|
The First Art Newspaper on the Net |
|
Established in 1996 |
|
Tuesday, November 5, 2024 |
|
At Sotheby's, it was 'no froth, no excitement.' That's the new normal |
|
|
On Tuesday night, Sothebys saw a 40% drop in its impressionist and modern art sales compared with the equivalent sale last May. Courtesy Sotheby's.
by Scott Reyburn and Robin Pogrebin
|
NEW YORK (NYT NEWS SERVICE).- If French Israeli telecommunications entrepreneur Patrick Drahi, who bought Sothebys in June in a deal worth $3.7 billion, needed proof that auctions are unlike any other business, he got a clear introduction to that reality during this weeks unpredictable sales.
On Tuesday night, Sothebys saw a 40% drop in its impressionist and modern art sales compared with the equivalent sale last May. By Thursday, the auction house was heartened by the $270.6 million total of its contemporary art sale although that, too, was 28% lower than the spring total.
To drive home the fickleness of the salesroom, Christies, on Wednesday, achieved an auction high for an Ed Ruscha work, fetching $52.5 million for the Prince of Pops 1964 word painting Hurting the Word Radio #2. The following night, Sothebys, on the other hand, couldnt even manage to sell Ruschas egg yolk on silk, She Gets Angry At Him, from the collection of designer Marc Jacobs. Ultimately, the auction house brought the piece back to the block as the last lot of Thursday evening and sold it for $1.7 million, below its $2 million low estimate.
The art business is not something you can equate to any other business, Helly Nahmad, a New York dealer, said. Theyre not selling stocks and bonds here. Theyre selling fine art.
This weeks sales provided ample evidence of why the art market continues to defy predictions and to confound those looking for reliable results. This auction season was buffeted by uncertainty around geopolitical trends. Collectors held onto their best material but, at the same time, buyers were still willing to pay top dollar for the best works that did emerge.
The auction houses suffered in the absence of any major estate sales. On the other hand, they benefited from the seemingly insatiable appetite for blue-chip works of contemporary art.
In the end, as in recent years past, dealers, collectors and the auction houses themselves were able to end the week trumpeting the results as proof of a resilient market.
A lot of people bidding a lot of money on a lot of paintings, said Marc Glimcher, president and chief executive of Pace Gallery. It was a strong sale. Everybodys happy.
Drahi, who took Sothebys private in a surprise deal and recently appointed Charles Stewart from Altice USA as his chief executive is expected to try to streamline Sothebys, paring costs and emphasizing digital development.
But art experts also caution that applying standard business practices has been tried before and may continue to prove challenging. The particular alchemy of the auction world depends on personal relationships with collectors, on auction specialists with years of expertise and on the serendipity of a live sale in which bidders decide often in the heat of the moment to go to the mat for the same object.
That type of frenzied excitement was evident Thursday night at Sothebys, as bids came fast and furious for Kerry James Marshalls Vignette 19 park scene of 2014, propelling the final price to $18.5 million well over the high estimate of $7.5 million (although shy of the painters top auction price of $21.1 million last year for Past Times, bought by Sean Combs).
Four bidders also competed for Marshalls 2013 painting, Small Pin-Up (Lens Flare), which sold to Los Angeles dealer Stavros Merjos for more than twice its low estimate: $5.5 million.
Marshalls mentor, the late printmaker and painter Charles White who last year was the subject of a MoMA retrospective also had a big night, his first in a Sothebys evening sale. Whites poignant and impressively large 1953 charcoal drawing went for $1.8 million against a low estimate of $500,000, setting a new auction high for the artist.
Called Ye Shall Inherit the Earth, the drawing shows Rosa Lee Ingram, an African American woman who became an icon of the social justice movement. In the late 1940s she was accused, with her two sons, of killing a white sharecropper. All three were sentenced to death, but after a public outcry, the sentence was commuted to life imprisonment.
The strength of these artists Thursday night was emblematic of a growing interest at auction in artists of color. An abstract painting by Norman Lewis, Ritual from 1962, sold for $2.8 million, a record at auction for the artists work.
African American art is strong at the moment, dealer Christophe Van de Weghe said. The auction houses have struggled to find good material. People dont want to sell their paintings. But when the auction houses find good things, they fly.
At the same time, the more obvious trophies were also in high demand. Three abstract paintings went to Asian bidders. Willem de Koonings large-scale abstract, Untitled XXII which was sold by New York art dealer Bob Mnuchin and had never before been offered at auction went for $30.1 million, having been guaranteed by a third party to sell at $25 million.
Similarly, Clyfford Stills 1946 PH-399, not seen on the market since 1970, sparked a 15-minute, three-way telephone battle before falling for $24.3 million to the same collector as the de Kooning. It had been estimated at $12 million to $18 million.
And Mark Rothkos bright orange abstract, Blue Over Red, from 1953, sold for a solid $26.5 million, on a low estimate of $25 million, despite having been unloved by some visitors at the auction preview.
The different results at Sothebys and Christies contemporary sales made clear how dependent auction houses are on the quality of the consignments they are able to corral each season. All but four of Sothebys lots were successful, with 70% selling for hammer prices above their low estimates. The previous evening at Christies, 40% of the material sold below estimate.
Maybe they had a more interesting mix of things, said art adviser Nancy Whyte, speaking of Sothebys.
At Phillips earlier Thursday night, the total results were healthy, if not exactly effervescent: $108.1 million, up slightly from Mays sales.
Everyone is a little apprehensive at the moment, said Frances Beatty, a New York-based art adviser. Art is very easy to buy but not so easy to sell.
One of the most remarkable signs of nervousness in the current market is the fact that auction sales of works by KAWS ($70.6 million) were higher in the first half of 2019 than those of art market powerhouse Jean-Michel Basquiat ($65.6 million), according to Artnets latest Intelligence Report.
The Phillips sale included Basquiats red-dominated 1981 canvas, The Ring, showing one of the artists trademark boxers in polka-dot shorts triumphantly holding a spear above his head. Guaranteed to sell for at least $10 million, the painting went to art adviser Abigail Asher for $15 million, with fees.
All in all, the week attested to the vagaries of the art market, which can simultaneously seem as volatile as tech stocks and as resilient as U.S. Treasury bonds.
It was steady, said Hugo Nathan, a London art adviser, No froth, no excitement, but robust results.
He added that The auction houses did a great job with what they had, and that This might be the pattern for a year or two.
© 2019 The New York Times Company
|
|
Today's News
November 16, 2019
Städel Museum exhibits drawings from Max Beckmann to Gerhard Richter
London's new Vagina Museum: education, not titillation
St Mark's closed as Venice faces more floods
At Sotheby's, it was 'no froth, no excitement.' That's the new normal
mumok opens an exhibition dedicated exclusively to Eva Hesse's works on paper
Antony Gormley's Field for the British Isles opens in Colchester
Exhibition unveils some of the highlights of a major joint acquisition
White Cube announces representation of Kaari Upson
Souls Grown Deep announces four new museum acquisition agreements
Don't call Tara Subkoff an 'it' girl
Asian collectors compete for American Abstraction in Sotheby's Contemporary Art Evening Auction
A rich imagination: Madhvi Parekh, an artist for today
A $4 U.S gold coin sells for $204,000
Sotheby's and RM Sotheby's online only: Nissan Figaro brings $51,750
Dia appoints Donna De Salvo as Senior Adjunct Curator, Special Projects
Guggenheim Museum appoints Ashley James Associate Curator, Contemporary Art
Netflix to fix Holocaust documentary after Poland complains
City Art Centre presents Beneath the Surface featuring work by nine contemporary artists based in Scotland
International fashion exhibition opens at TextielMuseum this autumn
Banderas opens his Malaga theatre with 'A Chorus Line'
Little-seen Norman Cornish sketchbooks displayed at Durham University
BALTIC Centre for Contemporary Art opens first major UK survey of works by Judy Chicago
Natural and supernatural worlds collide at the Royal Ontario Museum
Babe Ruth's Dodgers coaching uniform sold for $187,500 at Julien's Auctions
Buy Trending Dresses Online on This Black Friday
Latest Video Games Roblox MOD APK Download Unlimited
Why You Should Download the SCR888 APP
|
|
|
|
|
Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography, Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs, Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, . |
|
|
|
Royalville Communications, Inc produces:
|
|
|
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful
|
|