Poland's art world awaits a culture war counteroffensive
The First Art Newspaper on the Net    Established in 1996 Friday, November 8, 2024


Poland's art world awaits a culture war counteroffensive
The Law and Justice party tried to reshape the country via the arts. Now that it appears set to lose office, its critics are split over how to move on. (Maciek Nabrdalik/The New York Times)

by Alex Marshall



NEW YORK, NY.- Just weeks after becoming Poland’s culture minister, in 2015, Piotr Glinski began a yearslong effort to shift his country’s cultural life toward the political right.

He ousted liberal museum directors, replacing them with conservatives. He created new institutions to celebrate traditional culture and nationalist heroes. And along with other lawmakers from his party, Law and Justice, he launched broadsides against movies, plays and pop stars that criticized the Catholic Church or the government’s policies on issues including immigration.

Many artists and cultural leaders opposed Glinski’s actions, and there were protests throughout his term, including outside Poland’s National Museum after a leader he had appointed removed sexually suggestive artworks from the walls.

Pawel Sztarbowski, the deputy director at the Powszechny Theater, in Warsaw, Poland, said that Glinski had tried to “return Poland to an imaginary past.”

Now, that project may be coming to an end. After opposition parties won a majority of parliamentary seats in the recent general election, Polish cultural figures are calling on what is expected to be a coalition government dominated by centrist parties to reverse Glinski’s agenda. But they are split over how to do that without entrenching political interference in the arts, which they have spent nearly a decade protesting.

Jaroslaw Suchan, a former director of the Museum of Art in Lodz, Poland, whose contract was not renewed by the Law and Justice government, said that the party had “treated culture as an ideological weapon.” But if a new government simply fired Glinski’s appointees, “they’d be repeating the last government’s behaviors.”

“We have to think of the long term,” Suchan said, instead of seeking revenge.

More than three weeks since the Oct. 15 election, it is still uncertain when Law and Justice will leave office. Under the country’s constitution, President Andrzej Duda, a Law and Justice ally, has 30 days to ask a party to form a new government, although he has not done it yet. In the power vacuum, Law and Justice supporters have been trying to derail the decision by questioning the legitimacy of the vote.

Observers of Polish politics expect that Donald Tusk, the leader of Civic Coalition, the largest opposition party, will eventually be asked to lead a new government in alliance with several other groups.

Before the vote, Civic Coalition said in a manifesto that it would abolish the “censorship of Polish culture” and ensure that institutions that presented controversial work kept their grants. The party also promised that it would not appoint political figures to run cultural organizations, although the manifesto gave no further details. A spokesperson for Civic Coalition did not respond to an interview request.

Current and former museum and theater leaders said in interviews that they were hoping for more significant change.




The most pressing issue, according to Piotr Rypson, the chair of the Polish branch of the International Council of Museums, is the leadership of three important museums, which he said had been handed over to Law and Justice sympathizers: the Ujazdowski Castle Center for Contemporary Art and the Zacheta National Gallery of Art, both in Warsaw, as well as the Museum of Art in Lodz.

Rypson said two of those leaders were “incompetent,” and that the third, the Ujazdowski Castle’s director, Piotr Bernatowicz, had displayed artworks out of step with his institution’s traditions. Bernatowicz, whose contract runs through 2027, has staged several exhibitions featuring artists whose work focuses on conservative political hobbyhorses. He did not respond to emailed interview requests.

Malgorzata Omilanowska, who was culture minister in a center-right government before Law and Justice took office, said that the three appointees were a “real embarrassment” and had marginalized their museums within Poland.

They had also had an effect on Poland’s reputation abroad, she added, not least because they had just helped choose the country’s representative for next year’s Venice Biennale. Their pick, announced Oct. 31, was painter Ignacy Czwartos, with a show focused on Polish victims of German and Russian aggression, events often highlighted by Law and Justice. One of the works he proposes showing in Venice, for example, will depict Angela Merkel and Vladimir Putin on either side of a burning swastika.

In an email exchange, Andrzej Biernacki, the current director of the Museum of Art in Lodz, said that Poland’s art world was intolerant of artists with conservative views and its institutions had favored Western artists to the detriment of the country’s own. That’s why, he said, he refocused the museum’s budget to acquire works by Polish, rather than international, artists, buying or securing as donations nearly 1,000 pieces.

Janusz Janowski, the director of the Zacheta National Gallery of Art, said in an email that he has also shifted his museum’s focus toward contemporary Polish art, including through “collaborating with eminent artists, even those who might not necessarily align with the artistic ‘mainstream.’”

Janowski and Biernacki both said that they would be staying in their posts, and that their contracts ran until the end of 2025. Biernacki added that if the new government tried to remove him early, it would be breaking the law.

In an emailed statement, Glinski, the culture minister, said that he had simply replaced museum directors when their contracts expired. “Polish culture was dramatically underinvested” when he came to office, he said, and he had refocused the country’s institutions to foster a sense of national identity and patriotism — something “all wise and responsible states” do. Ukraine would have been quickly defeated by Russia without its “strong Ukrainian patriotism,” Glinski added.

The bullish statement summed up the past eight years with pride: “The scale of our achievements — of this great institutional change in Polish culture — has no precedent either in contemporary Polish politics or in contemporary culture.”

His critics see it differently, yet even among those who desire a cultural reset, there are some aspects of Glinski’s tenure that few want to lose. Suchan, the ousted Lodz museum director, said that under Glinski culture was “at the center of politics” — a position it never held under liberal governments, for whom it was often an afterthought. The culture ministry’s budget doubled during Law and Justice’s eight years in office, Suchan added, and Glinski secured funding to set up a host of new institutions — including museums, an opera company and various grant-making bodies.

The new coalition government should maintain that funding, Suchan added. If nothing else, Law and Justice had showed that “culture isn’t a waste of money,” he said, adding that “it plays an important role in creating citizens, and shaping society.” That, he said, was “one lesson” everyone in Poland, liberal or conservative, could take from the past eight years.

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.










Today's News

November 7, 2023

Were these artworks looted? After seizures and lawsuits, some still debate

Use of AI worries those who create covers for books

'Masterpieces' find new homes in Slotin Auction's Fall Self-Taught Sale

The novel source for this space mystery? A novel.

Bonhams celebrates its first sale on the island of Ireland with the Irish Sale: Vision & Voice

Five wounded as Russian missiles strike Odesa, damaging an art museum

Bundanon unveils new exhibition season

What the Golden Gate is (finally) doing about suicides

Pace opens an exhibition of new paintings by artist and musician Brice Guilbert

Five decades of Claude Viallat's work on view at Templon Brussels

Behind the gates of a private world for only the wealthiest New Yorkers

MACRO - Museum of Contemporary Art of Rome presents "Alexander Brodsky: Depth of field"

Power and fantasy unite at Dutch national museum Paleis Het Loo

60 years on: JFK's diary among Kennedy memorabilia up for auction this week

Poland's art world awaits a culture war counteroffensive

Zdenek Macal, conductor with an international reach, dies at 87

Halls Fine Art offer sculpture from landmark series by leading Irish artist with hopes of £25,000-30,000

Maggi Hambling joins Pearl Lam Galleries

Ernst, Picabia and Renoir lead two modernist sales in New York this November

Monica de Miranda is the winner of the first edition of EXPOSED Grant for Contemporary Photography

Wakehurst celebrates 10 years of Glow Wild

The Schirn presents the first comprehensive exhibition in Germany of John Akomfrah's installations

Celebrating literature that 'Brings the World Close'

Laufey's old-time pop is smooth. Its relationship to jazz is spikier.

True benefits of playing at an online casino

6 Dos and Don'ts of Outsourcing Graphic Assets for SMEs

Dubai Marina Yachting: A Beginner's Guide to Booking the Perfect Yacht

Exploring the influence of football in art




Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 



Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
(1941 - 2019)
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez
Writer: Ofelia Zurbia Betancourt

Attorneys
Truck Accident Attorneys
Accident Attorneys
Holistic Dentist
Abogado de accidentes
สล็อต
สล็อตเว็บตรง

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org juncodelavega.com facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site Parroquia Natividad del Señor
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful