NEW YORK, NY.- In 2016, reviewing the film A Man Called Ove for this newspaper, I mused, Swedens official entry for a best foreign-language film at the Academy Awards proves that Swedish pictures can be just as sentimental and conventionally heartwarming as Hollywood ones.
That movie, based on a bestselling Swedish novel, is about a thoroughgoing grump who becomes suicidal after the death of his wife, until interactions with new neighbors soften his heart. One supposes an American remake was inevitable, and here it is, directed by Marc Forster and starring Tom Hanks, with the main character renamed Otto.
Usually, U.S. remakes of foreign films tend to homogenize the source material. But A Man Called Otto is not only more bloated than the Swedish film; its more outré, in a way thats hard to pin down.
Forster handles the flashback of the backstory (in which the stars son, Truman Hanks, plays a younger Otto) in gauzy-arty fashion. When the older Otto Hanks reaches back to his excellent work in Catch Me If You Can to nail down the mans overarching irritability contemplates his happy marriage, his mind always goes back to its earliest times. Its curious, until the film reveals why it has avoided more recent memories, but by then, the omission feels like a withholding cheat.
Otherwise, obviousness rules the day here. When Otto visits an incapacitated former friend, the soundtrack spins Kenny Dorhams version of the jazz chestnut Old Folks which is always nice to hear, admittedly. Later, a teenager initially upbraided by Otto tells him that Ottos wife, who had been a schoolteacher, was the only person who didnt treat me like a freak, because Im transgender. As the television icon Marcia Brady once put it, Oh, my nose!
A Man Called Otto
Rated PG-13 for themes and language. Running time: 2 hours, 6 minutes. In theaters.
This article originally appeared in
The New York Times.