NEW YORK (NYT NEWS SERVICE).-
Milton Moses Ginsberg, who directed two ambitious but eccentric films before falling into obscurity, one about the meltdown of a psychiatrist and the other about a press aide in a Nixon-like administration who becomes a murderous werewolf, died on May 23 in his apartment in Manhattan. He was 85.
The cause was cancer, said his wife, Nina Ginsberg.
Milton Ginsberg, a film editor determined to make his own movies, wrote and directed Coming Apart (1969), a raw black-and-white film that used a single, almost entirely static camera to document the loveless trysts and psychological disintegration of a psychiatrist, played by Rip Torn, who surreptitiously records his encounters with a camera inside a mirrored box.
Coming Apart received mixed reviews, at best. But the one that devastated Ginsberg was from The Village Voices Andrew Sarris, who wrote that if everybody in the cast had refused to strip for action or inaction, Coming Apart would have crumbled commercially into a half-baked amateur movie incapable of selling enough tickets to fill a phone booth.
Ginsberg blamed that review for the films box-office failure.
That was it, he told The New York Times in 1998, adding: I had done everything I wanted to do. And nothing happened.
He followed Coming Apart in 1973 with another low-budget film: The Werewolf of Washington, a campy political parody inspired by the classic horror film The Wolf Man (1941), which terrified Ginsberg as a boy, and by President Richard M. Nixon, who terrified him as a man.
In Ginsbergs film, released more than a year into the Watergate scandal, Dean Stockwell plays an assistant press secretary who turns into a werewolf at inopportune moments, like when hes bowling with the president, and murders characters based on Katharine Graham, the publisher of The Washington Post, and Martha Mitchell, the outspoken wife of Attorney General John N. Mitchell.
The film isnt advertised as a documentary, syndicated columnist Nicholas von Hoffman wrote, but when you think about whats been going on around this town, you couldnt tell it from the plot.
In 1975, after Ginsberg received a diagnosis of non-Hodgkins lymphoma, he fell into a depression that lifted only after he met and married Nina Posnansky, a painter, in 1983. She and his brother, Arthur, survive him.
After the commercial failure of his feature films, Ginsberg returned to film editing. He worked on various projects, including the Oscar-winning documentaries Down and Out in America (1986), about unemployed and homeless people left behind in the economy, which was directed by actress Lee Grant, and The Personals (1998), about a group of older people in a theater group.
He was in limbo, he wrote in Film Comment in 1999, for having made Coming Apart, which he wryly called murder on an audience.
So if oblivion is what you crave, for both yourself and your movie, follow me! he added.
Ginsberg never made another feature, but in recent years he finished several short video essays, among them Kron: Along the Avenue of Time (2011), a phantasmagorical exploration of his life taken through a microscopic journey into intricate watch movements.
Milton Moses Ginsberg was born on Sept. 22, 1935, in the Bronx. His father, Elias, was a cutter in the garment district, and his mother, Fannie (Weis) Ginsberg, was a homemaker.
After graduating from the Bronx High School of Science, Ginsberg received a bachelors degree in literature from Columbia University. Italian films like Fellinis La Dolce Vita (1960) inspired him to make movies, but in the 1960s he worked instead as a film editor at NBC News, held a production job with documentarians Albert and David Maysles, and was an assistant at Candid Camera, the popular television series that used concealed cameras to capture people in various situations, which he said influenced the furtive recording of the psychiatrists guests in Coming Apart.
Ginsbergs disappointment at the response to his features was eased somewhat when the Museum of Modern Art screened Coming Apart in 1998. But he was too pained by its reception nearly 30 years before to watch it; he did not enter the theater until it ended, when he spoke to the audience. MoMA has shown it a few times since.
It was like nothing Id ever seen, Laurence Kardish, the former longtime senior curator of MoMAs film department, who had seen Coming Apart during its original release, said by phone. It was very explicit and very raw and struck me as an essential New York film, showing a New Yorkers enthusiasm for self-examination.
When Coming Apart was released on video in 2000, an article in The Chicago Tribune called it stylistically audacious. And in 2011, the Brooklyn Academy of Music screened both of Ginsbergs films. After its associate curator, Jacob Perlin, moved to Metrograph, the repertory theater on the Lower East Side, where he is now the artistic and programming director, he held a 50th-anniversary screening of Coming Apart in 2019. Restorations of both of Ginsbergs movies have been completed by the film company Kino Lorber.
The belated acceptance of his films offered some redemption to Ginsberg.
In 2011, Milton said that hes had two afterlives, Perlin, who became friends with Ginsberg, said by phone. When MoMA showed Coming Apart, and 2011, when I showed both his films.
This article originally appeared in The New York Times