NEW YORK, NY.- A mystery wends through Close Your Eyes, a drama in which the past, present and cinema converge. Its the latest from Spanish director Victor Erice, whos best known for the art-cinema paragon The Spirit of the Beehive (1973), a dream of a movie about a girl who is deeply troubled by the original Frankenstein film. Set around 1940 in the aftermath of the Spanish Civil War, Beehive elliptically focuses on a traumatized child and country that, when Erice made this classic, was in the waning years of Francos fascist dictatorship.
Close Your Eyes is the fourth feature-length movie from Erice, who, its worth noting, was born in 1940; its also his first since Dream of Light (1992). The story in Close Your Eyes turns on Miguel (Manolo Solo), a melancholic filmmaker who hasnt directed a movie in several decades and now scratches out a marginal living as a translator. Miguels last film, The Farewell Gaze, came to an aborted, ignoble finish when his lead actor, Julio (José Coronado), enigmatically disappeared. Without his star, Miguel was unable to finish the movie, which brought his film career to an end and, effectively, caused him to vanish as well.
The repressed have a way of returning, as it were. And so it is in Close Your Eyes, which follows Miguel as he confronts his old life, his unfinished film and his absent actor, all of whom come back to some kind of attenuated life courtesy of a TV program, Unsolved Cases. Miguel agrees to participate in the show, which will revisit his movies puzzling history. He sits down for an interview and lets the program present some of the few sequences that he managed to salvage; soon enough, he also tries to find out what happened to Julio, an inquiry that begins practically enough, though it gradually accrues destabilizing existential weight.
Written by Erice and Michel Gaztambide, Close Your Eyes quickly takes the shape of an investigation, one riddled with doubles, cinematic and otherwise. Much like Julios character in the unfinished film a long, chatty section from it opens the movie Miguel assumes the role of a detective whos charged with finding a missing person and even begins wearing the trench coat that Julio wore in the film. These two former compatriots once shared an artistic calling and other interests, including an ex-lover. As the main story unfolds, Miguels exploration of the past reveals as much about the investigator as the investigated, and the men progressively seem like doppelgängers. Each has been lost; each will be also be found.
Erice extends this doubling motif to the intimate one-on-one conversations that anchor Close My Eyes, and which incrementally, and at times almost begrudgingly, propel Miguels story forward. Erice tends to shoot the conversations in the earlier part of the movie as face-to-face encounters, with Miguel an earnest, worried-looking soul seated directly opposite another equally serious character. Later in the movie, after Miguel meets a stranger called Gardel (also played by Coronado), who helps solve the case of the missing actor, Erice often frames the two men side-by-side, as if twinning them. This visual shift underscores their connections without commensurately deepening either character or the overall movie.
The double that most conspicuously haunts Close Your Eyes is The Spirit of the Beehive, which is as gravely beautiful as it is narratively elliptical. Largely told from the point of view of its young protagonist, Ana played by Ana Torrent, a somber wonder child who appears in the new movie as Julios adult daughter Beehive is filled with quotidian and beguilingly cryptic scenes that build a feeling of dread into every lapidary shot. Amplifying this sense of danger is the films fascist backdrop, which seems partly incarnated by Frankensteins monster. This pitiful creature haunts Beehive and Ana, yet its also an emblem of cinema that fascinates her, so much that her sister explains how to summon it: Close your eyes.
The new movies narrative ellipses, by contrast, are frustrating rather than illuminating, and the whole enterprise lacks the political urgency that helps give Beehive its frisson. Close Your Eyes has its virtues, certainly, including some pleasurably loose interludes at the beachfront compound where Miguel lives. These have a delicate, unforced quality that creates pinpricks of light in a movie that, as it struggles to engage meaningfully with the past, sinks into ponderousness. Like Miguel, Erice has undertaken a search for meaning by returning to the past, its dreams and movies. With Close Your Eyes, he has also returned to The Spirit of the Beehive, a film that seems to have haunted him as much as it does those of us who love it.
Close Your Eyes: Not rated. In Spanish, with subtitles. Running time: 2 hours 49 minutes. In theaters.
This article originally appeared in
The New York Times.