NEW YORK, NY.- How do we connect with people? How do we care for them? And what does it all cost, both fiscally and emotionally? These are just a few of the questions Martyna Majok poses in her wrenching 2018 Pulitzer Prize-winning play, Cost of Living, which opened Monday night at the Samuel J. Friedman Theater in Manhattan.
After debuting at the Williamstown Theater Festival in 2016, Cost of Living ran off-Broadway in 2017 in a Manhattan Theater Club production at New York City Center. Now Majok is making her Broadway debut, arriving with an impressive inventory of awards and praise for her poignant, socially conscious work, which includes Sanctuary City (2021) and Ironbound (2016).
In her Pulitzer Award citation, the committee wrote that Majok invites audiences to examine diverse perceptions of privilege and human connection. She does this whether exploring the worlds of immigrants living in the country without legal permission or working-class New Jerseyans holding on by a thread.
As Cost of Living begins, Eddie is certainly looking for connection and redemption, and a way out from under the specter of loneliness since his wifes death. On this particular night, he says, he has been stood up for a date with his dead wife, Ani. He sits on a stool center stage at a bar, a shelf of bottles adorned with multicolored string lights floating behind him.
What Eddie (an affable David Zayas), a 40-something unemployed truck driver from Bayonne, New Jersey, leaves out in this impromptu bar eulogy to his wife are the tough times: his years of alcoholism and then a separation.
From here the play, tenderly directed by Jo Bonney, jumps back in time, when Eddie and Ani are separated. Its a few months after a devastating accident left Ani (Katy Sullivan) a quadriplegic and double amputee. Eddie wants to help with her home care; Ani, resentful and depressed, wants to be left alone.
Not too far south of Bayonne, in Princeton, Jess (Kara Young) is struggling to stay above the poverty line. A recent alum of the Ivy League school, shes nevertheless interviewing for a job as an aide to John (Gregg Mozgala), a graduate student with cerebral palsy. Jess is direct but guarded when it comes to her life, and John is pretentious and calculating, although he gets Jess to open up with his knavish charm.
The plays scenes alternate between the two stories of these caregivers, with a turntable set that rotates from Anis criminally beige living room and bathroom to Johns upscale, modern apartment with towering windows and a gray-tiled, sit-in shower stall. (The polished scenic design is by Wilson Chin.) Bonneys deft negotiation of these separate settings and stories is just one of the ways Cost of Living impressively teeters between two main axes the body, and the economy of its care without toppling over.
Theres a satisfying parallelism to the dynamics between the two pairs the chemistry, the witty repartee, the heartbreak one character offers, intentionally or unintentionally, to another. Each twosome exists in their separate bubbles of Jersey life until they finally intersect. And yet Majoks sharp writing is never predictable; even when she seems to be leading us down the path to a conventional love story, she pivots and offers an unexpected development like a wife who sends texts from beyond the grave or a romantic invitation that turns out to be a slick power play.
Bonneys direction adds an extra layer of cohesion to the story: subtle connections that bridge the worlds, like Eddie and Jess each walking separately to the same gentle patter of rainfall on a stormy day (sound design by Rob Kaplowitz).
Each of the four cast members performs with a three-dimensional pop of life. Eddies insistent affection and optimism is comically at odds with Anis dry deadpan. Sullivans fiery Ani speaks in a kind of poetry of insults and expletives. Youngs Jess is bright, brusque and uncompromising, even when her life is going sideways. And Mozgala portrays John as someone who is slippery, coy and clever, with a shadiness beneath.
Majoks script insists on the casting of diverse and disabled actors, helping to deepen an affecting work that readily breaks your heart, drags you through hurt and then kisses you on the forehead, sending you off with a laugh.
This play left me breathless, and Im not just using a manner of speech. As I made my way through the crowd of people exiting the theater, I took hard, shallow breaths, knowing that one deep inhale could set off a downpour of tears. This production either broke or mended something in me; I felt brilliantly, painfully, cathartically near the point of physical exhaustion.
It seems as if the tears, the chuckles, the full body ache of feeling is the currency of an outstanding work of art. We give nearly two hours of attention, and great theater offers us empathy and humanity in return: riches of which even the worlds wealthiest can only dream.
Cost of LivingThrough Oct. 30 at the Samuel J. Friedman Theater, Manhattan; manhattantheatreclub.com. Running time: 1 hour, 40 minutes.
This article originally appeared in
The New York Times.