Are art and science forever divided? Or are they one and the same?
The First Art Newspaper on the Net    Established in 1996 Thursday, September 19, 2024


Are art and science forever divided? Or are they one and the same?
A horoscope from 15th century Iran, the Book of the Birth of Iskandar, from “Mapping the Infinite: Cosmologies Across Cultures,” at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art. Created with scientists’ help, it explores attempts to explain the universe’s origins. (The Wellcome Collection’s Open Access Program; Museum Associates/LACMA via The New York Times)

by Jason Farago



NEW YORK, NY.- One spring morning, one wet English morning, John Keats looked up at a rainbow and felt nothing.

The colors that streaked across the sky in Hampstead should have awed him, as they awed people of centuries past — when Noah saw the rainbow as proof of the Lord’s covenant, or when Norsemen believed the rainbow linked this realm to the world of the gods. But by the early 19th century, all Keats could see in the rainbow were optical, verifiable facts. His countryman Isaac Newton had proved that the colors were just sunlight refracted on water droplets, each wavelength bent at a different angle. This was the scientific disenchantment that the young Romantic described in his 1819 poem “Lamia”:

There was an awful rainbow once in heaven:

We know her woof, her texture; she is given

In the

dull

catalogue of common things.

Philosophy will clip an Angel’s wings,

Conquer all mysteries by rule and line,

Empty the haunted air, and gnomed mine —

Unweave a rainbow …

Culture and religion, dreams and angels: for Keats, by 1819, they had all been unwoven. Their poetry had been zeroed out by the cold calculations of physics (or natural “philosophy,” to use his word). And as the modern gospel of progress and rationalization continued to “conquer all mysteries,” artists and scientists began to look at each other with a mutual incomprehension — even disdain — that British author and chemist C.P. Snow notoriously diagnosed in 1959 as “two cultures.” Art imagines, science answers: and the answer is final.

But go ask Aristotle: Art and science were not always opposites. The Renaissance was an art/science crossover. Without Charles Darwin and Albert Einstein there is no modernism. “PST ART: Art & Science Collide,” the biggest artistic event of the fall season, is all about these two complementary curiosities — and in Los Angeles this September, where Keats would have most likely encountered disappointing rainbows at a West Hollywood happy hour, the denizens of California’s studios and laboratories are going to get to know each other a little better. Nearly 70 exhibitions, of antiquities and contemporary production, in museums and at universities and research centers, will put science in a new frame, and art under the microscope.

Originally called Pacific Standard Time, “PST Art” is an initiative of the Getty — the richest art institution on earth, and among the most intellectually ambitious — to produce a synchronized showcase of Southern Californian cultural clout. This is its third full-scale edition since 2011, and this fall the Getty will be presenting no fewer than nine PST exhibitions, including “Lumen: The Art & Science of Light,” a survey of optics and religion in medieval Jewish, Christian and Islamic art, as well as an overview of Experiments in Art and Technology, a 1960s organization that brought leading American artists to Bell Labs. (Both shows opened Sept. 10.)

But this interdisciplinary festival stretches far beyond the Getty’s Brentwood acropolis. The Getty has committed $20.4 million to institutions large and small in Southern California, and, from the desert to the ocean, PST places a particular emphasis on research-driven exhibitions. There are shows of 1,500-year-old manuscripts and 20th-century aerospace technology, of botanical intricacy and digital minimalism.

At the Palm Springs Art Museum, “Particles and Waves: Southern California Abstraction and Science, 1945-1990” (from Sept. 14) examines how the astronomers at the Mount Wilson Observatory and the aeronautics engineers at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Pasadena inspired painters and sculptors in Cold War L.A. Similar correspondences animate “Crossing Over: Art and Science at Caltech, 1920-2020” (at six locations at the California Institute of Technology, from Sept. 27), which will present rare books of astronomy by Johannes Kepler and Nicolaus Copernicus and a new installation by Helen Pashgian, a California sculptor who worked at the science institute in the late 1960s. “Wonders of Creation: Art, Science, and Innovation in the Islamic World,” at the San Diego Museum of Art, assembles miniatures, maps, carvings and navigational instruments to illuminate an intellectual tradition in which art and science were not at odds (from Sept. 7).

A notable through-line of this year’s PST is surveillance technology: a science of images, in which a picture’s beholder might now be an artificial intelligence. The Wende Museum, a small historical archive of Eastern Bloc art and memorabilia in Culver City, gathers police manuals, Stasi photography, and early facial recognition apparatuses in “Counter/Surveillance: Control, Privacy, Agency” (from Oct. 12). UCR Arts, on the campus of the University of California, Riverside, puts contemporary art in the context of the 1960s development of digital imaging technology in “Digital Capture: Southern California and the Pixel-Based Image World” (from Sept. 21).

The surveillance theme points to a surprising, and somewhat dispiriting, aspect of this year’s PST: for all its promises of interdisciplinarity, much of the newest art that will be on view seems skeptical at best about science. The festival’s exhibitions of ancient, medieval, and modern art treat astronomy, botany or meteorology as progressive enterprise, efforts to discover new horizons. But contemporary artists seem weirdly afraid of the sort of knowledge deduced in laboratories today, and much more comfortable with science fiction, atavistic rituals and hippie alternatives.

“Scientia Sexualis,” a group survey at the Institute of Contemporary Art from Oct. 5, turns to artists with “speculative” approaches to sex and gender, who reimagine bodies from “the way they have been historically defined by science.” Further speculations take place in “Sci-Fi, Magick, Queer L.A.,” at the library of the University of Southern California, which apparently encompasses “a Halloween cosplay event.” Ancestralism and spiritualism will be rife this year; one PST show invokes “ancient wisdom,” another one “fire kinship,” and even the stentorian Getty is presenting an astrology exhibition. It all makes PST — or at least its contemporary side — sound less suited to the Salk Institute in La Jolla than the Erewhon organic grocery store on Venice Boulevard.

But contemporary science, as today’s best artists already understand, is neither an objective truth machine nor a western colonial conspiracy. It’s a human endeavor, which works best when it aims at the refinement of earlier knowledge and worst when it purports to answer things once and for all. That human understanding is what has recently led Pierre Huyghe, in exhibitions in Venice and Seoul, South Korea, to apply the latest neuroscience into his visual vocabulary, and Torkwase Dyson to integrate new climate research into her sculptural practice. It’s why painters like Laura Owens and Jacqueline Humphries adopt digital technologies of image compression and distortion when they turn to the canvas. That humanity is no less valid in the laboratories. The neuroscientists aiming to demystify consciousness, the quantum researchers who isolated a “God particle,” and the genomists troubling the frontiers of life span are broaching questions only a poet can truly answer.

Because when it comes to science, art can go to extremes: It is either too credulous or too skeptical. In one corner are the hustlers who keep promising “an intersection of art and technology,” lately typified by the kitsch debacles of the NFT boom and bust or the dopey image engines of AI. In the other are the mystics who caricature the scientific method as an instrument of oppression, and celebrate art as the province of alternative facts. These are twin problems with a common derivation — one that Keats, looking up at his rainbow, would have recognized. Art and science have become bare synonyms for imagination and reasoning. But both modes of inquiry require both modes of thinking.

In her eye-opening, discipline-jumping 2017 book “True Enough,” philosopher Catherine Z. Elgin argues that the sciences do not arrive at truth as such, but do something more valuable: They “advance understanding of the phenomena they bear on,” often through models that are not so much true as revealing. “In laboratory experiments, scientists simplify, streamline, manipulate, and omit,” Elgin writes. They assume molecules are perfect spheres, or pretend surfaces have no friction, “to disclose barely detectable or standardly overshadowed aspects of nature.” The scientist idealizes, approximates, prototypes; sometimes, as when Newton imagined shooting a cannonball into orbit, he invents thought experiments that could never take place at all.

These scientific imaginings — what Elgin calls “felicitous falsehoods” — do not actually aim toward absolute truth, but a perpetual refinement of the lenses and models through which we understand the world. Which is an argument that should make artists prick up their ears.

What if we set aside the aim of reconciling two supposed domains of art and science, and tried to reconceive the theories of knowledge that govern both? Eratosthenes’ calculation of the Earth’s circumference and Homer’s evocation of a planetary ocean, Einstein’s theory of relativity and Pablo Picasso’s fractured guitar, the rainbows in Keats’ poetry and the rainbows in Newton’s laboratory, are all in their way ideal representations. They are all models that spotlight what waking life leaves in shadow.

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.










Today's News

September 12, 2024

French ship that sank in 1856 disaster is found off Massachusetts coast

'Extra! Extra!: News Photographs from 1908-1975' opens at Howard Greenberg Gallery

Fontaine's Auction Gallery to offer Fine & Decorative Arts Sept. 28-29

Petroliana & Advertising auction at Miller & Miller Auctions, Ltd. featured 309 lots and grossed $683,308

They said her music was too exotic. Now she's a classical star.

Juilliard receives $20 million to unite disciplines and support jazz

Prison where Capote interviewed killers for 'In Cold Blood' will open to tourists

Andréhn-Schiptjenko opens its first solo-exhibition by British-Nigerian artist Ranti Bam

The Belvedere opens Kazuko Miyamoto's largest international retrospective to date

V&A celebrates 100 years of theatre and performance with new free display

Amy Sherald, brazen optimist

First US retrospective of Art Deco icon Tamara de Lempicka premieres in San Francisco

Solo exhibition of new works by Albert Oehlen opens at Galerie Max Hetzler

Art shows and exhibitions to see this fall

Exhibition features street photography by Michael Silberman

Art gallery to explore Indigenous culture throughout fall in new exhibit

The lost museum in the Mauritshuis

Museum Ludwig announces 'Schultze Projects #4-Kresiah Mukwazhi'

Yesterday's Broadway warhorses, saddled with today's concerns

Seeing the fashion world through the eyes of an 8-year-old

Why do Americans want to dress like Swedes?

Are art and science forever divided? Or are they one and the same?

Xavier Hufkens opens an exhibition dedicated to Jan Vercruysse

Boosting Productivity with AI-Driven PDF Reading Solutions

Harnessing Chat PDF GPT for Smarter Document Handling

The Rise of Online Betting in Singapore: A New Way to Unwind

Why Affordable Follower Packages are the Secret to Instagram Success

5 Common Techniques Used in Filmmaking

Luxury Caribbean Experiences: From Private Villas to Exclusive Tours

Cross-Boundary Innovation: Qiwei Li Forges a Design Legend with Exceptional Articles

6 Precautions to Take Before Renting a Furnished Property

How Art Can Help When Dealing With a Cancer Diagnosis

Why Regular Commercial Cleaning is Essential for Your Business

The Influence Of Design On Modern Road Safety

From Chaos to Clarity: Untangling Complex Pay Structures with Compensation Management Software

Vancouver's Most Common Appliance Issues: What to Watch Out For and How to Fix Them

Top 5 Reasons Dallas Businesses Are Switching to Managed IT Services in 2024

The Environmental Benefits of Choosing Professional Laundry Services

Choosing the Right Size for Your Roofer Dumpster Rental

Choosing the Right Kitchen Plumbing Services: What Every Homeowner Should Know

The Top Causes of Water Pressure Problems in Homes

Advantages of Frameless Glass Shower Enclosures for Modern Bathrooms

Making the Switch: A Complete Guide to Tub-to-Shower Conversion Remodeling

The Benefits of Professional Carpet and Upholstery Cleaning for Healthier Homes

Gunite vs. Fiberglass: Deciding on the Best Pool Construction Method for Your Home

The Benefits of Free Junk Car Removal Services

Top Hardscaping Services to Elevate Your Outdoor Living Space

Top Reasons to Invest in Professional Move In/Out Cleaning Services

Roof Installation 101: What Homeowners Need to Know Beforehand

Gutter Cleaning: The Key to Preventing Water Damage and Ensuring Longevity




Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 



Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez
Writer: Ofelia Zurbia Betancourt

Attorneys
Truck Accident Attorneys
Accident Attorneys

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org juncodelavega.com facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site Parroquia Natividad del Señor
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful