The First Art Newspaper on the Net   Established in 1996 United States Tuesday, January 22, 2019

Gallery's Detective Work Shows Two Portraits Painted at the Same Time
The Pelican portrait. Queen Elizabeth I attributed to Nicholas Hilliard, oil on panel, circa 1575. © Walker Art Gallery, Liverpool.

LONDON.- New scientific detective work has revealed that two renowned 16th century portraits of Queen Elizabeth I belonging to two different galleries were painted on wood panels from the same tree. The portraits were first associated with Hilliard in 1933, and the new findings support the attribution as it is now known that both portraits were painted in the same studio. The paintings of Elizabeth I, known as the ‘Phoenix' portrait and the ‘Pelican' portrait, will be shown together for the first time in more than 25 years, for one week only, at the National Portrait Gallery from 13 to19 September 2010 as part of the Making Art in Tudor Britain project led by Dr Tarnya Cooper.

The two portraits of Elizabeth I (1533-1603) were painted when the queen was in her early forties, almost half way through her reign. Their names derive from the jewels worn by the queen at her breast in each picture: in one a phoenix and in the other a pelican. The face pattern used for these portraits is thought to be based on a miniature of the queen by Nicholas Hilliard (1547-1619), also on display at the Gallery. The Phoenix portrait belongs to the National Portrait Gallery, but has been on loan to Tate Britain since 1965, and the Pelican portrait belongs to the Walker Art Gallery in Liverpool. The portraits were last shown together in an exhibition, Artists of the Tudor Court, in 1983 at the Victoria and Albert Museum.

In the last few weeks, scientific analysis at the National Portrait Gallery has revealed that the two portraits were painted in the same studio because the wooden panels they were painted on derive from the same two oak trees and the face pattern used for each picture matches almost exactly. Dendrochronology shows both panels to be made of three boards derived from the eastern Baltic, probably Poland or the countries immediately to the east and north. The four outer boards were discovered to be from one oak tree, and the central board of each panel from another single oak tree. The panels and the portraits are mirror images of each other.

Further evidence that the portraits were painted in the same studio is that a tracing of the pattern of the Phoenix portrait matches the Pelican portrait in reverse. It was previously thought that the Pelican portrait was painted first (c.1573-4) and the Phoenix portrait was painted around two years later. However, building on technical analysis first undertaken in the 1960s the new research at the National Portrait Gallery has confirmed, using infra-red technology, that the position of the eyes has been altered in the Phoenix (they were initially lower). This has led to the new conclusion that the artist started painting this picture first before the template was used for the second portrait. Very possibly the artist had both pictures in his workshop and finished them around the same time.

It is likely that these portraits were painted by Hilliard or members of his workshop. Hilliard became the queen's painter in 1570 and is best known for painting miniatures, as no identified oil paintings by him have survived. However, there are stylistic similarities between these portraits and miniatures by Hilliard, in particular the linear style and close attention to detail, which leads to the conclusion that the two paintings are by the artist or his studio. The portraits were first associated with Hilliard in 1933 through comparison with the miniature of Elizabeth (NPG 108), but there has been a long debate over whether he actually painted large scale oil paintings. Although no certainly identified portraits ‘in large' by Hilliard have survived, it is known that he was commissioned by his own Company - the Goldsmiths - to paint ‘a faire picture in greate of her Ma[jes]tie.'

The Phoenix and the Pelican: Two Portraits of Elizabeth I, c.1575 runs from 13 to 19 September 2010 in Room 2 of the National Portrait Gallery. Both portraits have recently undergone in-depth technical analysis as part of the Gallery's Making Art in Tudor Britain research project. After the display the Pelican portrait will return to the Walker Art Gallery, Liverpool and the Phoenix portrait to Tate Britain, where it is on long-term loan from the National Portrait Gallery Collection.

Dr Tarnya Cooper, 16th Century Curator, National Portrait Gallery says: ‘It has been wonderful to have the opportunity to look at these two important pictures of Elizabeth alongside each other, and the research has been extremely exciting. We have spent about nine weeks studying these pictures in our Conservation Studio with a team of different specialists, and the analysis has indicated they must come from the same artist studio, probably that of the talented miniaturist Nicholas Hilliard, or someone working close to him.'

David Crombie, Senior Paintings Conservator, National Museums Liverpool says: ‘The results of these detailed technical investigations are fascinating, as they give us a new insight into the making of these images. It is unusual to have found such decisive links between two works and the project underlines the value of this kind of collaborative work between conservators, curators and other specialists. It is very significant that new information about these paintings is available to the public, adding to enjoyment and understanding of our artistic heritage.'

Karen Hearn, Curator (16th & 17th Century British Art), Tate Britain (where the Phoenix portrait is on long-term loan from the National Portrait Gallery) says: ‘The Phoenix portrait of Elizabeth I is one of the most important Tudor paintings in our displays, so it is absolutely fascinating that this new information on it has emerged. It will be intriguing to see it hanging alongside the Pelican portrait for a week at the National Portrait Gallery, before it returns to Tate Britain. It is precisely through technical investigations of this kind that we can come to a greater understanding of these very early British portraits.'

Queen Elizabeth I | Portrait | National Portrait Gallery | Dr Tarnya Cooper |

Today's News

September 14, 2010

Vatican Apostolic Library Reopens to Scholars After Three-Year and $11.5 Million Restoration

After 75 Years, Boeing Co. will Demolish Historic Plant 2

Ninth Edition of the Most Prestigious Art Show in the Americas Announced

Bonhams Launch Irish Art Department with First Sale in February

Chinese Emperor's Seal Expected to Make Millions at Bonhams

Christie's New York to Offer Extraordinary Collection of Unique Daguerreotypes

Transport: A Major Thematic Exhibition by Marc Newson at Gagosian

Global Positioning System? Mapquest? Not for Fans of Hand-Drawn Maps

The Menil Collection to Publish The Catalogue Raisonné of the Drawings of Jasper Johns

Bonhams & Butterfields to Offer the J.D. Collection of Saint-Gaudens $10 Eagles

"Notorious & Notable" Fashion Exhibit Pays Homage to New York Style Icons

Bay Area Artist Nellie King Solomon Exhibits at Brian Gross Fine Art

Gallery's Detective Work Shows Two Portraits Painted at the Same Time

Works by Ryan Leigh, Sam Knowles and Nick Bailey at Simon Oldfield Gallery

80 Coloured Ink Paintings Made by Josephine King at Riflemaker

Yul Brynner's Photographic Oeuvre Shown for the First Time

Art of the 1980s: A Düsseldorf Perspective at Kunstsammlung Nordrhein-Westfalen

Elements, Objects and Groupings by Jean-Pascal Flavien at Galerie Michel Rein

Tom Leighton "Appropiation of Space" Opens at Cynthia Corbett Gallery

Sotheby's Announces Third Offering From The James S. Copley Library

Exhibition Presents Photographs of José A. Figueroa's "Other" Life in Cuba

The Biography and Complete Catalog Raisonné on William Bouguereau Out this Week

New Works by Christof Mascher at Galerie Michael Janssen

Roman Bronze Helmet, Found with a Metal Detector, to Be Offered at Christie's

Medal Awarded to Carpathia Crew for Rescue of Titanic Survivors to Sell

Picasso Graphics Museum Celebrates 10th Anniversary, Changes Name

Strong Group of Works by The Glasgow Boys to Open Sotheby's London Sale

Origins and Mysteries of the Inca's Gold Explored at Pinacothèque de Paris

Art Institute of Chicago Appoints Daniel Walker Chair of Two Curatorial Departments

Columbia University Buys 1st Amendment Crusader's Papers

Most Popular Last Seven Days

1.- Rare 1943 Lincoln Cent sells for $204,000 at Heritage Auctions

2.- Exhibition is the first to shed light on the phenomenon of the princely painter

3.- Nathaniel Silver named new Curator of the Collection at the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum

4.- Rijksmuseum van Oudheden explores the mystical world of the ancient Egyptian gods

5.- Media error draws misleading reports on sale of 1943 Bronze Lincoln Cent

6.- Four men deny giant gold coin heist from Berlin's Bode Museum

7.- Tanya Bonakdar Gallery presents an immersive installation by Charles Long

8.- Egypt says stolen pharaonic tablet repatriated from United Kingdom

9.- Israeli museum under fire over 'McJesus' exhibit

10.- Claremont Rug Company founder Jan David Winitz reveals major shifts in high-end antique Oriental rug market

Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .


Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher:Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez

Royalville Communications, Inc
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
to a Mexican poet.

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful