Kim Kardashian is sued for saying her tables are authentic Donald Judds

The First Art Newspaper on the Net    Established in 1996 Saturday, April 27, 2024


Kim Kardashian is sued for saying her tables are authentic Donald Judds
Kim Kardashian wearing the Swarovski x Skims body jewelry over two Jelly Sheer pieces from the collaboration in Calabasas, Calif., in October 2023. (Shaniqwa Jarvis/The New York Times)

by Zachary Small



NEW YORK, NY.- In a video where Kim Kardashian tours the offices of her Skkn by Kim company, she points out the glam rooms, theater and kitchen of her sprawling 40,000-square-foot space, all drenched in several rosy hues of beige.

It is sparsely furnished, in keeping with what Kardashian has described as her love for the calming influence of minimalist design.

Even the furniture tends to be minimalist chic.

“These Donald Judd tables are really amazing,” Kardashian says, speaking of an artist widely celebrated for his genius with simple forms, “and totally blend in with the seats.”

Except that the dining set is not by Donald Judd, according to the nonprofit foundation that represents his legacy. It sued the celebrity on Wednesday, accusing her of making false claims.

Also named in the lawsuit was Clements Design, which the court papers say produced the tables and chairs that resemble those designed by Judd. The foundation is accusing the company of trademark and copyright infringement.

“Consumers are likely to believe Judd Foundation and the Donald Judd brand are connected or affiliated with, or otherwise sponsored or endorsed Ms. Kardashian,” said the lawsuit, filed in U.S. District Court for the Central District of California. “Judd Foundation categorically prohibits customers from using purchased Donald Judd furniture for marketing and promotional purposes.”

Kardashian declined to comment Wednesday, but Clements Design released a statement saying there were “obvious key differences” between the furnishings and that the company felt “blindsided” by the lawsuit since there had been efforts “made to resolve this issue amicably.” The design company said the Judd Foundation “was unwilling to settle on reasonable terms. These claims have absolutely no merit.”

The dispute began in 2022, when Kardashian put out a video on YouTube that has since received more than 3.6 million views. Partway through the video, she pauses in the kitchen of her California office, where there are tables and chairs that evoke two Judd designs: La Mansana Table 22 and Chair 84. (The video was taken down Wednesday after the lawsuit was filed.)

The Judd furniture (the table costs $90,000 and only three authentic copies have been sold in the last 15 years) are part of how the foundation earns money, a representative for the foundation said. The chairs cost $9,000 each. More than 350 chairs have been sold, according to the foundation, which stamps and numbers each one.

“The furniture is integral to our financial stability,” said Rainer Judd, the artist’s daughter and the president of his foundation, who added that revenue from the designs accounted for nearly half of the organization’s earned income.

Three days after the video first appeared, the Judd Foundation says, it contacted Kardashian about the furniture. A spokesperson responded to the complaint, according to the lawsuit, saying they were “incredibly sorry for any inconvenience this has caused the foundation” and offering to “update the video caption with a retraction.”

But the Judd Foundation wanted the video deleted, the furniture “recycled” (i.e. destroyed) and Kardashian to issue a public statement.

Representatives for Kardashian countered with an offer to make a social media post in which she supported the foundation, the foundation said in court papers.

Ultimately the negotiations broke down, and the dispute is headed to court.

Clements Design, based in West Hollywood, helped design the Kardashian office in Los Angeles. It has argued that its furniture differed materially from the artist’s creations.

“It is simply not true that Clements Design commissioned imitation Donald Judd tables,” the lawyer, John Ulin, wrote to the foundation, adding that the wood type and overall proportions were different. “They are different tables with different designs.”

In its statement Wednesday, Clement said the company believed the issue had been already settled. “The Judd Foundation’s prior counsel acknowledged these differences and since then, we have not heard from them in over a year,” the statement said.

But the foundation pointed to an invoice from Clements Design in which it described the furniture as “in the style of Donald Judd” and included an image owned by the Judd Foundation of the authentic dining set.

“It is lower quality than Donald Judd’s furniture,” said Megan Bannigan, a lawyer representing the foundation. “We don’t want to be mixed up with Kim Kardashian. We respect what she does, but we don’t want to be involved with this.”

Before dying in 1994, Judd fiercely protected the authenticity of his creations. In 1990, he criticized Giuseppe Panza, an Italian art collector who created some sculptures based on the artist’s drawings, but without his direct involvement in some cases. Writing after the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum acquired the works, Judd said the collector had botched his designs with inferior materials.

“Panza doesn’t care,” he wrote. “What I require is too expensive. Consequently, Panza makes mock-ups, fakes.”

(Panza defended the sculptures as authentic and said Judd had agreed to his plan. The Guggenheim, which has used the dispute to study and discuss the parameters of authorship, identifies the sculptures Judd complained about as contested Judds.)

Rainer Judd said the Kardashian case is not too much ado about tables. “We are just doing our job to protect Donald Judd’s work,” she said. “Not every artist foundation has the time or resources to do that.”

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.










Today's News

March 29, 2024

The Impressionists' first flowering is still fresh after 150 years

The Broad Museum, a Los Angeles favorite, is expanding

Ty Cobb's rare 1909-11 'Smoking Tobacco' T206 sells for $432,000 at Heritage Auctions

For Richard Serra, art was not something. It was everything.

Kim Kardashian is sued for saying her tables are authentic Donald Judds

1969 Chappellet brings $64,575 at Heritage, leads wine auction past $2.4 million

Important painting by George Frederic Watts acquired for the nation and allocated to Watts Gallery

Nara Roesler announces the representation of Alberto Pitta

Craig Starr Gallery presents paintings and collages from 1950-66 by Ray Johnson

The Frick Collection reveals plans for new collection galleries on second floor of original residence

Inaugural Sam Gilliam Award winner announced by DIA and the Sam Gilliam Foundatiom

New exhibition examines traditional and innovative designs by Amish women quilters

Exhibition of new paintings by Martha Tuttle opens at Peter Blum Gallery

Holabird announces Wild West Relics Auction, April 6-7 and 13-14

After 25 years, a singer is the 'Heart and Soul' of the Met

Memories of a friendship with Prunella Clough come to auction

Pace opens Josef Koudelka's first solo show in New York in nearly a decade

Rebecca Hall redefines stardom

Kate Banks, children's author who wrote about grief, dies at 64

Overlooked no more: Henrietta Leavitt, who unraveled mysteries of the stars

Treasures from Planet Hollywood bring more than $15.6 million in historic event at Heritage Auctions

Review: A new dance at Trisha Brown examines the act of a fall

It's a statue of Prince Philip. Really. But now it has to go.

Rare early Maud Lewis paintings sell for $87,400 -far above estimate range

DIY Wig Styling Hacks You Need to Know

Epic Gaming Journeys: From Ancient European Casinos to Modern Asian Resorts

Become Gambler - The Best Online Casinos and Welcome Bonuses

Beyond Borrowing: The FinBro Loan Experience - Your Pathway to Financial Freedom




Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 



Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez

sa gaming free credit
Attorneys
Truck Accident Attorneys
Accident Attorneys

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org juncodelavega.com facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site Parroquia Natividad del Señor
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful