|
The First Art Newspaper on the Net |
|
Established in 1996 |
|
Tuesday, November 5, 2024 |
|
Valparaiso University closes museum and moves ahead with selling from the collection |
|
|
In its May petition to Porter County Superior Court, the University claims that the three paintings have become too valuable for it to keep them safe.
|
VALPARAISO, IN.- Valparaiso University has closed its Brauer Museum of Art and dismissed the director, Jonathan Canning, as part of an administrative restructuring announced late last week to address the tuition-dependent schools falling enrollment and mounting operating deficit. The move surprised the local community as it comes just weeks after the museum opened America the Beautiful, its summer exhibition of Impressionist paintings drawn from the permanent collection. It also comes as the University moves ahead with its plan to sell the museums three most valuable paintings to fund renovations of freshman dormitories.
News of VUs intention to sell Mountain Landscape (ca. 1849) by Frederic Church, The Silver Veil and the Golden Gate (1916) by Childe Hassam, and Georgia OKeeffes Rust Red Hills (ca. 1930) startled the art world when it was first revealed by The Chicago Tribune in February 2023. The American Alliance of Museums and the Association of Art Museum Directors both condemned the proposed sale and use of funds as a breach of professional ethics and best practices. The museums former director, Richard Brauer, and former VU law professor and museum donor Philipp Brockington delayed the sale by filing suit against the university. They claimed it would violate the terms of the original gift agreement between Percy H. Sloan and VU. Sloan donated the Church landscape and established an acquisition fund with which Richard Brauer bought the Hassam and OKeeffe in the early 1960s. Ultimately, the Court denied Brauer and Brockington standing. Indiana State Attorney General Todd Rokita stepped in to review the case, but recently opted not to oppose a sale.
In its May petition to Porter County Superior Court, the University claims that the three paintings have become too valuable for it to keep them safe. The petition cites an example of European environmentalists throwing paint at the Mona Lisa. VU estimates that security upgrades would cost between $50,000 and $100,000, and professional guards, as opposed to students, would add an additional $150,000 to the museums annual staffing costs. It also argues storage fees at the undisclosed secure location, to which the paintings were transferred last Fall, are wasteful given its financial predicament. That predicament a 2024 operating deficit of $9Mis the result of declining enrollment that not only preclude[s] [the University] from incurring the capital costs needed in order to securely display the three paintings, [but] jeopardizes its core education mission and its continued economic contribution to the local and state economies. For these reasons the University seeks the Courts permission to liquidate the paintings to underwrite dormitory renovations to bolster enrollment.
VU also argues that the Hassam and OKeeffe paintings should not have been bought with Sloans funds because of a stipulation that they be used to acquire only conservative paintings. Claiming that Richard Brauer first broke these terms, VU appeals to be released from all other restrictions, especially the requirement that revenue from sold paintings be deposited into the Sloan Purchase Fund. In response, Brauer has appealed to be heard by the Court, asserting that the University has misinterpreted his actions and overlooked the fact that Sloans executor, given full discretionary authority under the gift agreement, authorized both purchases.
Whether the judge engages in the art historical debate, he must determine if the enlargement of the student body, attracted by upgraded dormitories, cleaves closely enough to Sloans stated desire to educate students in the appreciation of art to allow the sale. As part of the dormitory renovations, the university will construct a gallery in which freshmen can examine examples of conservative art from the Sloan Collection. Senior Research Professor John Ruff scoffs at the whole proposal. The Brauer Museum was the embodiment of both Sloans dream and the Universitys commitments to him. Percy Sloan would not have understood the Universitys argument about conservative art. He gave us paintings by Impressionists and early Chicago Modernists. A student common room is not a suitable place for a museum collection; nor, for reasons of student safety, can it be open to the general public. These, plus the employment of a professional, are core requirements of the Sloan gift. The University, in its desperation, is despoiling one of its greatest treasures. It has torn up the original agreement. The Court has got to put a stop to this.
In addition to undergoing administrative restructuring, the University is also considering the discontinuance of up to thirty programs. Decisions as to whether the Lutheran-affiliated school will continue to offer undergraduate degrees in German, theology, philosophy, and music performance will be made in the coming weeks. They are likely to be as controversial in the world of higher education as the deaccessioning proposal is in the art world.
|
|
Today's News
June 25, 2024
Valparaiso University closes museum and moves ahead with selling from the collection
'Printer Savant: Lumiere Press and the Art of the Photo Book' opens at Howard Greenberg Gallery
Ahlers & Ogletree announces Modern & Contemporary Art + Design auction
Poster Auctions International announces highlights included in its 93rd Rare Posters Auction
Black Bear Antiques and Interiors will serve as the new home for 80 dealers
John McInnis Auctioneers, LLC to hold a firearms collection estate auction
Escher in The Palace acquires unique White Cat and discovers text written by Escher
Kader Attia presents a conversation between two large installations at the Berlinische Galerie
Inventive quilts by Black artists in summer 2024 exhibition at High Museum of Art
World-renowned Palestinian artist duo envelops Copenhagen Contemporary and the Glyptotek in powerful resistance poetry
Public art project bears fruit in Kings Hill
These Victorian lampshades are a TikTok hit
Kunstmuseum Den Haag launches Art Connection: For people with dementia and their carers
Cannupa Hanska Luger's new sculpture confronts the history of North American bison
Discord at the symphony: Losing a star, San Francisco weighs its future
The American who built a supersized Japanese aerie from abandoned parts
An odd rock in a box gets linked to a shooting star that fell 54 years ago
Bob Eckstein has the perfect museum for you
The Honarkar Foundation for Arts & Culture presents "Joe Goode │ Select Works: 1970s-2000s"
Jinny Yu debuts new abstract paintings in first AGO solo exhibition
Review: A 10th life for those jellicle 'Cats,' now in drag
Spatializing Reproductive Justice on view at the Center for Architecture
Mabe Fratti, a spark in Mexico City's experimental music scene
Frederick Crews, withering critic of Freud's legacy, dies at 91
The #1 Reason To Buy A Gift Hamper To Take Care Of Your Self
5 Ways to Get the Perfect Bronze Tan this Summer
The Escort Business: In-Depth Look at Structure, Operations, and Financials
The Best Free AI Image Enhancer to Improve Quality - insMind
What the work of 500K artists tells us about investment rules, price valuation, and more
|
|
|
|
|
Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography, Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs, Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, . |
|
|
|
Royalville Communications, Inc produces:
|
|
|
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful
|
|