Sotheby's to oligarch at art fraud trial: The buck stopped with you

The First Art Newspaper on the Net    Established in 1996 Saturday, May 25, 2024


Sotheby's to oligarch at art fraud trial: The buck stopped with you
The Russian billionaire Dmitry Rybolovlev looks out from his penthouse in Monte Carlo, Monaco, Sept. 18, 2018. (Benjamin Bechet/The New York Times)

by Graham Bowley



NEW YORK, NY.- Dmitry Rybolovlev survived the turmoil of the collapse of the Soviet Union, founded a bank in Russia in the 1990s and built a fortune of roughly $7 billion from the sale of a potash fertilizer company.

He managed to get that wealth out of Russia, acquired a share in a bank in Cyprus, a Monaco soccer team, a Greek island, and homes for his family in Switzerland, Monaco, New York and Hawaii.

But under cross-examination in a Manhattan courtroom on Friday, Rybolovlev acknowledged that the diligence he had applied in building his business empire was not always present when he and his staff bought $2 billion in fine art through a Swiss dealer.

Asked by a lawyer for Sotheby’s whether he thought the aide he had trusted to handle those high-priced acquisitions had done a good job, he told the courtroom, “Let’s put it this way: There was room for improvement.”

Rybolovlev has accused the Swiss dealer, Yves Bouvier, of tricking him into overpaying for the art he bought over a period of 12 years as he constructed a collection of masterpieces, including Picassos, Van Goghs and works by other artists.

Rybolovlev has said that he believed Bouvier, who is not a defendant in this case, was acting as a commissioned consultant, assisting him in obtaining rare artworks at a good price by negotiating on his behalf. But he later discovered that Bouvier was operating as an independent dealer, not solely as an adviser.

Bouvier had actually bought the artworks himself, for about $1 billion, before flipping them to Rybolovlev and keeping a $1 billion profit.

Bouvier has long insisted he did nothing wrong: that he had been clear that he was a dealer and was free to charge what he wanted for a work. After years and years of legal fights, the two men agreed to a confidential settlement last year. But Rybolovlev is still pursuing Sotheby’s, which he says in his lawsuit was aware of, and abetted, the alleged fraud.

Lawyers for Rybolovlev have said Bouvier pretended to haggle with phantom sellers in an effort to drive up the prices paid by their client. In court papers, they have accused Samuel Valette, a Sotheby’s specialist in the sale of impressionist and modern art, of helping Bouvier by providing inflated appraisals that were sent to Rybolovlev and by leaving Bouvier’s name out of transaction histories.

Sotheby’s was involved in a dozen of the sales, but only four are the subject of the lawsuit. The auction house has said that it knew nothing of any scheme and, as its lawyers argued again Friday, that Rybolovlev should blame only himself for failing to protect himself against price inflations.

In particular, said Marcus Asner, a lawyer for Sotheby’s, Rybolovlev’s aide had never formalized the agency agreement with Bouvier; had never asked to see contracts with the sellers from whom Bouvier said he was buying art; and had never checked to see where all the money Rybolovlev paid was going.

Although Rybolovlev’s aide was the point person, Asner said, the billionaire himself also never checked these things and ultimately was responsible because he was in charge.

“You understand the term ‘trust and verify’?,” Asner said.

“I understand,” Rybolovlev replied.

“Mr. Rybolovlev, are you familiar with the term ‘The buck stops here’?,” Asner asked later. “You’re the boss.”

One of the most compelling moments in Rybolovlev’s second day on the stand was his account of how he first became aware that he had been significantly overpaying for his art. Rybolovlev, speaking softly in Russian through a translator who sat by his side, described for the jury a chance meeting in St. Barts in December 2014 with a New York art adviser.

Over lunch with his girlfriend, a friend who was a collector and the friend’s wife in a restaurant at the Eden Rock hotel, Rybolovlev said, he struck up a conversation with art adviser Sandy Heller. Heller, Rybolovlev said, mentioned that a client — hedge fund manager and New York Mets owner Steven Cohen — had recently sold a Modigliani painting for $93.5 million.

It was, in fact, the same Modigliani that Rybolovlev had just bought, but Rybolovlev had paid Bouvier $118 million. He had not realized until that moment, he said, that Bouvier had been buying up the art and reselling it to him at higher prices.

“I was in a state of shock” after the revelation, he said. “My friend thought I was having a heart attack because I turned completely pale.” He left the table.

Rybolovlev also testified that he came to view the scheme as a betrayal by a man who had become his friend and whom he had admitted into his inner circle and had even invited to join his small birthday celebration in Hawaii.

At one point, he asked for a moment to compose himself as he recalled conversations with Bouvier.

“He behaved in a way that made you trust him,” he said. “There is a point in time when you start to completely and utterly trust in some person.”

Rybolovlev insisted that putting what he believed was their arrangement formally in writing or seeking contracts from sellers would not have stopped Bouvier because, he said, Bouvier would have produced another document from a purported seller and it would have been difficult to check its veracity.

Rybolovlev said his previous business experience did not help him in the art world because it was an industry that lacked transparency. He said he considered himself a victim of that lack of transparency. “It is important for the art market to be more transparent,” he said.

But Asner said that Rybolovlev himself had embraced the tactical stratagems of the art market when it suited him. He went on to describe a scheme concocted by Bouvier to cancel a meeting with the owners of one work they were seeking to buy, a painting by Leonardo da Vinci, in hopes that their feigned disinterest would lead the sellers to lower their price.

“Is it OK for you not to be transparent in a dealing with the da Vinci sellers?,” Asner asked. “Did you tell Mr. Bouvier when he proposed this ruse to not lie?”

Rybolovlev said he had decided to let Bouvier handle the negotiations.

“How he was going to do it, what he was going to say, that was up to him,” he said.

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.










Today's News

January 14, 2024

Daring to create art freely behind the Iron Curtain

A pirate stole the band's music. The duo - both lawyers - couldn't get it back.

Field Museum covers some Native displays as new rules take effect

A frugal opera superfan's surprise gift: $1.7 million for the arts

Did this couple inspire Edward Albee's 'Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?'?

The Fahey/Klein Gallery opens a retrospective of Douglas Kirkland's photographs

Robert Andrew Parker, 96, dies; Prolific magazine and book illustrator

36 hours in Zurich

Steve Genter's Munich '72 medals shine at Olympic-themed auction

Swann Galleries timed sale: 'The Artists of the WPA' closing Jan 25

Phillips presents 'New Terrains' in January 2024, the company's first major exhibition of Native American art

Stevens Auction Company announces annual New Year's Multi-Estate Auction

Sotheby's to oligarch at art fraud trial: The buck stopped with you

On 'Orquídeas,' Kali Uchis gets all she wants

Review: Hilary Hahn gives, and gets, at the Philharmonic

Wadsworth Atheneum Museum of Art names Philippe Halbert, PhD Associate Curator of American Decorative Arts

Tellus Science Museum announces new expansion plan

Jay Clayton, vocal innovator in jazz and beyond, dies at 82

Alina Cojocaru: A freelance ballerina, forging her own path

When Mean Girls grow up

An actor channeling the folklore of his ancestors

With 'Echo,' Alaqua Cox smashes boundaries and bad guys' faces

Red Paden, juke joint 'King' who kept the blues alive, dies at 67

Wang Tuo wins the Sigg Prize 2023 with his multi-channel cinematic installation The Northeast Tetralogy

Beste IPTV Providers Nederland (Getest in 2024)

Redefining Skincare: The Effectiveness of Niacid Acne Cream

Building a Career at Sea: Offshore Welding Jobs' Allure with WTS Energy

Using Strategy to Deploy: Merchandising Trailers for Specific Markets

The Significance of Virtual Cards for Foreigners in the United States




Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 



Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez

sa gaming free credit
Attorneys
Truck Accident Attorneys
Accident Attorneys

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org juncodelavega.com facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site Parroquia Natividad del Señor
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful