NEW YORK, NY.- Anthony Braxtons music is inherently theatrical. Its also serious, and hilariously entertaining.
It is not, however, performed with a frequency that befits Braxtons stature, in a glaring, countrywide omission. More on that in a bit, but first: When seasoned practitioners of his work gather to explore some of his most overlooked pieces, which happened this past week at the Brick Theater in Brooklyn, that should qualify as a major event.
On Thursday night at the Brick, the scrappy Experiments in Opera company pulled off a delirious debut performance of what its calling Anthony Braxton Theater Improvisations. The one-hour show proved delightful; and the small, cozy venue was rightfully sold out. The run continued through Saturday.
Those who didnt make it can still dig into this side of Braxtons music, thanks to how doggedly he documents his projects. The Experiments in Opera show deserved attention, and perhaps documentation, given the way it provided a new lens on a corner of Braxtons more conceptual side.
The evening was based on Opuses 279-283 in Braxtons catalog: comedic efforts written for a narrator and an improvising instrumentalist. In 2000, Braxton playing a range of saxophones and clarinets recorded several of these works with a young stand-up comedian, Alex Horwitz.
In Composition No. 282, that narrator is called upon to read the days newspaper (with an option to crumple it for timbral effect), while the instrumentalist improvises. In No. 281, beboplike phrases run underneath one-liners and observational humor.
But with just two people, the recordings charm sometimes peters out. The Experiments in Opera show maintains higher energy, and brings three artists to each performance: a narrator-actor (Rob Reese, who also directed); another scene partner and soprano (Kamala Sankaram, a veteran of Braxton opera recordings); and an instrumentalist (on Thursday, trumpeter Nate Wooley, who participated memorably in some larger Braxton ensembles during the 2010s).
Before the show, saxophonist James Fei, who performed on Fridays set, told me that Composition No. 279 is essentially a compendium of jokes. That piece didnt make the cut in Braxtons recording with Horwitz from 2000, but it was featured in the Experiments in Opera show.
Holding a top hat, Reese paced among the audience members and asked some of them to pick a card from inside it. A card might carry one of Braxtons language music organizational prompts (such as intervallic formings), paired with a genre of joke from Composition No. 279 (such as Republican/Democrat jokes.)
While Wooley and Sankaram worked with strident, leaping intervals, Reese delivered a joke that tended toward the school of one-liner king Henny Youngman (to whom Braxton dedicated Composition 282). I roughly transcribed one of the jokes this way: Why are Democrats always in favor of gun control? Because they keep shooting themselves in the foot.
On the page, this may not seem like much. But set against a duet of wildly leaping figures, it all produced a dazzling novelty that also reinvigorated a vintage form; the borscht belt never sounded so endearingly strange.
Reese, who collaborated with Sankaram on her imaginative opera Miranda, also improvised some scenic work at the front of the stage with her. Some of their material was less obviously connected to the Braxton compositions as previously recorded but felt in the right spirit as did Wooleys improvisations away from his horn. In the background of one scene between Reese and Sankaram, the trumpeter sat against the brick wall at the stages rear. While lit with the penumbra of a spotlight aimed elsewhere, he coolly mimed the smoking of a cigarette with a kazoo.
And since Braxton has written that all compositions in my music system can be executed at the same time/moment, the troupe reveled in that possibility. At one point, Wooley relished the languid, bop-tinged opening theme of Composition No. 23D, originally recorded on the album New York, Fall 1974.
Then Sankaram swung into one of the meatier passages written for her in Braxtons Composition No. 380 the opera Trillium J, which was recorded and performed in 2014 at Roulette in Brooklyn. In one scene, Sankaram plays the role of Miss Scarlet, a helpless maiden who happens to own 400 nuclear weapons stockpile containers not to mention the chemical gas warfare options.
Coloratura singing, written for those lines? Thats funny. In the full opera which is available on Blu-ray and as a paid download on Vimeo the moment of humor that Sankaram really sells can whiz by amid all the orchestral complexity. But it had new verve when she brought it back around in the improvisational maelstrom of Thursdays more intimate set.
All of this spoke to the unexplored potential of Braxtons oeuvre. His catalog of over a half-centurys compositions and his playing on reed instruments are both rightfully talked about with awe, as is his record as a mentor. Wave after wave of celebrated player-composers, including George E. Lewis and Mary Halvorson, have cut their professional teeth in his ensembles. Aaron Siegel, executive director of Experiments in Opera, has also served as a percussionist in those groups. In opening remarks Thursday, he credited Braxton as one of his companys original mentors.
Braxton has won a Guggenheim Fellowship and a MacArthur Foundation grant, and an NEA Jazz Masters award. If you talk to leaders of forward-thinking orchestras and opera companies, youll often hear (off the record) about their desire to program Braxtons ambitious pieces the ones that carry traces of bebop and Karlheinz Stockhausen, of Hildegard von Bingen and American folk dances.
But its evidently difficult to make happen. When Pulitzer Prize-winning composer David Lang was young and working with the New York Philharmonic, he tried pushing Braxtons orchestral music on his superiors. No dice. Perhaps thats because Braxton asks players to improvise as well as pay attention to complex notated material.
So, for now, we have to rely on smaller organizations such as Experiments in Opera to find the right balance and bring Braxtonia to life properly. And this past week, they nailed it.
This article originally appeared in
The New York Times.