The First Art Newspaper on the Net   Established in 1996 Thursday, July 16, 2020

Cooper Hewitt chief was forced out after probe of her wedding
Caroline Baumann, center, attends a Cooper Hewitt gala in New York on Oct. 18, 2018, in the same dress she wore to her wedding a month earlier. Baumann’s resignation as director of the Cooper Hewitt, Smithsonian Design Museum was made public Feb. 7, 2020, following an investigation by the Smithsonian’s inspector general into potential problems regarding the procurement of the dress and her wedding space. Rebecca Smeyne/The New York Times.

by Robin Pogrebin

NEW YORK (NYT NEWS SERVICE ).- Everything fell into place for Caroline Baumann on her wedding day. She wore an elegant silveresque dress she’d ordered from a Brooklyn designer. She exchanged her vows at a lush Hamptons preserve inside one of her favorite sculptures, a dome designed by R. Buckminster Fuller. She put photos of the day on Instagram.

That joyous event may have cost Baumann her job.

Baumann was forced to resign as director of the Cooper Hewitt, Smithsonian Design Museum in Manhattan last week following an investigation by the Smithsonian’s inspector general into potential problems regarding the procurement of the dress and the wedding space.

Her resignation was made public Feb. 7, without explanation of the reason. Two people with knowledge of the Smithsonian’s decision making, but who declined to be identified because the organization was not publicly commenting on the matter, said that the investigation had turned up evidence of an appearance of a conflict of interest.

The ousting of Baumann has angered members of the Cooper Hewitt board, which is separate from the Smithsonian leadership. Several board members said they were considering resigning because they disagreed with the decision and were not consulted in advance. A number of the board members have donated substantial sums to the museum in recent years, and their departure could affect its finances.

“I know the circumstances of the investigation that led to Caroline’s dismissal and I must say I am appalled that this was its conclusion,” Judy Francis Zankel, a prominent philanthropist who serves as the secretary of the board, wrote in an email to Lonnie G. Bunch III, the Smithsonian’s secretary and top official. “I have been working with her long enough to know without a doubt that she has been unfairly accused and unjustly judged.”

Even board members who acknowledged Baumann may have violated policy said they believed the punishment was too harsh.

It was unclear whether there were additional reasons for Baumann’s forced resignation, and a Smithsonian spokeswoman, Linda St. Thomas, declined to discuss specifics. “We’re transparent about a lot of things,” she said, “but not personnel.”

Baumann, 53, declined to be interviewed. She had been with the museum since 2001, having previously worked at the Museum of Modern Art, and was named director in 2013.

Despite its turn-of-the-century housing, an imposing Fifth Avenue mansion built for Andrew Carnegie, the museum is renowned as a repository of forward-thinking design in an array of fields, including art, architecture, graphics, electronics and products.

Several trustees said Baumann had been transformational for the Cooper Hewitt, overseeing its $91 million renovation, raising the museum’s profile and attracting donations.

The investigation into her conduct was triggered by an unidentified staff member’s complaint, and focused on her September 2018 wedding to John Stewart Malcolmson, a branding and graphic design consultant. (The wedding was featured in the regular “Mini-Vows” section of The New York Times.)

One issue was the dress Baumann commissioned from a young Brooklyn designer, Samantha Sleeper. Sleeper said in an interview with The New York Times that she provided the inspector general with emails showing that she had charged — and Baumann had paid — $750 for a cocktail dress. But since the designer’s website says that “custom gowns begin at $3,000,” that price discrepancy raised eyebrows at the inspector general’s office, which sent agents to speak with Sleeper.

According to Sleeper, the agents suggested that Baumann had offered to use her stature as the head of Cooper Hewitt to wrangle a discount, perhaps by offering to promote Sleeper’s work. Sleeper said she responded that she had given Baumann an appropriate price, since the dress was a sleeveless sheath and not a wedding gown. She said that she told the agents that she was not seeking publicity, as she had already been featured in major magazines.

“It was a super simple silhouette with no freelancers working on it besides me,” Sleeper told the The Times. “I did not give her a discount nor did she ask for a discount. She asked the price of the dress, I sent her an email and she paid me that amount.”

It is not clear what the inspector general concluded about the dress, but another focus of its investigation was the location of the wedding, the LongHouse Reserve in East Hampton. The reserve, a 16-acre property with carefully tended gardens and outdoor sculptures, is run by a nonprofit founded by Jack Lenor Larsen, a prominent textile designer who lives on the property and is a friend of Baumann. (In 2015, the Cooper Hewitt awarded Larsen one of its annual national design awards.)

Larsen welcomed Baumann’s use of the property for the ceremony (the reception was held on Shelter Island) and did not charge her. According to the people familiar with the Smithsonian’s decision, it took issue with the fact that Baumann allowed Larsen’s nonprofit to hold its board meetings at no cost in a conference room at the Cooper Hewitt.

“How can it be inappropriate for a nonprofit to use a conference room for a board meeting?” said Matko Tomicic, executive director of LongHouse. But the Smithsonian was apparently concerned about the appearance that favors had been exchanged and believed that Baumann should have reported the free use of the reserve as a gift.

The Smithsonian is not a federal agency, but it was created by Congress and is partly funded by the government. In accordance with its charter, its board of regents comprises three members each from the House and Senate, the vice president, the chief justice and members of the public.

In many ways, it behaves like an appendage of the government, and has a conflict of interest policy that mimics those of many public agencies: “Employees must not engage in private or personal activities that might conflict, or appear to conflict, with Smithsonian interests, such as using Smithsonian employment for private gain” or “giving preferential treatment to any person or company for any reason.”

Like many federal departments, it also has an independent inspector general. But Sleeper said that she was troubled by the behavior of the agents who interviewed her. A few weeks later, she sent an email to the inspector general’s office saying that the agents sounded biased against Baumann and predisposed to find fault.

She said one of the agents told Sleeper that he had heard that Baumann was “a ‘Devil Wears Prada’ type” and that she “was a bitch.”

“I found this statement to be astronomically shocking and inappropriate coming from a man who was representing a federal investigation whose purpose was to be in a place of inquiry,” Sleeper said in her email. “I expressed my opinion that it’s not a respectful or appropriate way to speak about women, and that I don’t think it’s appropriate to be repeating that term to me.” She wrote that the agent responded that he “didn’t need a lecture.”

Epin Hu Christensen, a counsel to the inspector general’s office, said the office could not comment on the substance of its investigations. “As a general matter,” she said in an email, “we adhere to the Council of the Inspectors General on Integrity and Efficiency’s Quality Standards for Investigations.”

Part of the Cooper Hewitt board’s displeasure stems from the unorthodox structure of the Smithsonian, which oversees 19 museums and galleries and the National Zoo, almost all located in the Washington area. The Cooper Hewitt board oversees the day-to-day operations of the museum and contributes significant funds, but it technically has only an advisory role.

The share of Cooper Hewitt’s budget that comes from the government is about half that received by the Smithsonian’s other museums. It is the only one to charge admission, and it relies heavily on donations, including gifts from its board.

In 2014, for example, the museum received a $10 million donation from the family foundation of longtime board member Barbara Mandel. And interior designer Agnes C. Bourne, a current vice president of the board, donated $2 million toward the museum’s 1996 renovation. Bourne commended Baumann’s leadership, adding, “I can’t imagine anything she would do that would be a problem.”

Another board member, author Kurt Andersen, said that Baumann “has done an extraordinary job, overseeing a great renovation and expansion and reinvigoration of the museum.”

“If her alleged infractions are what I understand them to be, the punishment seems crazily disproportionate,” he added. “I really hope they’ll reconsider.”

© 2020 The New York Times Company

Today's News

February 15, 2020

Three surviving versions of Armada Portrait of Elizabeth I go on display together

A major new exhibition of Chatsworth's world-class collection of Old Masters drawings opens at Millennium Gallery

Empathy and artistry: Rediscovering Dorothea Lange

Cooper Hewitt chief was forced out after probe of her wedding

Dalí: Sketchbooks from the 1930s on view at Omer Tiroche Gallery

Towner Eastbourne opens 'Early Works' an exhibition by Alan Davie and David Hockney

Exhibition provides insight into the work of Pablo Picasso during the Second World War

National Gallery of Art announces new Curator of Italian and Spanish Paintings Eve Straussman-Pflanzer

A ballerina's nightmare: 'Am I more than just a dancer?'

Exhibitions explore changing ecology, technology, and community

The Westmoreland Museum of American Art presents African American art in the 20th century

Major gift to support reimagining visitor experience at Library of Congress

Pavlensky, artist provocateur, claims top French political scalp

The Currier Museum of Art celebrates Maud Briggs Knowlton, the museum's first director

Ultra-rare sealed video games, unique Nintendo console offered at Heritage Auctions

Galerie Barbara Thumm exhibits works by Anna Oppermann

Dallas Museum of Art appoints Vivian Crockett as Assistant Curator of Contemporary Art

Institute of Contemporary Art Miami appoints seven new Trustees and Board President

Exhibition juxtaposes artists' work with nature's to question the lines we humans draw

Michael Friedman left behind a musical. They're finishing it.

Record auction price for late Norfolk artist highlights growing recognition

Praz-Delavallade Paris opens an exhibition of works by Xavier Robles de Medina

The National Gallery of Denmark opens exhibition of recently donated works by Ragna Braase

NOME presents Kirsten Stolle's latest solo presentation, Pesticide Pop

How to Let Explainer Videos Do the Heavy Work for You

Where to Go: The Top 5 Museums To Visit When You're In Canada

The Image of a Poker Player

Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .


Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez

sa gaming free credit

Royalville Communications, Inc
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
to a Mexican poet.

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful