A 500-year-old chapel, 438 solar panels and an architectural squabble
The First Art Newspaper on the Net    Established in 1996 Thursday, November 7, 2024


A 500-year-old chapel, 438 solar panels and an architectural squabble
A visitor takes photos inside King's College Chapel, whose fan vault was carved between 1512 and 1515 and is the world’s largest, in Cambridge, England, March 14, 2024. King’s College Chapel is one of several British landmarks that have installed solar panels, gratifying climate campaigners and ruffling feathers among some traditionalists. (Hannah Reyes Morales/The New York Times)

by Mark Landler



CAMBRIDGE.- Clambering across the sloped roof of King’s College Chapel with the agility of an undergraduate, Toby Lucas, 56, pointed to where his craftspeople had welded solar panels to an expanse of newly installed lead. It was the scariest part of the project, he said, because an errant spark could have ignited the 500-year-old timbers underneath, which hold up the roof of this English Gothic masterpiece.

“It’s an iconic landmark in Cambridge, and it’s part and parcel of where I live,” said Lucas, whose firm, Barnes Construction, did the restoration. “You don’t want to be the person who is responsible for burning part of it down.”

The chapel came through the project unscorched and now stands at the heart of Cambridge University, no longer just a glorious relic of the late-medieval period but also a cutting-edge symbol of the green-energy future. Its 438 photovoltaic panels, along with solar panels on two nearby buildings, will supply a shade more than 5% of the college’s electricity.

King’s College Chapel is one of several landmark houses of worship in England that have installed solar panels in recent years. The cathedrals in Salisbury and Gloucester have them, and this project may open the door to more: A neighboring Cambridge college, Trinity, is contemplating whether to put photovoltaic panels on the roof of its chapel, which dates to the 16th century.

But this being a college town, and King’s College Chapel being such a nonpareil work of architecture, the debate over installing panels was long and lively — a heady mix of aesthetics, economics and politics. Even now, with the scaffolding dismantled and the panels beginning to soak up the late-winter sunlight, critics are eager to point out why the project was a mistake.

“You have this extraordinary openwork parapet, which is a really bold feature,” said John Neale, gesturing toward the top of the chapel, where a crenelated wall runs along the north and south sides. “You can see through the parapet.”

“Now what you can see through the parapet, and indeed above it, depending on where you’re looking from, is a reflective layer of solar panels,” said Neale, director of development advice at Historic England, a preservation group. “That will be radically at odds with the historical character of the building.”

In truth, the solar panels are scarcely visible from ground level, although they are more noticeable from a distance. But Neale noted that they change color depending on the weather, as light plays off them. Although the effect is muted during the frequently overcast winter, it could become more conspicuous in the summer, with clouds scudding across a blue sky.

Neale was at pains to say that he does not, on principle, oppose retrofitting old buildings with new features. He pointed to a nearby cafe in the nave of St. Michael’s Church as a worthy example of converting an old building into new uses. Historic England, he said, has endorsed panels on other churches.

But “on the whole, you shouldn’t put panels on prominent roofs,” Neale said. Far from setting a precedent, “this actually is the outer limit, and we think has crossed a line that shouldn’t have been crossed.”

Other critics argued that the relatively small percentage of electricity generated did not justify the aesthetic cost. In a hint of a culture war, some suggested the solar panels were the kind of politically correct gesture typical of a progressive institution such as King’s College, whose graduates include economist John Maynard Keynes, World War II code breaker Alan Turing and novelist Zadie Smith.

“There are many ways to address fears about rising temperatures,” David Abulafia, an emeritus professor of history at Cambridge, wrote in the right-leaning Spectator magazine last year, as Cambridge City Council weighed whether to approve the project. Installing solar panels, he added, was “quite simply, another example of virtue-signaling.”

Asked how he viewed the panels now that they were in place, Abulafia kept his sword sheathed. “It’s happened now!” he said.

The leaders of King’s College were aware of these critiques when they considered installing panels, along with a new lead roof. The dean of King’s College Chapel, the Rev. Stephen Cherry, said he was initially skeptical of the idea, which came up during a planning meeting several years ago.

“We needed to think very carefully about the visual impact and the amount of energy generation we would achieve,” he said. “I was very concerned that we would be tempted to make an empty symbolic gesture.”

A study concluded that the photovoltaic panels would generate an estimated 123,000 kilowatt-hours of energy per year. That is enough to reduce the college’s carbon emissions by more than 23 tons each year, which is the equivalent of planting 1,090 trees. The college’s nearby Wilkins Building and Old Garden Hostel have panels, but no other surface offered that kind of opportunity.

As for the visual impact, Cherry said it was mitigated by the fact that the panels virtually covered the roof, which at least made it consistent. Although the polished sheen of the panels was a change from the textured gray of the lead, both were utilitarian rather than decorative features, he argued.

“Nobody has said, ‘Goodness me, that’s quite an eyesore,’” Cherry said.

Among the students, he said, the project has been popular, perhaps even giving the chapel a currency it has not had at King’s College for years. With its magnificent fan vault — carved between 1512 and 1515 and the world’s largest — the chapel almost stands apart from King’s College, a tourist attraction that draws visitors who barely linger to look at the manicured frontcourt or the dining hall.

“It’s not so much signaling virtue as signaling a clarion call for change,” Gillian Tett, provost of King’s College and a columnist for The Financial Times, told The Guardian in November. “Yes, it’s a symbol, but symbols reinforce what’s normal, and we’re trying to change what’s thought of as normal.”

For Lucas, who has restored several old buildings in Cambridge, it was an engineering challenge and a labor of love. To reduce the risk of fire, he used thermal imaging every evening to make sure his workers did not leave behind hot spots. In laying the frame, they had to compensate for a barely perceptible sag in the middle of the 289-foot-long roof.

After months on the roof, Lucas became a student of its ways. He pointed out peregrines that alight on the chapel’s four corner towers to hunt. He noted how over centuries, visitors carved their initials in the stone wall along the spiral stairs leading to the roof. “Helen 2009,” reads a recent inscription.

Given that the chapel has stood for a half-millennium — the product of a 70-year construction project under four kings: Henry VI, VII and VIII, plus Richard III — the furor over the solar panels will end up being at most a transitory distraction.

“The new roof should last 100 years,” Lucas said. “The life span of these panels is 25 to 30 years. They can always take them off.”

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.










Today's News

April 1, 2024

A 500-year-old chapel, 438 solar panels and an architectural squabble

Denver Art Museum announces 2023 acquisitions

The eclipse was so nice, they're doing it twice

Weird and wonderful Martin Brothers pottery leads Heritage's Art Nouveau, Art Deco & Art Glass event

National Galleries of Scotland acquires first ever Remedios Varo oil painting to enter a European collection

As graffiti moves from eyesore to amenity, landlords try to cash in

Lincoln, Trotsky, Einstein, and more are among April Fine Autographs and Artifacts Auction

Legendary: The Collection of Torben V. Kristiansen comes to market at Heffel

Shahar Molcho appointed as the new curator of contemporary art at the Tel Aviv Museum of Art

Tate Britain unveils Viva Voce, a new film installation by Keith Piper

The Knoxville Museum of Art acquires two Yigal Ozeri Photorealist artworks

The team effort behind one of classical music's greatest hits

Rare, newly discovered eyewitness sketch of Continental Army sheds new light on wartime life

Bluerider ART kicks off 2024 programme, expanding its artistic footprint with its new Mayfair gallery in London

Original artwork, inscribed first editions and more from Edgar Rice Burroughs' collection debut at Heritage in April

Ewan McGregor and Mary Elizabeth Winstead go from 'Fargo' to 'Moscow'

Chance Perdomo, star of 'Chilling Adventures of Sabrina,' dies at 27

Logan Lerman honors two families in 'We Were the Lucky Ones'

Police raid Peruvian president's home, looking for Rolex watches

How long does New York take to fix a staircase? 10 years and counting.

Los Angeles County Museum acquires work by Veronika Kellndorfer

Rothschild Fine Art Gallery moves to new space in South Tel Aviv

A Secondary Eye to open new gallery in Sydney

5 Upcoming Arabic TV Shows Expected on Netflix in 2024 with Multilanguage Translation Support

Shipping Insurance: Ensuring Safe Delivery of Your Valuable Goods




Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 



Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez
Writer: Ofelia Zurbia Betancourt

Attorneys
Truck Accident Attorneys
Accident Attorneys
Holistic Dentist
Abogado de accidentes
สล็อต
สล็อตเว็บตรง

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org juncodelavega.com facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site Parroquia Natividad del Señor
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful