|The First Art Newspaper on the Net
|Established in 1996
| Sunday, February 25, 2024
|Eurydice, a new opera, looks back all too tamely
From left, Kevin Ray as Loud Stone, Raehann Bryce-Davis as Big Stone, and Stacey Tappan as Small Stone, in Eurydice at the Dorothy Chandler Pavilion in Los Angeles, Jan. 29, 2020. The composer Matthew Aucoin is deferential to Sarah Ruhls text, in a Los Angeles production that comes to the Met Opera next year. Emily Berl/The New York Times.
by Anthony Tommasini
LOS ANGELES (NYT NEWS SERVICE ).- Composer Matthew Aucoin began working on Crossing, his first opera, when he was in college. It was a work of enormous talent, exciting promise and considerable hubris: Aucoin wrote his own libretto, inventing a story about Walt Whitmans work with wounded soldiers during the Civil War.
If Crossing (2015) lacked a certain kind of unity as Aucoin, now 29, said in a recent interview it was still taut, intense and audacious. What would he do next?
The answer came Saturday, with the premiere of Eurydice at the Los Angeles Opera, where it runs through Feb. 23 before traveling to the Metropolitan Opera in New York next year. This project demanded a very different approach. Aucoin didnt write the libretto; instead, the text was a collaboration with playwright Sarah Ruhl, closely hewing to her 2003 play, a modern-day take on the Orpheus and Eurydice myth that tells the story from the womans perspective.
The play is meditative and surreal, fantastical and funny. Aucoin said in the interview that he thought he needed to do remarkably little: He wanted just to tap the words, to release the wells of emotional undercurrents in Ruhls clean, simple phrases. Throughout this three-act opera, you sense Aucoin honorably striving to serve the play.
He may have been overly deferential. Ruhls libretto called for a lighter, more enchanting score than Crossing. But the musical language of Eurydice is at times curiously tame.
I liked the opera most when, during fraught episodes, the music turns jagged and dangerous. Whenever Aucoin gives vent to his liveliest voice with hints here of Maurice Ravel, Benjamin Britten and Thomas Adès the opera takes off.
I sat up every time he seemed to push the libretto aside briefly to let some gnarly, skittish music take charge, especially in the incisive performance he conducted. And director Mary Zimmermans inventive production conveys the right mix of whimsical fairy tale and disturbing morality play through a simple, colorful staging, with sets by Daniel Ostling and costumes by Ana Kuzmanic.
After a short, quizzical overture, we meet Orpheus and Eurydice, dressed for fun at the beach. The vivacious Eurydice (soprano Danielle de Niese) seems smitten with the hearty Orpheus (baritone Joshua Hopkins). Yet you soon sense her doubts. A self-absorbed if supernaturally talented musician, Orpheus doesnt share her passion for books and words. When he looks distracted and Eurydice asks him what hes thinking about, he answers: music.
In the operas boldest stroke, Aucoin, who sees Orpheus as a divided character, gives him a double. Orpheus the everyday guy clueless if also endearing is sung by Hopkins, with firm voice and youthful swagger. But Orpheus also has a godlike dimension, represented here by a countertenor, John Holiday, who appears in moments when Orpheus questing nature comes out. Eurydice doesnt see Orpheus double, but panicky outbursts in the orchestra and her sputtered vocal lines suggest that she senses him.
Eurydice readily accepts Orpheus marriage proposal. But soon after, in the underworld, we see her deceased father, a sad, reflective man who still adores his daughter. (He is sung by mellow-voiced baritone Rod Gilfry an old Aucoin hand, having originated the role of Whitman in Crossing.)
He writes a letter to Eurydice, offering the fatherly advice he would have shared at the ceremony. Aucoin shows respect for the tender, charming words by setting them to somber music of lyrical pining over restless orchestral stirrings. But I wanted less reverence and more intensity.
The wedding scene is wonderful, with guests dancing to gyrating music; at one point the orchestra becomes a riot of squiggly riffs. But Eurydice is somehow dissatisfied. I always thought there would be more interesting people at my wedding, she says.
Well, an interesting person appears: Hades, a character Aucoin clearly relished, written for high-lying tenor and sung fearlessly by Barry Banks. The god of the underworld, Hades first seems courtly, snaring Eurydice by telling her he has a letter for her from her father. Aucoin has a penchant for using the orchestra to hug vocal lines. He takes this to arresting extremes with Hades: Groups of instruments buttress, enclose, mimic and sometimes needle every syllable.
De Niese, though strained at times, sang with fullness and richly expressive shadings. She was riveting a young woman tortured with indecision as she went off with Hades then tumbled into the underworld.
The darkest element of the play and opera is how the underworld is depicted: The dead pass through a river of forgetfulness, where they lose their memories and even language. Eurydices father has secretly kept possession of a pen forbidden below and his English. In a heartbreaking moment, the dead Eurydice arrives, holding an umbrella that has not protected her from the waters. She mistakes her beloved father for a porter.
Almost every musical telling of this myth has a moment when Orpheus sings a song that so enchants the gatekeepers of the underworld that he is given permission to enter and reclaim his wife. Aucoins version, with Orpheus joined by his double, is more a stentorian demand that an aria of lyrical persuasion. I thought the music, for all its stern fortitude, needed more threatening fervor.
The emotions of the characters are poked at throughout by a trio of bizarre figures: Little Stone (Stacey Tappan), Big Stone (Raehann Bryce-Davis) and Loud Stone (Kevin Ray). Like an irreverent Greek chorus, they laugh at human pretensions and encourage people to feel nothing. (No one gets hurt that way.) As they trade phrases and boisterously overlap, Aucoins music for them is aptly snide and harmonically slippery.
A chorus of nearly 40 voices provides harmonic plushness and ethereal sounds during crucial episodes. But Zimmerman, with the blessing of Aucoin, keeps the chorus backstage in an effort to focus on the main characters. This seemed a major miscalculation. The choral writing added pungency to the score. And the drama, which sometimes felt static, could have benefited from the presence of witnesses onstage. Zimmerman might reconsider this before the production travels to the Met, which co-commissioned the work.
When Orpheus is poised to lead his wife up to Earths surface agreeing not to look back as he does so this Eurydice, her memory still fuzzy, is uncertain. Her husband is waiting, the three stones tell her. Thats a stranger, she answers: And when you think about it, wasnt Orpheus, wrapped in his art, always a kind of stranger to this thoughtful woman?
After she has died a second time, Eurydice writes a sisterly letter to Orpheus future wife, giving de Niese a poignantly fragile final aria. Aucoins music lifts her vocal lines while shimmering tremulously in the background. Here this still-young, extravagantly gifted composer grabbed the dramatic moment and met it with energy and originality. If only he had done so more often.
Through Feb. 23 at the Dorothy Chandler Pavilion, Los Angeles; laopera.org.
© 2020 The New York Times Company
Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .
|Royalville Communications, Inc
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.