The plan to save Frank Lloyd Wright's only skyscraper isn't going as planned
The First Art Newspaper on the Net    Established in 1996 Tuesday, October 1, 2024


The plan to save Frank Lloyd Wright's only skyscraper isn't going as planned
A hotel room at Price Tower, Frank Lloyd Wright’s only realized skyscraper, in Bartlesville, Okla., Aug. 26, 2024. The 18-story national historic landmark, which has struggled for many years to find an anchor tenant, is up sale — listed on a commercial real estate auction website next to hollowed out strip malls and an empty Burger King. (Joseph Rushmore/The New York Times)

by Annie Aguiar



BARTLESVILLE, OKLA.- Frank Lloyd Wright’s only realized skyscraper is just 19 stories, but even 70 years after it was built, Price Tower sits higher than most buildings in this city, and the view from the top still stretches to the horizon where the rolling prairie starts to take shape.

The tower is a landmark in Bartlesville, and a rarity in the architect’s portfolio. Designed by Wright to resemble a tree, with green, oxidized copper paneling, it’s featured on a mural nearby that depicts bison, an oil well and other anchors of the city’s heritage.

But the tower is now in trouble.

Once a buzzy hub of business life, and briefly occupied by Phillips Petroleum, the oil company that has long called Bartlesville home, it has struggled for many years to find an anchor tenant. It was reinvented as a nonprofit arts center in 2001 and soon added a boutique hotel and restaurant, but its major benefactor, former Phillips chief executive C.J. Silas, also known as Pete, died a decade ago.

Facing a financial crisis, the nonprofit organization turned last year to a married pair of cryptocurrency entrepreneurs, Cynthia and Anthem Blanchard, who presented a bold plan to revive Wright’s masterwork. They proposed that a group led by Cynthia Blanchard would buy the building, renovate it and make it the launchpad for a rethinking of Bartlesville as “Silicon Ranch,” a new hub for technology startups drawn by Oklahoma’s lower cost of living.

“The vision was to hopefully create an incubator, similar to what Tulsa is doing, that used Price Tower as the apex of the attraction for young tech entrepreneurs,” said Blanchard, the chief executive of Copper Tree Group, the entity that bought the building through a subsidiary.

The sale price was only $10, but Bartlesville officials were enthused by Blanchard’s promise to settle the building’s outstanding debt and to spend $10 million on improvements to the building, a national historic landmark. There was even going to be a new upscale restaurant, called Sinatra’s.

“It seemed like there was a hero there,” said Scott Perkins, a former curator of Price Tower’s museum collection and now a senior official at Fallingwater, the home that is perhaps Wright’s most famous creation.

After nearly two years, though, the $10 million has not materialized. The new owners have sold some one-of-a-kind furnishings that Wright designed for the building. And the building itself is up for sale, listed on a commercial real estate auction website next to hollowed out strip malls and an empty Burger King.

Blanchard said she underestimated the challenge of profitably operating the tower and that selling some of the furnishings was necessary to meet expenses.

“We have done nothing illegal or nothing wrong,” she said of the Copper Tree Group’s handling of the building. “We’ve tried to do everything with the utmost transparency and professionalism.”

That rationale has done little to assuage preservationists who have worked for decades to protect the building as part of Wright’s legacy. The Frank Lloyd Wright Building Conservancy, which has a preservation easement on the property, is working to block any further sale of the furnishings by filing liens against Blanchard’s company.

“Under the terms of the easement, they are not to sell easement-protected items without our consent,” said Barbara Gordon, the executive director of the conservancy.

For some Bartlesville residents who see the tower as the town’s centerpiece, it has been disappointing to watch a rescue effort unveiled with such optimism dissolve with such speed.

“My sweet, 88-year-old mom is like, ‘I wish I could win the lottery and buy the tower,’” said Maria Swindell Gus, the tourism director for Bartlesville. “I’ve heard that from a lot of people.”

The Tree That Escaped the Crowded Forest

Skyscrapers were never really a core part of Wright’s vision. For his mentor, Louis Sullivan? Yes. But Wright was known for low-lying houses that sunk into their natural environments.

His design for a skyscraper with copper panels and single-pane glass windows that maximize natural light was intended to be part of a series of towers to be built in New York in the 1920s. But the Depression intervened and the design lay dormant for decades until Wright was approached in 1952 by Harold Charles Price, a welder who had applied his skills to pipeline construction and rode them to success as Bartlesville’s oil fortunes bloomed.

Those oil fortunes began with the Phillips brothers, who drilled their first successful well outside the city in 1905. Their company would later become two companies, ConocoPhillips and Phillips 66, and each would move their headquarters to Houston. But enough business operations remained to make those two companies Bartlesville’s top employers, even today.

The idea to get Wright involved in a new office building for the H.C. Price Co. is credited to one of Price’s sons, Joe, who had studied architecture at the University of Oklahoma. He thought it would be great for Price to bring the one-of-a-kind Wright building to the city as a gesture that the company was giving something back.

Wright, then in his mid-80s, saw the project as an opportunity to express his mature architectural vision, David De Long, a Wright expert, wrote in a 1982 study of the tower’s interior.

Wright, holistic in his approach, viewed exterior and interior as a whole, and spent time designing the offices and other spaces as well as the furnishings. It made for an odd office building, with few right angles. Wright thought a variety of angles encouraged more flexible human movement. Some of Wright’s furniture — chairs, desks, stools and tables — took on the same angled forms as the building.

At the building’s 1956 dedication, Wright spoke of the tower as an “upraised hand on the prairie,” as “the tree that escaped the crowded forest.”

“Now the skyscraper comes into its own,” he said, “on the rolling plains of Oklahoma.”

When the Price company relocated to Dallas in 1981, the tower was sold to Phillips, which briefly used it for office space and storage. When the company’s need for it diminished, the building sat vacant for years before local organizers led by Silas, the former Phillips chief executive, and his wife, Theo, drove an effort to repurpose it as an arts hub for the city. Despite its small size, Bartlesville, population 37,795, has long had a certain cosmopolitan flair, with a ballet company and an annual Mozart festival, in addition to its highest-profile cultural icon, the Price Tower.

In 2001, the Phillips company donated the building to the nonprofit organization known as the Price Tower Arts Center and the building soon featured a 21-room boutique hotel and the Copper Restaurant + Bar. Guests at the hotel were invited to “spend a night with Frank Lloyd Wright” and take in art exhibitions and installations that discussed the architect’s vision for the building.

In 2011, during a period when the building was seeking recognition as a UNESCO World Heritage site, the Wright conservancy was given a preservation easement on the property, empowering it to review changes in the building’s design. And when the budget did not balance in a given year, the Silases were there to close the gaps.

But after Pete Silas died in 2014 and Theo Silas in 2017, the nonprofit lost a major source of revenue and had to dip deeper and deeper into its reserves. Brad Doenges, who became the chair of the organization in 2017, said that last year, when the building was sold to the group led by Cynthia Blanchard, the only other option beyond selling was bankruptcy.

Doenges said the nonprofit was comforted by the fact that the conservancy had a preservation easement and that the new owners had a plan.

“The merits of it, the reality of it, I really can’t say,” he said in an interview. “It didn’t come to fruition, obviously.”

‘Where History Meets the Future’

Cynthia Blanchard was raised in Dewey, Oklahoma, about a 10-minute drive down Route 123 to Bartlesville and remembers going to Price Tower on occasion while growing up. But she said she didn’t fully appreciate the building until she was an adult, visiting home.

“It’s just a special place,” she said. “People fall in love with it.”

Cynthia Blanchard and her husband, Anthem, met in New Orleans in 2004. She was working in music publishing and had once been a background singer on a Reba McEntire album. He had been raised in New Orleans, the son of James U. Blanchard III, a wealthy pioneering seller of gold and other precious metals.

Anthem Blanchard also went into the precious metals trade, then pivoted to cryptocurrency entrepreneurship with a series of companies he started that included HeraSoft, a blockchain-based cybersecurity technology company that he co-founded with Cynthia Blanchard. When the COVID lockdown began several years ago, the Blanchards relocated to Bartlesville to be closer to Cynthia Blanchard’s parents, and decided to anchor HeraSoft in Bartlesville’s old, historic Washington County Courthouse.

In 2023, as the tower’s woes deepened, they were encouraged by friends with an office in the building to consider acquiring it. The nonprofit was open to the idea.

Under the sale agreement, the real estate subsidiary company of the Copper Tree Group led by Cynthia Blanchard agreed to assume a standing $600,000 loan that had been taken out by a member of the nonprofit board to cover operating costs.

Blanchard said her husband helped her think through how to rejuvenate Price Tower but never had a formal role and is not part of the Copper Tree Group. The plan the company put forward included a suite of revenue-generating ideas, including a new restaurant, a private membership club and a line of marketable non-fungible tokens based on the tower.

The Bartlesville Development Authority chipped in, providing $88,000 to help kick-start the two restaurants — Sinatra’s, which changed its name to WrightSteak after a trademark dispute, and a downstairs spot called Love 66 Bistro.

The new plan also came with an inspiring motto: “Where History Meets the Future.”

Little of this would ultimately materialize.

Blanchard says the $10 million was always “more of a wish list,” a combination of an expected $5 million loan that fell through and theoretical funding from state tax credits. She argued that the nonprofit had pressured her into closing on the sale too soon, before the finances were fully set; Doenges denied that characterization.

“Our due diligence wasn’t as complete as it should have been, because we jumped in with so much faith,” Blanchard said.

Still, she said, she was proud of her efforts, even though it never felt like she owned the building.

“I was just the steward,” she said. “I was kind of assigned by God to do this.”

Selling Off Wright’s Furnishings

Though the tower has yet to be sold, some of its furnishings have been. In April, Andy Dossett, a reporter for The Bartlesville Examiner-Enterprise, said he watched as two men loaded bubble-wrapped chairs and stools from the tower into a large white van.

The Copper Tree Group has sold 10 of the furnishings to a Dallas midcentury furniture reseller. Some copper tables, stools and panels, an armchair, and what is believed to be the only example of a Wright-designed office directory board, are expected to command high prices. The armchair, for example, is listed at $88,000.

The Wright conservancy is trying to block any sales of the items, asserting they are covered by the preservation easement. Under the 2011 easement, the conservancy says it has the right to preserve the condition of the tower and its furnishings.

Blanchard said she believes the easement expired with the transfer of ownership to her Copper Tree Group, a position the conservancy rejects.

Blanchard said she only sold the Wright furnishings because she was “up against the wall” financially. She noted that the nonprofit, with the conservancy’s approval, had sold other furnishings in earlier years. Gordon said those items had been duplicates.

Liz Waytkus, the executive director of Docomomo US, an organization that works to preserve modern architecture, said it strongly opposes any sale of the Wright materials.

“They’re trafficked goods,” Waytkus said. “The same that you would say of pottery or vases from Egypt or Mesopotamia that were obtained through illegal ways, these pieces from Frank Lloyd Wright should be thought of in the same exact way.”

For Sale: A Very Tall Wright Landmark

The financial crisis that has befallen Price Tower will not be solved by the sale of some furniture, no matter how pricey. In August, the Copper Tree Group laid off the majority of the building’s staff, closed it to the public and told tenants they needed to leave by the end of the month.

HeraSoft, the company the Blanchards founded and brought to Bartlesville, has shut down and Anthem Blanchard was just accused this month in a civil case brought by the Securities and Exchange Commission of defrauding investors in the company of more than $5 million. He has denied wrongdoing.

Cynthia Blanchard said she is no longer affiliated with HeraSoft, and does not anticipate the case will have any effect on the sale of the building.

The tower, which was appraised to be worth $6.2 million last year, is now listed for sale on an online auction site. The starting bid is $600,000.

There has been some concern that no local employer is in need of as much office space as the tower provides, so the new owners would likely need to take on a hodgepodge of tenants, and look to address needed renovations.

But a broker handling the sale, Scott Schlotfelt, said the building is drawing interest and Blanchard’s group may decide to accept an offer before the scheduled Oct. 7 auction.

One snag going forward could be a lawsuit filed by McFarlin Building LLC, a Tulsa development firm, that says it has a formal agreement signed by Blanchard in May to purchase the building.

Blanchard contests that claim, saying that the company put forth unreasonable last-minute purchase terms. Schlotfelt, the broker, said he is not concerned that the dispute would affect any sale or scare off bidders.

Whoever takes over the building will find a welcome partner in the conservancy, which said it was very interested in working to preserve a building that offered a unique example of Wright’s vision. “Price Tower is still a very important building,” Gordon said.

Many residents of Bartlesville, like Patti Grissom, 73, share that view. Grissom remembers walking into the tower in 1977, a young woman beginning a career in accounting with H.C. Price and excited to work at the swankiest building in town.

She later spent years working at the nonprofit as Pete Silas’ executive assistant. She said the building still had energy then and it was disappointing now to see it emptied out and vacant.

“I’m kind of heartbroken for the tower, because I just didn’t know what was going to become of it,” she said. “I just keep hoping for good news.”

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.










Today's News

October 1, 2024

Convelio and SML Unveil Groundbreaking Art Operations Talent Report

Unique Christo-wrapped Leica M4 camera inscribed and gifted to photographer Wolfgang Volz to be auctioned Oct. 12

Christie's announces 20th/21st Century Art Marquee Week sales

Paul de Flers' fourth solo exhibition with Almine Rech opens in New York

Hammer Museum names Zoë Ryan as its new Director

Hayward Gallery and Hayward Gallery Touring 2025 visual arts programme announced

The plan to save Frank Lloyd Wright's only skyscraper isn't going as planned

Donors say a scarred island could become a park

Fergus McCaffrey Tokyo exhibiton celebrates the centennial of the birth of two Gutai artists

Cristiana Collu appointed Director of the Fondazione Querini Stampalia in Venice

Archibald winner in first solo exhibition at The Art Gallery of Western Australia

Francis Upritchard unfolds a world of mermaids and mythical creatures in her first Scandinavian exhibition

mother's tankstation opens 'Prudence Flint: Second Lesson'

Kemper Museum of Contemporary Art names Jessica S. Hong Chief Curator

Roald Dahl is antisemitic, but not a cartoon villain, in 'Giant'

'The Hills of California,' alive with the sound of music

What to know about Francis Ford Coppola and 'Megalopolis'

Malcolm Gladwell holds his ideas loosely. He thinks you should, too.

Gavin Creel, Tony-winning musical theater actor, dies at 48




Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 



Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez
Writer: Ofelia Zurbia Betancourt

Attorneys
Truck Accident Attorneys
Accident Attorneys
Holistic Dentist
Abogado de accidentes

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org juncodelavega.com facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site Parroquia Natividad del Señor
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful