NEW YORK, NY.-
You do not expect the star of a musical about a man lynched by an antisemitic mob to be his wife. Especially when that man, Leo Frank, who was murdered in Georgia in 1915, is played, with his usual intensity and vocal drama, by Ben Platt.
Yet, in the riveting Broadway revival of the musical Parade that opened Thursday at the Bernard B. Jacobs Theater, its Micaela Diamond, as Lucille Frank, you watch most closely and who breaks your heart. With no affectation whatsoever, and a voice directly wired to her emotions, she makes Lucille our way into a story we might rather turn away from.
True, this alters the balance of the show as originally staged by Harold Prince in 1998, further tipping it toward the marriage instead of the miscarriage of justice. Also toward the rapturous score by Jason Robert Brown, which won a Tony Award in 1999. But since the legal procedural was never the best part or even the point of Parade, the enhanced emphasis on a love story tested by tragedy and set to song is a big net gain.
Its strange, of course, to talk about net gains in relation to such a horrible tale. But Parade has always been strange anyway, seeking to make commercial entertainment out of a violent history and, because hes a victim, a hero of a nebbish.
As Alfred Uhrys book also a Tony winner relates, Leo, manager of a pencil factory owned by Lucilles uncle, is a misfit in Atlanta: a New York Jew but also a cold fish. In Platts highly physical interpretation, he is scrunched and sickly looking, as if literally oppressed by the gentile society around him. That Lucilles family, longtime Southerners, seems warmly assimilated into that society makes their marriage, at the start, a curdling of cream and vinegar.
Michael Ardens staging, imported with a slightly different cast from the City Center gala he directed in November, rightly relishes such contrasts. He signals the primacy of the love story by starting, in the 1860s, with sex: a young Confederate soldier bidding goodbye to his girl. A foreboding Dixie anthem called The Old Red Hills of Home leaps 50 years forward to connect the white Christian bigotry that fueled the Civil War to the war against Leo as well.
His troubles begin with the murder of Mary Phagan (Erin Rose Doyle), a 13-year-old white employee who works, for 10 cents an hour, fastening erasers to pencil caps. Lacking conclusive evidence and in dire need of a conviction, the district attorney, Hugh Dorsey (Paul Alexander Nolan), railroads Leo by suborning testimony from many sources: friends of Phagans; a cleaner at the factory (Alex Joseph Grayson); and even Minnie, the Franks maid (Danielle Lee Greaves). After a sensational trial that cynically pits Jewish Atlantans against Black ones, Leo is sentenced to hang.
When the first act ends on that awful note, we still do not know Leo well. His first song, usually in musicals a moment for ingratiation, is instead a bitter snit called How Can I Call This Home? His last before the verdict is Its Hard to Speak My Heart. Whatever that heart really holds is further blurred by Uhrys device of having Leo enact the false testimony of other characters, so we see him as a rake and a maniac before weve grasped him as a man.
Arden begins to correct for that during the intermission, which Leo, now imprisoned, spends sitting onstage with his head in his hands. In Act 2, as he recognizes his growing dependence on Lucille, she finally becomes real to him and thus he to us.
Its too bad that some of this enlightenment is achieved through huge elisions and license in relating what is still a contested history. Although its true that Georgias governor (Sean Allan Krill) opened an inquiry that led to the commutation of Leos death sentence but only to life in prison its doubtful he did so as a result of Lucilles buttonholing him at a tea dance. Nor that she accompanied him like a lay detective as he reinterviewed witnesses and obtained their recantations.
Even if true, its unconvincing here, presented almost as a series of Nancy Drew skits. Still, Diamond maintains her dignity, allowing the final phase of the tragedy in which Leo, after two years of appeals that are summarized in one line, is kidnapped from his cell and hanged to commence with the drama righted.
It is never wronged as long as Browns music plays.
In this, his first Broadway show, he demonstrates the astonishing knack for dirty pastiche that has informed such follow-ups as The Last Five Years, 13 and The Bridges of Madison County. Pastiche because of his inerrant ear for just the right genre to fit any situation, in this case including John Philip Sousa-style marches, work songs, blues, swing ditties for the factory girls, a dainty waltz for the governors party. Dirty because he roughs them up with post-Stephen Sondheim technique, scraping the surface to bring up the blood.
And as one of the few musical theater composers to write his own lyrics successfully, he gives singing actors something to act. He also manages to achieve in a rhyme what would otherwise take a scene of dialogue. As the politicians and journalists foment local hysteria and national media interest in the case, he gives two Black workers in the governors mansion a mordant triplet in the song A Rumblin and a Rollin: I can tell you this as a matter of fact / that the local hotels wouldnt be so packed / if a little Black girl had been attacked.
That the Black workers (Douglas Lyons and Courtnee Carter) are otherwise barely characterized is one of the more obvious signs that the shows book was written in the 20th century. (Uhry has made some revisions for this production.) Arden addresses this by keeping the ensemble as particular as possible, never letting it devolve into vague masses making generic gestures. And in minimizing the visual elements the set (by Dane Laffrey) is essentially a high platform on a low one, suggesting a witness box, a cell and a scaffold he keeps our attention on the people and what they sing.
If actual history plays second fiddle to that by the way, theres a terrific orchestra of 17 players, just two shy of the plush original current history steps in as a pretty good substitute. Not just in the guise of revitalized antisemitism, although the shows first preview, on Feb. 21, was greeted by a small gaggle of neo-Nazi demonstrators.
What struck me even more vividly in this well-judged and timely revival is the quick path hysteria has always burned through the American spirit if fanned by media, politicians and prejudice of any kind. When a chorus of white Georgians chants, Hang im, hang im, make him pay, the words cant help but echo uncomfortably in the post-Jan. 6, 2021, air. And another song, a prayer for a return of the day when the Southland was free, sounds a lot like current talk of a second secession.
Our historical wounds never really heal over. Although Franks death sentence was commuted, he was killed anyway and, as Parade points out, never exonerated. That case is ongoing.
Through Aug. 6 at the Bernard B. Jacobs Theater, Manhattan; paradebroadway.com. Running time: 2 hours, 30 minutes.
This article originally appeared in The New York Times