get known in the United States. Rhythmically, it gets less flexible — more repeated patterns and spiky rhythms. And harmonically, it’s more dissonant. The orchestration has this brashness, and a lot of clashes and disjunct that shows itself already in “Pocahontas.”

It is interesting, though: If you play “Pocahontas” for someone and say, “Name that composer,” it would take a lot of people who know a lot about music to get through a lot of composers to get to Carter.

Q: I would say the time is easy to place, but definitely not the composer.

A: If you hear the Piano Sonata (1945) and the “Holiday Overture” (1944), they’re of the same ilk. He sort of didn’t advocate for his early music very much. But I think it’s important to know where he came from. If you pair this with his late music, it’s a hell of a journey. And this is how it started.

Q: Can you point to anything that survives the turn Carter takes after the First String Quartet?

A: It’s a little hard to compare “Pocahontas” with a piece like the String Quartet. But I would look at the Pavane at the end, the way he starts to lay harmonies on top of each other. It’s clear at this moment he’s not writing “Billy the Kid,” or any other kind of Copland Americana, even though it has an Americana subject. He doesn’t stick a folk tune in, or nod to Native American music. He writes in a sense like Prokofiev: He writes the music that he wants to write.

At the same time, it’s not at all juvenilia. You know it’s a piece that was done by a gifted and skilled composer. The writing is quite sophisticated. Even talented orchestrators make mistakes in their early pieces, but you get into a movement like “Princess Pocahontas and Her Ladies” — that’s really subtle writing. Most young composers on their first orchestra piece couldn’t pull that off. When we think of Carter, we don’t think of orchestration as one of his main strengths. But with this piece it clearly is.

Q: It reminds me of early Joyce, straightforward yet showing a total mastery of prose.

A: That’s a great example. Because nobody understands any of James Joyce at the end. You have to read every sentence like 16 times, but it’s still worth it. The early things that have a more direct communication line to the accepted musical syntax of the time can still be interesting. The quality of his mind and music is apparent even in a form that’s digestible by the normal concertgoing audience.

And just because it’s digestible doesn’t mean it’s not musical, or not interesting. In fact, it’s sometimes harder to write music that functions on both planes. Those are the pieces that I really love.

© 2021 The New York Times Company










Today's News

March 18, 2021

France's Bayeux Tapestry faces first restoration in 150 years

Vibrant multimedia artist and painter Amaranth Roslyn Ehrenhalt dies at the age of 93

Asia Week New York extends online viewing room through March 27th

Solo exhibition of ten works by Roy Lichtenstein opens at Pace Gallery's seasonal location in Palm Beach

The Met receives significant gift of 18 exceptional contemporary metalworks by Japanese artists

Extremely rare Ming Dynasty bowl discovered at Connecticut yard sale for $35 achieves $721,800 at Sotheby's

Career-spanning survey of Alice Neel opens March 22 at The Met

James Levine, former Met Opera maestro, is dead at 77

2021 begins a new era of arms & armor at Cowan's and Hindman

An architect's muted triumph

Naudline Pierre now represented by James Cohan

Exhibition at BOZAR presents a comprehensive overview of Roger Raveel's work

The arts are coming back this summer. Just step outside.

PalaisPopulaire gives new insight into the important oeuvre of K.H. Hödicke

Colnaghi partners with influential Barcelona galleries for 'Spanish Modern Landscapes' exhibition

Artcurial announces the 4th edition of Italian Design sales

Nicola Pagett, 'Upstairs, Downstairs' actress, dies at 75

Elliott Carter's early flops reveal a budding musical master

Hosfelt Gallery announces the world premiere of the most recent video by Liliana Porter

Stanley Whitney's first full-scale exhibition in Los Angeles on view at Matthew Marks

Sports items headlined by Roger Peckinpaugh collection up for auction

Hip Hop artist I Self Devine partners with Minneapolis Institute of Art on 'Rituals of Resilience' exhibition

Archive of plans for Walt Disney's legendary backyard railroad pulls in to Heritage Auctions

Heritage Auctions' march toward April 1-4 Comics and Comic Art sale began with a record-setting event

Lead-to-Customer Conversion Rate in 2021

5 Logo Design Lessons From Ikea's Iconic Logo

3 tips to get 1000s of Twitter followers.

4 killer ways to increase Twitter followers

Insider Secrets for Organic Instagram Growth

Instagram Stories Strategies: What You Should Share

Art in online gaming is not just an illusion

5 Birthday Gift Ideas For Stylish Men

Panerai: An Overview of the Luxury Dive Watch

Audemars Piguet's Timepieces Raised Around The World

Why Does Every Online Casino Need These Features?




Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 



Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez
Writer: Ofelia Zurbia Betancourt

Attorneys
Truck Accident Attorneys
Accident Attorneys
Holistic Dentist
Abogado de accidentes
สล็อต
สล็อตเว็บตรง

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org juncodelavega.com facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site Parroquia Natividad del Señor
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful