NEW YORK, NY.- Nobody becomes a choreographer because they love spreadsheets. The business side of dance budgeting, marketing, scheduling and fundraising can seem very far away from the in-the-body creative work of the studio and the stage.
During the 20th century dance boom, dance companies often formalized that divide. Relatively plentiful arts funding meant successful choreographers could hand over administrative duties to executive directors and their well-staffed teams. Maintaining a church-and-state separation even became a kind of artistic virtue: A working choreographer shouldnt let the practical distract from the creative. Recently, choreographer Dominic Moore-Dunson asked a mentor, an established dance maker, for marketing advice. The mentor told him not to worry: Your job is just to make the art.
But that is now no longer feasible, or even desirable, for most choreographers. Todays dance makers are far more likely to operate on a project-to-project basis because of limited resources, the desire for creative flexibility, or both. That means theyre often their own administrators; spreadsheets are very much a part of their everyday life. But the dance fields business best practices are decades old. And though there are a variety of grants and residencies to bolster choreographers creative endeavors, for a long time there was little support for the less-glamorous work of dance administration.
In 2020, the National Center for Choreography at the University of Akron in Ohio began the Creative Administration Research program to address that gap. The initiative challenges the perception of arts administration as a duty to be endured or delegated. Instead, said Christy Bolingbroke, the centers founding and artistic director, it proposes that choreographers use their considerable creative powers to help imagine structures better suited to their needs. Its expanding artists creative practice beyond just, I make dances, Bolingbroke said.
The Creative Administration Research program has helped 21 dance artists, including Moore-Dunson, envision different approaches to administration. A newly announced $1 million grant from the Mellon Foundation means the program will be able to mount a second phase over the next three years.
Most of the big-picture administrative challenges choreographers face, including scarce funding and dwindling audiences after pandemic shutdowns, arent unique to dance. But dance artists may be particularly well equipped to handle them.
Theres no playbook to follow in making a dance, or in dance thinking, said choreographer Silas Riener, who, with his longtime collaborator Rashaun Mitchell, participated in the first round of the Akron program. Which means dance artists, generally, are problem solvers. So theres a lot of ingenuity in the field, and now youre seeing that in the administrative practices.
Like its older peer, Florida State Universitys Maggie Allesee National Center for Choreography, the National Center for Choreography at the University of Akron offers several artistic programs and residencies. But building better infrastructure for dance has been a special focus for the Akron hub since its incorporation in 2015. Instead of following the typical residency model well give you some money and a space, you make a dance it aims to strengthen the larger dance ecosystem. We look at the foundations that people get to dance on and figure out how to fill in some of the cracks, so other people can have better footing, Bolingbroke said.
The Creative Administration Research program pairs choreographers with what it calls thought partners, collaborators who might be business-minded arts administrators, funders or presenters, but who also are often working artists. Composer and educator Byron Au Yong, who has been a thought partner for choreographers Raja Feather Kelly and Takahiro Yamamoto, said the breadth of that adviser pool sets the initiative apart.
There are business and marketing consultants out there, but unless you have an embodied, lived experience of working in the arts in the United States, how can you advise a dance artist? Au Yong said. There will always be a disconnect.
During a series of online retreats, each team reflects on how the choreographer makes work and what kind of structure might best support their process. The program has also hosted two summits, bringing several dozen artists and leaders to the centers University of Akron home to share their insights into creative administration. (And to dance together or to physicalize their administrative thinking and dreaming, as a news release said.)
For some participating choreographers, the initiative has prompted dramatic change. Banning Bouldin, who uses they/them pronouns, formerly ran their Nashville, Tennessee, organization, New Dialect, as a conventional dance company, though their goal was to create a dance hub for the city. A thought partner, John Michael Schert, helped Bouldin recognize that the company model only fit maybe 40% of what we were doing, Bouldin said, and that it was hampering the organizations community organizing and engagement efforts. Now, rather than employing a small roster of full-time dancers, New Dialect dedicates more resources to professional development workshops, residencies and performance production.
Philosophically, we made a really meaningful shift, Bouldin said. Were serving more artists and more of the community in a way thats financially sustainable.
Rosie Herrera, the director of Rosie Herrera Dance Theater, found that Creative Administration Research affirmed many of her existing ways of working. Through conversations with thought partners and other artists in the program, she said, she realized that as a Latina in Miami, who started out just making work with her friends, she had intuitively avoided many best practice traps.
There was no hierarchy in the company, and wed always done things like bartering you know, Ill dance in your drag show, you do costumes for my show, Herrera said. The program allowed her to choreograph time for reflection, to articulate how those practices had grown out of the inclusive values that also shape her artistic process.
Administrative insights sometimes seep back into creative work. Bouldin found that letting go of the company director role altered their perspective on studio practice; though they still choreograph, they now feel theyre a facilitator more than a leader. Ive gone from a sort of outside or in-front-of relationship to the artists that were working with to being inside of these teams and the groups, part of the community, they said.
In Creative Administration Researchs first phase, the National Center for Choreography team invited most of the choreographers. The second round of the program will feature open application periods, the first beginning Sept. 5. In addition to creating thought partner-choreographer teams, the 2.0 edition will also seed administrative experiments, Bolingbroke said, allowing artists to propose specific short-term projects renting a dedicated operational space, making a temporary administrative hire which the program will fund and facilitate. Between large national summits in Akron, the program will host smaller gatherings of artists and administrators in other cities around the country. And a book of essays on the programs findings is in the works.
Bolingbroke hopes these expanded efforts will help spread the gospel of creative administration not just outward, but also upward to larger arts institutions. There is only so much individual artists can do to fix administrative problems that are often systemic, especially in the wake of pandemic shutdowns.
Were in a scary place right now, with a lot of arts organizations cutting back or closing, Bolingbroke said. I think as a whole field, were going to have to re-imagine our way forward together.
Dance residency centers have not fared well in the post-shutdown reckoning. In January the American Dance Institute announced it was selling its Lumberyard campus, formerly an important dance incubator; in June, choreographer Stephen Petronio decided to shutter his residency center, which had been a haven for dance artists. The center in Akron has survived partly by applying the creative administration principles championed by its own programming.
During its eight years of existence, the center has tested out and rethought several administrative positions, seeking the right balance of stability and flexibility. (For a while, Bolingbroke was its only full-time employee.) That adaptive approach has helped the center weather an uncertain climate. In the past year, it has not contracted but expanded, adding more staff and programming.
As a young organization, we dont have too many Weve always done it that way habits that we have to let go of, Bolingbroke said. Were evolving alongside our artists.
Few choreographers emerge from the program with solutions to every administrative problem. But those problems feel less daunting, Moore-Dunson said, now that he thinks of administration as part of his art.
Before Creative Administration Research, there was admin over here and artistry over there, and I tried to spend as much of my time as possible on the artistic side, Moore-Dunson said. Now Ive started to see them as one and the same. Spreadsheets? Thats just the choreography of numbers. They tell a story, the same way the dance Im going to rehearse later tells a story.
This article originally appeared in
The New York Times.