NEW YORK, NY.- What comes to mind when you think of soap operas? Amnesia, murders, cliffhangers, catfights?
Think bigger.
Even judged by the standards of All My Children and Dynasty, Michael R. Jacksons satirical soap musical White Girl in Danger, which opened Monday at the Tony Kiser Theater, is a wild, raunchy, overstuffed tale.
Sure, it features amnesia and the rest, and mile-a-minute jokes, but the author of the Pulitzer Prize-winning A Strange Loop has also packed the nearly three hours of White Girl way too long with a thesis worth of insight and argument. By the time you get to the dildo slapping and the Hairspray parody, followed by the anguished yet hopeful finale, you no longer know what hilarious, despairing, muddle of a planet youre on.
Surely that was the plan. White Girl in Danger, directed by Lileana Blain-Cruz, is simultaneously set in a fictional soap opera world called Allwhite and a metaphorical one inhabited by ideas. Allwhite is dominated, of course, by its white characters: the high-school mean girls Meagan, Maegan and Megan (abused, bulimic, druggie), their mothers (smothering, manipulative, viperish) and their boyfriends (psychotic, supportive, dissolute). Among the girls especially, privilege is assumed; it allows them to choose their own adventures.
Their priorities are a little off, though. The most pressing issue they face as the insanely catchy title song kick-starts the action is not so much the discovery, every few minutes, of another white schoolmates body in the Allwhite woods. Its the way the deaths threaten their hopes of winning an upcoming battle of the bands. Who will be left to play autoharp?
The Black inhabitants of Allwhite have different problems. The Allwhite Writer (represented at first by thunderbolts and a voice-over) has consigned them to the Blackground, there to serve as friends, helpers and (in inexplicable historical flashbacks) enslaved people picking cotton. Mostly they are resigned to their fate; it may not be very fulfilling but, except for Police Violence Story Time, its relatively safe.
Thats not good enough for Keesha Erica Kane Gibbs (Latoya Edwards). Her ambition is to transcend the Blackground and get an Allwhite story of her own, even if it means becoming a victim or a villain: whichever one works.
This puts Keesha in conflict with the other Black characters, especially her mother, Nell Carter Gibbs (Tarra Conner Jones), who takes a more conservative approach as she rises from cafeteria lady to nurse and beyond. Also disapproving is Keeshas DAngelo-like ex-boyfriend, Tarik Blackwell (Vincent Jamal Hooper), who says shes hooked on that assimilation crack. More fatefully, her schemes set her on a collision course with the Allwhite Writer himself.
In Jacksons complex and cross-linked encyclopedia of ideas, Nell and Keesha stand for a multitude of distorted representations of Black women in white culture, soap operatic or otherwise. He loves those representations but also loathes them, usually in the same breath; the ambivalence is the motor of the shows satire, which scathes and kisses.
Nell is the more familiar case: Shes the Mammy figure from Gone With the Wind and the title character from Caroline, or Change, even though they are nothing alike. The 11 oclock number Jackson gives her, a ringer for I Know Where Ive Been from Hairspray, provides the same full-throated thrill (in Jones titanic performance) as Motormouth Maybelles did in the earlier show, even as Jackson punctures its uplift by recasting it as Thats Why I Kill.
And in Keeshas quest for an interblacktional bleminist movement that will liberate all Blackgrounds, Jackson needles the jargon of trauma and revolution and the bourgeois appropriation of victimhood he suggests it represents. Yet Keesha, as portrayed by the tireless Edwards, is also the eternal spirit of Black advancement spurred by bright young women from Beneatha Younger onward. It is not, we soon learn, just the Allwhite Writer who cant make up his mind.
If that leaves the characters confusing and hard to follow, well, they can join the club. Everything about White Girl in Danger is confusing and hard to follow. In the manner of soap operas, but with an absurdly fast twitch rate, personalities and plots get rewritten without notice. Theres very little for the actors to act except the twitch itself, which quickly grows tiresome through no fault of their own. Since most of them play three or more roles Liz Lark Brown as all the white mothers, Eric William Morris as all the white boyfriends they tend to blur into archetypes when they dont whirl into inconsequence.
Yet somehow the show remains compelling. Not because of the staging, which flags and other than Montana Levi Blancos parade of laugh-out-loud costumes is visually underpowered. (Even the constantly slamming doors wobble.) From Blain-Cruz and her set designer, Adam Rigg, who in last seasons The Skin of Our Teeth delivered many astonishments for the eyes, that comes as a surprise. Perhaps White Girl, despite being a coproduction of the Vineyard and Second Stage theaters, could not, on an off-Broadway budget, afford all its ambitions.
What keeps your attention most of the time as you watch, and certainly when thinking about it later, is the bounty and electricity of Jacksons ideas, which derive as much from his long history as a soap opera lover as from his complex approach to the underlying conflicts of race and gender.
Those conflicts, expressed in A Strange Loop through the voice and thoughts of just one character, are distributed more broadly in White Girl, a typical sophomore play problem (its chaotic and exhausting) but also an opportunity. Whether the opportunity can be exploited without exacerbating the problem, we must leave for future productions to discover. Stay tuned!
It was in any case an opportunity worth taking. A glance at some of the special thanks in small type in the program gives you a sense of the fascinating breadth of Jacksons high-low influences: Jackie Collins, Black musicals, Fine-Ass Oiled Up Mens, Soap Opera Digest, PC/un-PC/woke/anti-woke story lines, cultural neoliberalism and childhood loneliness.
You can pretty much feel them all in White Girl, especially when a figure whose identity I wont spoil (but is played beautifully by James Jackson Jr., one of the thoughts in A Strange Loop) arrives near the end as a kind of deus ex mess to untangle the shows themes. Though that proves impossible, his attempt reminds us that ambivalence of all kinds, about people and love and stories and theater, is not a failure no matter what world you live in. Nor is it a success. Its a start.
White Girl in Danger
At the Tony Kiser Theater in Manhattan; 2st.com. Running time: 2 hours 50 minutes.
This article originally appeared in
The New York Times.