Collector sues to block investigators from seizing Roman bronze
The First Art Newspaper on the Net    Established in 1996 Thursday, November 21, 2024


Collector sues to block investigators from seizing Roman bronze



NEW YORK, NY.- A California collector has gone to court to block efforts by New York investigators to seize an ancient Roman bronze statue that they assert was looted from Turkey in the 1960s.

In a federal court filing last week in California, lawyers for the collector, Aaron Mendelsohn, 74, disputed the evidence they said investigators had presented indicating that the ancient statue of a man was stolen from an archaeological site in Turkey. The lawyers said investigators had no jurisdiction to seize items in California and so were overstepping their authority.

It was the latest in a series of recent challenges to efforts by the Manhattan district attorney’s office to seize artifacts believed to have been looted. The Cleveland Museum of Art and the Art Institute of Chicago are also engaged in legal challenges with the investigators over items with disputed histories.

In Mendelsohn’s case, his lawyers have accused the investigators of using the threat of prosecution to pressure their client into giving up the statue. In addition, they have argued that by pursuing the statue in a potential criminal proceeding, the investigators can avoid the fuller disclosure and access to evidence that would have been required in civil court.

The district attorney’s office “has invoked New York criminal process in an effort to intimidate Mendelsohn into relinquishing the Bronze Male, without affording Mendelsohn a legitimate opportunity to fully explore the evidence that DANY claims casts doubt on Mendelsohn’s ownership or to litigate its true ownership,” Marcus Asner, a lawyer for Mendelsohn, wrote in court papers filed in U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, Western Division.

Manhattan district attorney’s office responded with a statement that said: “Our Antiquities Trafficking Unit has successfully recovered thousands of stolen antiquities that came through Manhattan from galleries, homes, and museums around the country. We will respond to this filing in court.”

The statue is thought by investigators in New York and Turkey to be part of a grouping once created at a shrine that was built during Roman rule, around AD 50 to AD 250, in what is today southwestern Turkey, to honor a succession of Roman emperors. Investigators say that many of the statues were stolen in the 1960s during a looting spree by villagers at the archaeological site, called Bubon.

In the past few years, as part of its investigation into Turkey’s claims that artifacts were looted, the district attorney’s Antiquities Trafficking Unit has returned several other statues thought to have been from the same location, including pieces seized from the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the Museum of Greek, Etruscan, and Roman Art at Fordham University, among others.

But last year the Cleveland Museum of Art went to federal court in Ohio to block the seizure of one of its premier statues, a headless bronze. Investigators believe the bronze, valued at $20 million, also came from Bubon and depicts the great Roman statesman Marcus Aurelius.

The Cleveland case is the focus of attention among lawyers waiting to see whether the outcome will limit the authority of the Manhattan prosecutors.

According to the court papers, Mendelsohn bought the statue in 2007 from a New York art dealer, Royal-Athena Galleries, for about $1.33 million.

The bronze was described by the dealer in its invoice as “ROMAN BRONZE MONUMENTAL MALE MEMBER OF THE IMPERIAL FAMILY IN HEROIC POSE.” The provenance was “Said to be from Bubon, Turkey. Late 2nd — early 3rd Century AD”; it had previously been in a Boston private collection, which had acquired it in Switzerland.

Elizabeth Marlowe, a professor at Colgate University in New York, who has advised the district attorney’s office on the Bubon investigation, said the statue was one of two sold by the gallery. It was accompanied at the time, she said, by a letter from Cornelius Vermeule, then curator of classical antiquities at the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston, that endorsed it as having come from Bubon.

“That’s significant because Vermeule was the first American scholar to start tracking the Bubon case and was the undisputed authority,” she said.

Mendelsohn’s lawyers said he would return the statue to Turkey if the evidence showed it had been looted.

But they wrote: “The evidence presented by DANY does not provide a sufficient basis to conclude that the Bronze Male was looted and illegally exported from Bubon in the 1960s, let alone that it originated from Bubon in the first place.”

“DANY’s claim of origin rests on inconsistent and incomplete historical records, unreliable testimony from a single witness about an event that happened over fifty years ago, and highly suggestive photo arrays and sequences of various bronze statues shown to that single witness,” the filing said.

According to the court papers, in January, New York investigators sent Mendelsohn a request for documents and correspondence relating to the statue and summoned him by subpoena to appear before a grand jury in New York. He did not accept the subpoena and instead had his lawyers contact investigators.

In moving to seize items held by institutions or collections outside of New York, the Manhattan district attorney’s office has argued that it has jurisdiction because the items had passed through, or been sold in, New York.

Out-of-state museums like the J. Paul Getty in Los Angeles and the Carnegie Museums in Pittsburgh have given up items voluntarily after the investigators presented evidence that they were stolen property that had passed through New York.

Mendelsohn’s lawyers noted that the bronze statue had been in their client’s possession in California for 17 years, but “the statute of limitations for criminal possession of stolen property under New York penal law is five years,” meaning the opportunity for prosecution has expired. They asked the court to declare Mendelsohn the rightful owner of the statue.

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.










Today's News

September 5, 2024

The Nohra Haime Gallery opens an exhibition of Pedro Ruiz' latest work

The 1790-1795 ship's log kept by Peter Rainier will headline Grant Zahajko's auction

'Gold from Dragon City: Masterpieces of Three Yan from Liaoning, 337-436' opens at the China Institute Gallery

Antique Gold Rush-era denim jeans and rare U.S. gold coins dominate the list of top lots at Holabird sale

Desperate bid to save JFK shown in resurfaced film

Asia Week New York and noted author Becky MacGuire zoom-in on Four Centuries of Blue & White, Wednesday, September 11

The Morgan Library & Museum presents: 'Belle da Costa Greene: A Librarian's Legacy'

Las Vegas places a bet on a new art museum, with help from LA

Alvin Ailey, the man and the mind behind the unapologetic sparkle

Gagosian to present Titus Kaphar exhibition in Beverly Hills

Bellevue Arts Museum announces closure

Edra Soto unveils her latest monument to Puerto Rico at Central Park

The Walters announces details for its first dedicated Latin American Art Galleries, opening May 2025

The Black List helped reshape Hollywood. Can it change publishing?

Internet Archive loses court appeal in fight over online lending library

Harry Styles' favorite designer returns

Surprise! A class of college seniors learns their tuition will be free.

'The Notebook' will end its Broadway run in December. A tour is next.

What if orchestras were more like Netflix?

V&A announces new exhibitions for 2025 spanning Cartier to Marie Antoinette, and design and disability to ancient Egypt

Tarnanthi Art Fair returns as online event in 2024

The truth about Patti LuPone and Mia Farrow

Collector sues to block investigators from seizing Roman bronze

Why GBWhatsApp is the Best WhatsApp Alternative

Reviving the Classics: Why Second-Hand Pianos Are Becoming the Instrument of Choice

Unleashing Your Inner Musician: How a Pre-Owned Piano and Expert Guidance Can Spark Your Passion

The Timeless Legacy of Ancient Masks: Unlocking the Mysteries of Mesoamerican and Andean Civilizations




Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 



Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez
Writer: Ofelia Zurbia Betancourt

Attorneys
Truck Accident Attorneys
Accident Attorneys
Holistic Dentist
Abogado de accidentes
สล็อต
สล็อตเว็บตรง

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org juncodelavega.com facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site Parroquia Natividad del Señor
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful