When songs sound similar, courts look for musical DNA
The First Art Newspaper on the Net    Established in 1996 Friday, November 22, 2024


When songs sound similar, courts look for musical DNA
Dua Lipa performs at Madison Square Garden in New York, March 1, 2022. The chord progressions in Ed Sheeran’s “Thinking Out Loud” and Marvin Gaye’s “Let’s Get It On” are part of a debate about just how much of a piece of music can be protected by law. (The New York Times)

by Ben Sisario



NEW YORK, NY.- On the surface, Ed Sheeran and Led Zeppelin might not seem to have a lot in common. Sheeran is a baby-faced singer-songwriter whose hummable ballads like “Perfect” and “Photograph” have become streaming-era pop standards. Led Zeppelin is a classic-rock colossus whose molten riffs are part of the foundation of heavy metal.

Yet when it comes to the recent history of copyright litigation in music, Sheeran and Led Zeppelin are practically joined at the hip. Both have been accused of copying other artists’ work in ways that are at the center of an evolving debate over just how much — or how little — of a piece of music can be protected by law.

Next month, Sheeran is scheduled to begin a long-delayed trial in federal court in New York over his song “Thinking Out Loud,” which the plaintiffs say copied elements of Marvin Gaye’s soul classic “Let’s Get It On.” (The litigation’s history is complex, involving three separate cases filed on behalf of owners of the rights of Ed Townsend, Gaye’s co-writer, who died in 2003.)

In some ways, “Thinking Out Loud” bears an obvious resemblance to “Let’s Get It On.” They share nearly identical chord progressions and similar bass lines. Aspects of the instrumental tracks on both recordings, like the tempo and drum sound, are close enough that when one YouTuber stitched the two songs together, it was hard to tell where one ended and the other began. (In this case, performance elements in the recordings are irrelevant; the suit involves only the underlying compositions.)

But are they close enough that Sheeran should be liable for copyright infringement? Or is their overlap limited to fundamental musical building blocks that are part of the public domain?

Courts have been hashing out these very questions in recent cases involving Robin Thicke, Katy Perry, the Weeknd and Dua Lipa — as well as Led Zeppelin, whose victory over an infringement claim against “Stairway to Heaven” could give Sheeran an edge. A detailed appeals court ruling in favor of “Stairway” addressed the knotty issue of what counts as infringement when two pieces of music are based on commonplace elements like scales, melodic fragments or simple chord progressions.

“All of these cases are about the question of how similar is too similar,” said Joseph P. Fishman, a professor at Vanderbilt Law School in Nashville, Tennessee. “The Copyright Act that Congress passed says nothing whatsoever about that question. In the U.S. copyright system, the rules for how that question gets answered are entirely developed by federal judges.”

Copyright suits are a standard hazard for successful pop musicians; they may be inevitable in an art form that relies so deeply on the influence of past works.

In fact, one go-to strategy for defendants is to point to “prior art” — examples from music history, the more distant the better, showing that a given melody or pattern has such deep roots that it may be public domain (or at least is not the exclusive property of a plaintiff). At trial, Led Zeppelin’s lawyers cited a 17th-century guitar sonata that, at one spot, sounds an awful lot like “Stairway to Heaven.”




The elephant in the room for all these cases is “Blurred Lines.” In 2015, a jury decided that the song by Thicke and Pharrell Williams infringed on the copyright of another Gaye classic, “Got to Give It Up,” and Gaye’s heirs were awarded more than $5 million in damages.

That result alarmed many in the music industry who thought the case involved basic genre elements that had long been considered fair game. In the wake of the verdict, lawyers reported an uptick in new claims.

The Led Zeppelin appeal, issued in 2020, sent the pendulum back in the other direction. The similarities between “Stairway to Heaven” and the song that challenged it, “Taurus” by Spirit — a band Led Zeppelin occasionally shared stages with in its early days — came down to an arpeggiated chord progression and a bass line that descended along a chromatic scale.

Elements like those, appeals court judges said, were so commonplace that they deserved only a so-called thin copyright. In that case, two works must be “virtually identical” for one to infringe the other, the judges said.

A week after that ruling was issued, it was cited by a judge who vacated a jury’s verdict that Perry’s hit “Dark Horse” had copied elements of a Christian rap song — a case that came down to a sequence of eight notes.

Peter J. Anderson, a lawyer who represented Led Zeppelin at the “Stairway” trial and appeal, called the appeals court’s decision an important clarification.

“These are basic concepts that you need to make music,” Anderson said. “You need to be able to put three or four notes together, and there are only seven notes in the scale.”

Even so, the results can be unpredictable because the facts of each case differ and a great deal of what a jury hears is decided by a judge.

Will the Led Zeppelin ruling help Sheeran? A handful of intellectual property lawyers polled for this article said the answer should be a resounding yes — though they hastened to add that jury trials could be unpredictable.

The judge in that case has already narrowed much of the evidence that can be presented to a jury. Gone is the bass, which does not appear in the sheet music “deposit copy” that established the copyright for “Let’s Get It On” in 1973. And in a pretrial ruling, the judge said the plaintiffs’ expert musicologist could not testify that the song’s chord progression or “harmonic rhythm” were unique or distinctive. There is uncontested proof, he determined, that those elements are common musical techniques.

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.










Today's News

March 4, 2023

Wangechi Mutu: An imagined world made possible

For an artist, the Morgan is subject, object and venue

The power of art in a political age

Why Warhol images are making museums nervous

Wayne Shorter, innovator during an era of change in jazz, dies at 89

Galerie56 opens an exhibition of drawings by Gaetano Pesce

Mark Manders, 'Writing Skiapod' opens at Tanya Bonakdar Gallery, Los Angeles

If big brands copied their work, what are artists to do?

'Pierre Dunoyer: The 1980s' on view at the Nohra Haime Gallery

The magic of Man Ray at Bonhams surrealist sale in Paris

Chrysler Museum of Art opens exhibition on Tlingit Culture

University of Michigan Museum of Art announces new acquisitions of various new artists

When songs sound similar, courts look for musical DNA

Danziger Gallery exhibits photographs by Arne Svenson

The minimalist composer who keeps getting left out

Review: Ohad Naharin is more than the sum of his imitators

'Funny Girl,' Starring Lea Michele, to close Labor Day Weekend

'I don't take a single second for granted': Asian and Asian American nominees on the Oscars

Heritage Auctions offers elite single-owner collection of top wines from world's best growing regions

Wayne Shorter, a jazz hero whose goal was 'to fear nothing'

Everything Everywhere All at auction

The Intersections of Art and Computer Coding

Subway Surfers MOD APK v3.8.2 (Unlimited Money/Keys)

Klaiyi Human Hair Wigs

An Art Essay: Exploring the Artistic Style of French Surrealism

What steps should the lessee take when a leased vehicle is involved in an accident?

Top 4 Reasons to Hire a Family Lawyer

Here's why you need to engage an arbitration agreement attorney

Some Tips for You to Learn Forex Trading

Vegas-x Casino: Top-Notch Sweepstakes Platform

Internet Cafe Sweepstakes Games Online: Why You Need to Play Them

Top 3 Skillmine Slots You Must Give a Try!




Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 



Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez
Writer: Ofelia Zurbia Betancourt

Attorneys
Truck Accident Attorneys
Accident Attorneys
Holistic Dentist
Abogado de accidentes
สล็อต
สล็อตเว็บตรง

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org juncodelavega.com facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site Parroquia Natividad del Señor
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful