|The First Art Newspaper on the Net
||Established in 1996
|| Wednesday, March 21, 2018
|New York Lawyer Convicted in Dead Sea Scrolls Case|
Attorney Raphael Golb, center, is seen outside the courtroom with his attorney Ron Kuby, left, during a recess in his trial at Manhattan State Supreme court, Monday, Sept. 27, 2010, in New York. Golb is on trial on criminal charges of online impersonation and harassment for the sheer sake of coloring opinion. Prosecutors say Golb mounted an elaborate, carefully cloaked effort to promote his father's side in a rarefied but vigorous scholarly dispute over which ancient Jews wrote the more than 2,000-year-old scrolls. AP Photo/ Louis Lanzano.
By: Colleen Long, Associated Press Writer
NEW YORK (AP).- A scholar's son was convicted Thursday of using online aliases to harass and discredit his father's detractors in a heated academic debate over the origins of the Dead Sea Scrolls.
A Manhattan jury convicted Raphael Golb on Thursday of 30 counts against him, including identity theft, forgery and harassment. He was acquitted of one count of criminal impersonation.
Prosecutors said Golb, a 50-year-old lawyer, used fake e-mail accounts and wrote blog posts under assumed names to take his father's side in an obscure but sharp-elbowed scholarly dispute over the scrolls' origins.
Golb acknowledged crafting the e-mails and blog posts, and said the writings amounted to academic whistle-blowing and blogosphere banter not crime.
He said outside court he would appeal. His attorney said the conviction violates the First Amendment.
The more than 2,000-year-old documents, found in caves in Israel in the 1940s and '50s, contain the earliest known versions of portions of the Hebrew Bible and have provided important insight into the history of Judaism and the beginnings of Christianity.
Golb's father, 83-year-old University of Chicago Professor Norman Golb, said nearly a decade ago that Dr. Lawrence Schiffman, chairman of New York University's Skirball Department of Hebrew and Judaic Studies, had plagiarized his research. But he has never had to answer for it, and that so angered Golb that he broke the law, prosecutors said.
Golb created an e-mail account under Schiffman's name, then sent a message from it to Schiffman's colleagues admitting plagiarizing Norman Golb's work. Golb says his actions were not criminal. Rather, he said he was engaging in a spirited debate about the history of the texts and trying to highlight the fact that his father, a longtime scholar of the scrolls, was plagiarized by a rival professor.
Assistant District Attorney John Bandler told jurors during his closing arguments that Golb's claims are untrue.
"You blow the whistle by going to the boss. You don't do it by stealing someone's identity," he said.
Bandler said Golb's electronic campaign was calculated and massive, and it included the impersonation of five people, about 70 phony e-mail accounts and hundreds, if not thousands, of hours of work.
"It's not one bad decision he made in the heat of anger," Bandler said.
The defense summed up its case on Tuesday. Attorney David Breitbart said the real liar was Schiffman, who wrongly mounted a campaign against Golb that he took to the police.
Norman Golb and Schiffman disagree on the origins of the texts. Schiffman says the texts were assembled by a sect known as the Essenes. Professor Golb says the writings were the work of a range of Jewish groups and communities. Scholars are split on the debate; both arguments have followers.
During testimony, jurors got a history lesson on the ancient texts believed to be 2,000 years old. The scrolls, found by a Bedouin shepherd searching for a lost goat in Israel in the 1940s, include the earliest known versions of portions of the Hebrew Bible. Access to the scrolls was tightly controlled by a group known as the monopoly. Jewish scholars including Norman Golb were not allowed to evaluate them.
The controlled access to the scrolls continues, Raphael Golb argued during his testimony. He said his father was excluded from participating in workshops and museum exhibits on the texts while other more popular scholars were invited.
Jurors started deliberations Thursday afternoon. Bandler asked them to focus on the case in basic terms: Stealing someone's identity is wrong, and Golb knew that and did it anyway.
"This case is not about whether Dr. Schiffman plagiarized Dr. Golb. It is about how you can't impersonate anyone," he said.
(This version correct in third paragraph that Golb did acknowledge crafting e-mails.)
Copyright 2010 The Associated Press.
October 1, 2010
Images of a Capital: The Impressionists in Paris Opens at the Museum Folkwang in Essen
Exhibition Examines Return to Classicism in European Art Between World Wars
Olmec: Colossal Masterworks of Ancient Mexico to Open LACMA's New Resnick Exhibition Pavilion
Christie's in London Presents Treasures of the Islamic and Indian Worlds
At Italy's Barolo Wine Museum, Visitors are Encouraged to Play with Many of the Exhibits
Royal Ontario Museum Announces Second Year of Terracotta Warriors Exhibition Tour Not Proceeding
National Portrait Gallery Presents Portrait of Charles M. Schulz by Yousuf Karsh
Donors Endow Curatorship at Princeton University Art Museum; Laura M. Giles Appointed
Guggenheim Foundation and BMW Group Announce a Major New Global Initiative
Tatiana Trouvé Creates a New Installation in the Main Gallery at South London Gallery
Just a Click Away: Italian Masterpieces from Uffizi Gallery in Florence Go Online
Mint Museum Opens New Facility that Increase Museum's Space by More than 60 Percent
Twenty-Five Years After His Death, André Kertész Gets Exhibition at Jeu de Paume
Three New Space-Filling Installations by David Claerbout on View in Munich
New Mobile Guide Program Premieres at The Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art
Montclair Art Musuem Appoints New Curator of Contemporary Art
The Buddhist Cave Temples of Xiangtangshan at the Smart Museum of Art
Phillips de Pury & Co. to Launch Carte Blanche Auction at New Space on Park Avenue
Exhibition Celebrates the History of the New York Public Library's Photography Collection
New York Lawyer Convicted in Dead Sea Scrolls Case
The Morgan Library and Museum's Landmark McKim Building to Reopen October 30
Photographer Rankin Celebrates 10 Seasons of Luxury Clothing Label Thomas Wylde
Mexican Archaeologists from INAH Explore Prehispanic Observatory in Tabasco
The Robert Devereux Collection of Post-War British Art at Sotheby's This November
Exhibition at the IMA to Examine Material Culture Through Luxurious Textiles
Actor and Surrealist Painter, Tony Curtis, Dies at Age 85 in Las Vegas-Area Home
Latin America Countries Unite in Favor of Submerged Heritage
Paul Kasmin Gallery Presents Monochromes: A Special Project with Robert Žungu
National Gallery of Art Announces Gauguin: Maker of Myth" in Washington, Next Year
Benjamin Franklin's Famed "Disputes with America" Letter of 1767 Released by Midwest Collector Claude Harkins
Most Popular Last Seven Days
1.- The Morgan explores the Medieval world's fascinating approach to the passage of time
2.- Experts discover hidden ancient Maya structures in Guatemala
3.- Egyptian archaeologists unveil tomb of Old Kingdom priestess Hetpet
4.- The Speed Art Museum and Italian Ministry reach loan agreement on ancient calyx-krater
5.- Major exhibition features artistic masterpieces from the glorious Church of the Gesù
6.- From Beowulf to Chaucer, the British Library makes 1,000 years of rich literary history freely available online
7.- Truck damages Peru's ancient Nazca lines
8.- Trish Duebber is new Coordinator of Youth Programs at Boca Raton Museum Art School
9.- Exhibition examines the way art, like language, was used to articulate a rhetoric of exclusion
10.- The Dallas Museum of Art announces gift of three major European works
Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .
|Royalville Communications, Inc|
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.