NEW YORK (NYT NEWS SERVICE).-
Mexican cinema was just emerging from decades of obscurity when Alfonso Cuaróns Y Tu Mamá También, a voyage of self-discovery and the study of a country in flux, was released there in 2001, instantly achieving landmark status.
The film, structured as a road trip from Mexico City to a paradisiacal beach in Oaxaca, revolves around a love triangle involving the upper-class teenager Tenoch (Diego Luna), his humbler best friend, Julio (Gael García Bernal), and a Spanish visitor, Luisa (Maribel Verdú). She challenges the boys nascent notions of manhood against the backdrop of a society getting its first taste of democracy after seven decades under the rule of the Institutional Revolutionary Party, known as the PRI.
The movie, which smashed box office records in Mexico before debuting at the Venice Film Festival that August, represented a return for the director, not only to Mexico after a stint in Hollywood but also to his passion for cinema. And it saw the birth of cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezkis naturalistic film grammar. But the films larger effect resides in the sexual openness it depicted, resulting in the most restrictive rating from the Mexican government; its tacit questioning of traditional masculinity in a culture where machismo is ingrained; and its incisive treatment of class issues in a nation of painful inequalities.
I spoke with the far-flung stars and filmmakers, including Carlos Cuarón, the directors brother, who co-wrote the Oscar-nominated screenplay, about their memories of making the film, the changes it brought to their careers and the reception in Mexico at the time, when the carnal encounter between the two boys was controversial. These are edited excerpts from those conversations.
Q: Where were you in your career when Y Tu Mamá También happened? Was it a turning point?
ALFONSO CUARÓN: At that point I had let the industry seduce me and thats where my confusion started because I forgot about cinema. Its a myth that the industry corrupts you, you corrupt yourself. Making my first movie in Hollywood, A Little Princess , was wonderful, but then I made another movie, Great Expectations , that I never understood. I started watching a lot of movies I had loved. Thats when I called my brother and said, Lets write a movie.
CARLOS CUARÓN: Y Tu Mamá También was a conceptual idea that Alfonso and I had even before his first movie, Sólo con tu pareja. The movie is inspired by those trips that we take in adolescence. What neither my brother nor I did was do that with a beautiful Spanish woman. [Laughs] We were working on it for about 10 years while apart. But then a really nice project Alfonso had in the U.S. fell apart and here in Mexico what was going to be my debut feature also fell apart. Alfonso lived in New York and he called me. What if we make Y Tu Mamá También? I flew to New York using his frequent flyer miles and we got to work. [Laughs]
DIEGO LUNA: This was the first time I realized [I] could have a reach that I didnt imagine possible. I grew up mostly in theater in Mexico and thinking mostly in the context of my community there. But Y Tu Mamá was like an awakening for me. What struck me the hardest was the distance that developed between my family and friends and I after this movie. I started to work in other countries, to spend long periods away from home to the point that I questioned where my home really was. That can be exciting, but it was also anguishing because you feel lost, like you dont belong anywhere.
GAEL GARCÍA BERNAL: When I made Amores Perros [his first movie, in 2000] I discovered this universe without knowing anything about the craziness of moviemaking. With Y Tu Mamá También, Alfonso was at a moment in his life where he was very open to including us actors throughout the process for over a year. We learned the basics of cinema! What Ive taken with me into every movie I make is that as an important requirement there should be a sense of fraternity like the one we had then.
MARIBEL VERDÚ: Ive been working since I was 13, so I would have kept on working in Latin America and in my country regardless, but thanks to Y Tu Mamá También I became known abroad. It wasnt only that I gained international recognition for any movie, but this prestigious and significant movie. I got to know Mexico thanks to [Alfonso] and eventually made other films with Mexican directors.
Q: What do you believe are some of the reason that made Y Tu Mamá También a success?
ALFONSO CUARÓN: One part is obvious. Putting teenagers in situations that include sex will always be attractive to a certain audience. But I hope Y Tu Mamá También transcended that, because we set out to not be American Pie. We wanted the sex scenes to get a point across about these characters and about the social elements we were playing with, like class and the conceptions of masculinity that these characters have.
CARLOS CUARÓN: That portrait of adolescence with its failures and virtues, the narrator who doesnt narrate but contextualizes things and helped us avoid explanatory scenes, the enormous chemistry between Diego and Gael and the counterpoint that Maribel provided were some of the many factors. None of us who made it thought it would have such success. When we wrote the screenplay, we didnt know who would dare make it.
LUNA: This is a great movie, of course, but not all great movies arrive in the correct moment. Y Tu Mamá También had such luck. It found an audience that needed a journey like the one the movie proposes. The movie speaks of fundamental relationships and its very easy to reflect yourself in it. Its also a movie that portrays a Mexico that seemed to be hidden before. The way it depicts the economic inequality and class conflict was very painful for some to see back then. I remember a lot of people complained, Why do you portray Mexico this way? But at the same time it portrayed the beauty that the country has to offer.
GARCÍA BERNAL: It caused a schism within the Mexican audience. Many people connected positively with the movie but it angered the pearl-clutchers. [Laughs] Some audiences projected a certain discomfort with the sexual openness or with the fact that the movie touched on gay themes in an ambiguous way. All of that created a dialogue. Outside Mexico what transcended was the desire to live that this movie instills in you. When you come out of the theater, you want to head to the beach and go on a crazy adventure.
VERDÚ: I believe its authenticity. Its a movie that feels like a documentary. It looks like something improvised, but theres so much work behind it. There [were] rehearsals to have it all very tight, but to make it seem like everything was just happening in front of us. Thats so magical and audiences felt that too.
Q: We are currently having a reckoning on masculinity. Back then, were you thinking about what the relationship between these two young men said on the subject?
ALFONSO CUARÓN: I talked a lot about this with Guillermo del Toro, with Carlos and Chivo [Emmanuel Lubezki]. It would be pretentious to say the discussions were about masculinity, because those conversations happen more now, but without using that language we were trying to explore that. At some point it becomes more obvious. Theres a moment in which Luisa tells them, The only thing you want is to have sex with each other.
CARLOS CUARÓN: I vividly remember that at the premiere in Mexico City people cursed and whistled when Diego and Gael kissed. During that premiere, a gay friend, a theater and film director, said, Thank you for showing clearly the image of the Mexican macho for the first time. I asked him what that image was and he said, Julio and Tenoch kissing.
LUNA: We always said that we were making a love story between the two men. In the debates about the ending, people wanted us to label what it meant. The movie suggests things but leaves that decision up to the audience. Thats what good movies do. They make questions. They dont give answers.
GARCÍA BERNAL: The 2000s were a watershed. The youth at the time, including myself, started having a very different vision of sex and the lines of division between genders started disappearing, given that masculinity was and is in a tremendous crisis. Im convinced this movie couldnt have been done in the U.S. In Mexico we have greater freedom of expression in cinema because we can put things together more independently.
VERDÚ: On that front the movie was ahead of its time. It shows things that no one did back then. No one dared.
Q: In the final scene, the narrator tells us Tenoch and Julio never saw each other again. Do you trust the narrator or do you think they did reconnect?
LUNA: I dont believe the narrator. I think they did meet again somehow. Its hard to think that they didnt. Curiosity probably brought them back together. Thats what I want to believe because in life nothing is definitive.
ALFONSO CUARÓN: Ive questioned that. At some point Carlos and I talked about the possibility of making a movie about [them] but now in their forties. Unfortunately I think it would be too sad. I have a bit of a pessimistic view on life. Tenoch probably followed in his fathers footsteps, not as a politician but as a banker. And I dont think Julio had a good relationship with women. But they both have a beautiful spirit and theres a possibility they reconnect and what unites them are the things missing in their lives. Perhaps talking about the past acts as a catalyst for the second part of their lives. Thats a nice way to look at it. Maybe Diego is right.
CARLOS CUARÓN: If the narrator says it, then they never saw each other again. If they [did] it was probably by accident. I truly believe that life separated them. I dont think they ever saw each other again not because they hated each other, but because they loved each other too much.
GARCÍA BERNAL: Im sure they met again, but the narrator says what their parents would want to say. Now that we are over 40, we should probably do a reunion between Julio and Tenoch.
VERDÚ: They never ever saw each other again. Im convinced. Their relationship wasnt real. You see it, for example, when one goes into the others home and he lifts the toilet seat with his foot as to not to touch it. They came from different backgrounds. They went on a trip with that Spanish woman and they enjoyed it as part of the sexual awakening. She united them for that moment, then she disappeared, and they disappeared from each others lives. And thats that.
This article originally appeared in The New York Times