How a murderous poet inspired one of Dostoevsky's masterworks
The First Art Newspaper on the Net    Established in 1996 Thursday, November 14, 2024


How a murderous poet inspired one of Dostoevsky's masterworks
'The Sinner and the Saint: Dostoevsky and the Gentleman Murderer Who Inspired a Masterpiece' by Kevin Birmingham. 416 pages. Penguin Press. $30.

by Jennifer Szalai



NEW YORK, NY.- The truth about Fyodor Dostoyevsky has proved to be as mysterious and inexhaustible as the enigmatic figures he wrote about, drawing the attention of novelists (Leonid Tsypkin, J.M. Coetzee) and any number of biographers (Joseph Frank, Leonid Grossman). In “Dostoevsky in Love,” published this year, Alex Christofi combined genres, plucking lines from Dostoyevsky’s fiction and training them across a trellis of biographical fact.

The endless revisitation suggests something that Dostoyevsky himself may have appreciated. As Oliver Ready observes in the introduction to his superb translation of “Crime and Punishment,” knowing the facts is not the same as knowing the person — a notion that happens to align with Dostoyevsky’s own objections to the fixation on “mere data.”

So Kevin Birmingham has set out to offer something more interpretive and immersive in “The Sinner and the Saint.” Birmingham is the author of “The Most Dangerous Book” (2014), which told the story behind James Joyce’s “Ulysses”; his new book tells the story behind “Crime and Punishment,” another work of literary innovation, whose publication marked a turning point for both Dostoyevsky and the history of the novel.

“He was entering the greatest phase of his career,” Birmingham writes, a period that would include “The Idiot,” “Demons” and “The Brothers Karamazov.” He was also finding a new way of writing about self-consciousness and self-deception, by producing not a novel of ideas but what Birmingham calls “a novel about the trouble with ideas” — exploring their enormous power but also their pathetic inadequacy, how the most pristine concepts run aground on the stubborn intransigence of the world.

The distinction is essential. As Birmingham shows, Dostoyevsky wasn’t the schematic storyteller his critics make him out to be, mapping out some grand ideologies and then deducing the details. He usually started from bits of conversation, a person’s voice, a memorable image. (“Crime and Punishment,” which he initially proposed as a 90-page story that would take him only two weeks to complete, soon sprawled far beyond that plan.) Part of Birmingham’s intention is to give proper due to the inspiration provided to the novel by the 1835 trial of “poet-murderer” Pierre-François Lacenaire, which Dostoyevsky learned about in 1861, when he and his brother were looking for material for their new literary magazine.

Lacenaire was a strange combination of haughty and dissolute — someone who read Rousseau’s “Social Contract” while waiting on an apartment landing for one of his victims. After robbing and killing two people, including an old widow lying in her sickbed, he and his accomplice took their meager spoils to treat themselves to dinner and then a comedy show.

“That was a great day for me,” Lacenaire later reminisced. “I breathed again.”

Raskolnikov of “Crime and Punishment” is no Lacenaire. Yes, he commits a double murder, killing a pawnbroker and her half-sister. Yes, he tries to exalt the grisly crime in the lofty language of utilitarianism — insisting that the pawnbroker’s money could be put to altruistic use. But where Lacenaire was cool, unflappable and languid, Raskolnikov is feverish, tormented and confused, torn between ideas and impulses, as divided as his own name (raskol means schism, or split) implies.

Birmingham ably guides us through the first few decades of Dostoyevsky’s astonishing life, paying particular heed to his time amid reformist circles in St. Petersburg, Russia. A sudden burst of literary acclaim in response to his first novel, “Poor Folk,” in January 1846 was swiftly followed by critical ridicule when “The Double” was published the month after. In 1849, he was arrested for political offenses against the state and put in front of a firing squad before being given a theatrical last-minute reprieve. He was then sent to Siberia, where he got to know some of the actual poor folk he had previously only written about. He talked to murderers, too, and was fascinated not only by their stories but by how they told them — the way they would boast of their formidable willpower at one moment and protest how utterly powerless they were the next.




It was the kind of oscillation that Dostoyevsky knew well. Before his exile, he would borrow money, write furiously to pay off the debts and then borrow again to buy time to write some more. He also liked to gamble, though putting it this way implies it was more fun thrill than desperate compulsion, when for him it was palpably both. He returned to St. Petersburg after a decade away, and “Crime and Punishment” was written under extreme financial duress. Still, Birmingham says, as much as he needed the money — his financial entanglements meant he was essentially upping the ante, courting total ruin — Dostoyevsky stayed committed to the integrity of the story, following it wherever it needed to go.

Against all of this turmoil, Birmingham’s chapters on Lacenaire begin to feel like an intrusion, despite the vivid portrait. The poet-murderer was chillingly unrepentant; kneeling before the guillotine, he twisted his torso so that he could see the blade coming down. But next to Birmingham’s rich, detailed narration of Dostoyevsky’s life, with all of its paradoxes and tortured ambivalences, Lacenaire’s extreme self-regard quickly becomes predictable, even a bit tedious. His villainy is like a gargoyle: inert and thoroughly grotesque.

“The Sinner and the Saint” ends right after Dostoyevsky marries Anna Grigorievna Snitkina, the stenographer who helped him complete “Crime and Punishment” and therefore rescued him from immediate catastrophe. But as Andrew Kaufman’s recent biography of Snitkina shows, she ultimately couldn’t save her husband from his paranoia, his misogyny, his antisemitism — those ugly impulses that existed alongside his generous imagination.

Before having children of his own, Dostoyevsky used to regale his nieces and nephews with stories about ghosts, but the writer who peered into the abyss of the self showed that such phantoms weren’t the most frightening beings of all. His young listeners “should go into an empty room, he said, look into a mirror and stare into their own eyes for five minutes,” Birmingham writes. “It is terrifying, he told the children, and nearly impossible.”



Publication Notes:

'The Sinner and the Saint: Dostoevsky and the Gentleman Murderer Who Inspired a Masterpiece'

By Kevin Birmingham.

416 pages. Penguin Press. $30.

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.










Today's News

November 11, 2021

Q3 2021 Market Report

Tears, dance as Benin welcomes back looted treasures from France

London's Courtauld to reopen after three-year revamp

More than $200 million sold on first night of New York fall auctions

Virtual tour of Greece's ancient Olympia goes live

Gagosian to open an exhibition of paintings and drawings by Mark Tansey

Whose writing is on the wall at the museum? It could be yours.

Wadsworth Atheneum announces new leadership model, appointment of CEO and search for new director

Nationalmuseum acquires painting by Julia Beck

Marie Antoinette's bracelets dazzle at auction

Literary star Viet Thanh Nguyen on the roots of identity politics

Christie's Paris announces highlights included in the Exceptional Sale

France's Azoulay re-elected as UNESCO chief

Vans x MOCA launch artist-inspired collection

The superheroes from House of Slay are here to stay

U.S. Holocaust Museum says China 'may be committing genocide' against Uyghurs

In her Met debut, a conductor leads a fresh 'La Bohème'

UT Austin's Briscoe Center acquires photo archive of Christopher Little

Daylight Books to release 'Viewing Distance: Remixing the Archives of the Military-Industrial Complex'

Christie's presents Magnificent Jewels and Jewels Online & Colorful Whimsy: Jewels by Michele della Valle

Triumphant return for ART X Lagos

Rivich brings designer fashion and American standards to auction, Nov. 17-18

How a murderous poet inspired one of Dostoevsky's masterworks

Don Maddox, last survivor of a pioneering country band, dies at 98

10 tips for writing better geography papers

Art and Design Elements in Online Casinos and How they Contribute to a Better User Experience

Learn The Causes Of Stress And Ways To Relieve Them!

Top 3 Benefits of Puppy Obedience Training for Your New Family Member




Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 



Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez
Writer: Ofelia Zurbia Betancourt

Attorneys
Truck Accident Attorneys
Accident Attorneys
Holistic Dentist
Abogado de accidentes
สล็อต
สล็อตเว็บตรง

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org juncodelavega.com facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site Parroquia Natividad del Señor
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful