Opera Philadelphia cuts its budget, but not its ambition

The First Art Newspaper on the Net    Established in 1996 Monday, April 22, 2024

Opera Philadelphia cuts its budget, but not its ambition
The company, a haven for contemporary and innovative opera, presented a scaled back yet rich edition of its season-opening festival. Photo: Steven Pisano Photography.

by Joshua Barone

PHILADELPHIA, PA.- Opera Philadelphia, like many arts organizations worldwide, is experiencing something of a hangover from the darkest days of the pandemic.

When companies returned to live performance, it was common — and necessary — for them to broadcast to their audiences that they had come back strong. In Europe, a proliferation of Wagner productions signified a return to grandeur; at the Metropolitan Opera in New York, the first work by a Black composer ushered in a new era for a bastion of staid tradition; and last year, Opera Philadelphia resumed its hulking, adventurous and essential season-opening festival.

By then, the company was merely adding a live component to its busy lockdown output, which featured innovative video operas that kept the art form going, while also asking where else it could go. Few houses have been such a haven for new, truly groundbreaking work, in good times and bad.

But the financial reality of the pandemic has set in for opera: the cost of keeping up appearances without ticket sales; the slow return of live audiences; the ruthlessly increasing, inflated expenses behind this most extravagant of performing arts. This season, the Met has fewer productions and more dark nights. In places like San Diego and Tulsa, Oklahoma, programming has been choked off by floundering budgets.

In August, Opera Philadelphia announced that in each of the past two fiscal years, it had operated at a deficit of more than $800,000. So it has reduced its budget by about $2 million — or 20% — by postponing a production of Joseph Boulogne’s “The Anonymous Lover,” originally planned for early 2024, cutting jobs from its administration and shutting down its pandemic-era streaming platform.

And this year’s edition of its Festival O, founded in 2017, is also a bit smaller than in the past. Crucially, though, Opera Philadelphia has not backed down from its ambition for the festival, which opened Thursday and continues through Sunday.

There is still, praise be, a world premiere: Rene Orth and Hannah Moscovitch’s harrowing, breathless “10 Days in a Madhouse.” Where Festival O was once exhaustingly dense, however, it is now easier to take in, with “10 Days” joined by a large-scale offering in Verdi’s “Simon Boccanegra” and a staged recital, “Unholy Wars.” I saw all three within just over 24 rainy hours over the weekend.

As long as Opera Philadelphia continues to commit to premieres — especially those with the range in style and compositional voices of “10 Days” and previous creations like Daniel Bernard Roumain and Marc Bamuthi Joseph’s “We Shall Not Be Moved” or the finest of the festival’s commissions, Philip Venables and Ted Huffman’s “Denis & Katya” — it will continue to reign as a destination for those seeking something new.

And opera needs works like “10 Days,” which treats the medium with affection and respect while also chafing at its tropes throughout history. This adaptation of Nellie Bly’s 19th-century journalistic report of the same name questions the nature of madness — and who has the authority to identify it — in an art form that subjects its heroines to many of the same horrors that Bly witnessed on Blackwell’s Island (now Roosevelt Island), where she was undercover, feigning mental illness to be briefly institutionalized.

Orth’s score has its problems. Its use of electronics can come off as dated, and its musical shorthand for insanity and dread — jittery phrasing, ghostly choruses — verges on the parodic and cliché. At its best, though, it captures a tension that has long made opera unsettling, the way in which, say, a mad scene can be a thing of shattering beauty and breathtaking athleticism, but also one of undeniable misogyny.

For this is an opera that jerks between beauty and terror — seamlessly under the baton of Daniela Candillari, leading an ensemble of about a dozen instrumentalists. The patients (members of Opera Philadelphia Chorus, led by Elizabeth Braden) can sing the same hymn with serenity in one scene and chaotic dissonance in the next, with few indications of which is the truer rendition. The villain, Dr. Josiah Blackwell, performed by baritone Will Liverman with frightening warmth, is given a gentle melody over an unstable waltz that shifts from 3/2 to 2/2 time and back again.

Joanna Settle’s production at the Wilma Theater unfolds around a unit set by Andrew Lieberman, a cylinder cut into quadrants by two intersecting hallways, which over the opera’s 90 minutes begins to feel appropriately unvarying and confined. In this space, Bly — soprano Kiera Duffy, her bright sound adding alarm to her role’s lyricism — encounters women who are less insane than their diagnoses, and a nurse (Lauren Pearl, an indelible presence with limited vocal material) who seems just as agonized as them.

The most tragic of the patients is Lizzie (mezzo-soprano Raehann Bryce-Davis, who sings with a lush and moving elegance that would make her ideal for mid-20th century American opera). Her repetitive ramblings come into logical focus with a long, crushing aria about the death of her daughter. You come to realize, frustratingly, that, like the Chinese woman declaring her sanity in a language no one else can understand, or like Bly herself, Lizzie doesn’t belong there. She’s only grieving.

In a score of dance-beat non sequiturs and eclecticism, her aria was a testament to the power of a directly pleading, flowing melody — the kind of music you get out of more traditional fare like Verdi’s “Boccanegra,” which opened at the Academy of Music on Friday evening.

Laurence Dale’s production, dressed up in Italian modernism in Gary McCann’s set design, was best as a straightforward vehicle for the strong cast, led by baritone Quinn Kelsey in the title role, alongside bass-baritone Christian Van Horn as Fiesco. The two men — introduced in the prologue following an autumnal overture conducted by Corrado Rovaris, Opera Philadelphia’s music director — were immediately commanding, in voice and stature.

But what makes them remarkable is the heart behind their mighty sounds: Van Horn’s convincing grief, Kelsey’s sympathetic ambivalence and longing. And they were well supported by soprano Ana María Martínez, who settled into the role of Boccanegra’s daughter after an unsteady start, and by tenor Richard Trey Smagur as an aching yet sturdy Adorno.

Somewhere in between Orth’s world premiere and Verdi’s classic was “Unholy Wars” at the Suzanne Roberts Theater, created by tenor Karim Sulayman. First performed at Spoleto Festival USA last year, it explores works of the late Renaissance and Baroque about the Middle East and the Crusades, with the aim of having the “other” — Sulayman, the child of Lebanese immigrants — embody othering music.

It’s an interesting idea, one that succeeds more musically than theatrically. The individual elements of “Unholy Wars” — Sulayman’s selection of works, which includes newly composed interludes by Mary Kouyoumdjian; Ebony Williams’ choreography, danced by Coral Dolphin; Kevin Newbury’s production of pouring water and sand; Kevork Mourad’s illustrative projections — assemble rather than cohere. And the performances tend to outshine everything else.

Julie Andrijeski directs the music: selections from Caccini, Monteverdi and more, ending with Handel and featuring, at its heart, the scena “Il Combattimento di Tancredi e Clorinda.” Sulayman, his voice angelic and affecting, intelligent and sincere, is joined, with equal commitment, by soprano Raha Mirzadegan and bass-baritone John Taylor Ward.

If “Unholy Wars” doesn’t always land, it always challenges — its 70 minutes worth experiencing, and especially worth hearing. And that, more than the safety of a season’s standard programming, is what we should want out of any festival, even in lean times.

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.

Today's News

October 17, 2023

Is a women's museum still relevant?

Schoelkopf Gallery to represent the Max Weber Foundation, a pioneering American Modernist

An X-Wing model from the original 'Star Wars' sells for $3.1 million

San Francisco Museum of Modern Art reveals newly added artworks in 'Infinite Love' by Yayoi Kusama

How 6 Italian brothers shaped the story of New York

Modern Art Museum of Fort Worth is now exhibiting 'Jaune Quick-to-See Smith: Memory Map'

Fondation Louis Vuitton to present first retrospective in France dedicated to Mark Rothko

Solo exhibition by Greek filmmaker and visual artist Janis Rafa on view at Eye Filmmuseum

'That Luscious Day' and 'Daguerreotypes: Up Close' open at PDNB Gallery

Bonhams Scotland celebrates the canine companion with the return of The Dog Sale

Discover the future of technology: artificial intelligence exhibition at the CCCB

Searching for America's first Black female novelist

LeVar Burton to host National Book Awards

Suzanne Somers, star of 'Three's Company,' is dead at 76

Opera Philadelphia cuts its budget, but not its ambition

Balanchine's gems were his dancers. He honored them with 'Jewels.'

Famed Iranian filmmaker is killed in his home

M.S. Rau's new gallery exhibition 'Erté & the Era of Art Deco' features 170 works by the 'Father of Art Deco'

The experience of communing featured in Joy Labinjo's 'Beloved, Take What You Need'

Mendes Wood DM, Paris, presents 'I See No Difference Between a Handshake and a Poem'

Omid Asadi has first major UK solo exhibition at Castlefield Gallery

Unusual Artwork by Famous Artists

The Sparkling Alliance: How Bitcoin and The U.S Art Repertoire are Carving Out New Ways of Engaging and Connecting

Ciambella Tea Cake: The Perfect Every-Day Treat

AI Art and implications to artists and the art world

The Most Interesting Museums for Visiting Students of Any Field

Maurizio D'Andrea: The Alchemy of Abstract in Contemporary Art

Unlocking the Puzzle: Why Crossword Enthusiasts Can't Get Enough

Why You Should Trust a Construction Injury Attorney for Legal Aid?

Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .


Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez

sa gaming free credit
Truck Accident Attorneys
Accident Attorneys

Royalville Communications, Inc

ignaciovillarreal.org juncodelavega.com facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. Hommage
to a Mexican poet.

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site Parroquia Natividad del Señor
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful