The First Art Newspaper on the Net   Established in 1996 United States Sunday, May 26, 2019

French tug-of-war over remains of Lourdes saint
French soldiers and a policeman patrol inside the sanctuary of Lourdes on May 3, 2015, as part of the 'vigipirate plan' to ensure the security of Christians during the pilgrimages season. AFP PHOTO/ PASCAL PAVANI.

By: Loic Vennin with Marjorie Boyet in Nevers

LOURDES (AFP).- For many visitors to Lourdes it comes as a surprise that the saint whose visions of the Virgin Mary made the French town a major Catholic pilgrimage site is not actually buried there.

The remains of Bernadette Soubirous are now the subject of a tug-of-war between those who want her brought home, and the town of Nevers where her body is preserved in a shrine.

Lourdes, in southwestern France, draws six million people a year to visit a shrine in a grotto where Mary is said to have appeared to the poor shepherd girl Bernadette 18 times in 1858, and to bathe in the purportedly healing waters of a spring in the cave.

"Ah really! That's a surprise," said Michel, a pilgrim visiting the grotto, upon learning that Bernadette's remains were not at the site, but 700 kilometres (435 miles) north in Nevers.

It was to this French town that Bernadette went to join a convent aged 22 to escape the crowds and attention after her visions, and it was there that she died aged 35.

"The time has come" to return her remains to Lourdes, argues Jose Marthe, a regional councillor who formed an association with descendants of the saint's family to lobby for her return.

"Our intentions are pure."

But Nevers Mayor Denis Thuriot is not so sure. "It's obvious that the association, even if it denies it, is only looking to draw more tourists" to Lourdes, he said this week.

He deplored that "neither the association nor the descendants of Saint Bernadette have the heart to defend her memory or the wish of a woman who wanted to remain simple and anonymous, and found in Nevers a refuge and peace that today is being disturbed."

Marthe and the 300 members of the association, however, argue that Bernadette would have wanted to be laid to rest in Lourdes.

Benoit Casterot, a descendant of Bernadette's mother, is one of the association's leaders and says it "is absolutely logical that this local girl, our idol, return to Lourdes."

Another distant relative Francis Bayoumeu -- who married Bernadette's great grand-niece and runs her parents' house as a museum -- insists the saint "never wanted to leave Lourdes".

"Bernadette left under duress because of the media pressure," he told AFP.

Efforts 'in vain 
However the Sisters of Charity nuns charged with looking after her remains insist Bernadette came to Nevers of her own volition "to hide" and wanted to remain there.

"In 1957 Pope Pius XII definitively ratified the Church's position by confirming that Bernadette would be kept in Nevers," said the convent's Mother Superior Elisabeth de Tonquedec.

Pius had canonised Bernadette in 1933 after a long investigation into the apparitions convinced the Church they had indeed taken place.

Nicolas Joanne, director of a pilgrimage site in Nevers for those wishing to visit Bernadette's body, said moving her would not make spiritual sense.

"If we took Bernadette back to Lourdes she would become a curiosity. In Lourdes you have large processions... here it is a much more intimate encounter," he said.

Joanne said the 170,000 pilgrims who visited Nevers each year "say they want to meet the ordinary saint".

"She wouldn't tolerate being seen as a healer and she left Lourdes to avoid this misunderstanding," he said.

Nevers would also lose some 2.5 million euros ($2.7 million) a year brought to the small town by the pilgrims if her body was moved, a study showed in 2012.

Mathias Terrier, communications director for the Lourdes pilgrimage site, said the campaign to return Bernadette was "in vain, quite simply because it is not in line with her wishes".

In historical records tracing conversations Bernadette had, she reportedly replied "Oh no, never" when a fellow nun suggested she return to Lourdes.

"There is no ambiguity," said Terrier.

But to Marthe this is just "hearsay".

"We don't know if it will take six months or six years but Bernadette will be back." 

© 1994-2015 Agence France-Presse

Today's News

May 4, 2015

Fondazione Prada announces the launch of new Milan venue and opening exhibitions

Edvard Munch expert curates simultaneous exhibition in London & New York

Auction could smash art world records; Picasso valued at $140 million and a Giacometti worth $130 million

Baroque masterworks featured in Ketterer Kunst's auction of Old Masters & Art of the 19th Century

'In Light of the Past' at National Gallery of Art celebrates 25 years of collecting photographs

Russia mourns Maya Plisetskaya: One of the greatest ballerinas of the 20th century

Hopper, Moran, O'Keeffe, Peale, and Remington featured in Christie's American Art Sales

Artists from Israel, Spain and UK in the running for National Portrait Gallery's BP Portrait Award 2015

The much awaited second half of the Slaney collection of English coins is finally coming to auction

Christie's Russian Art Sale geatures masterworks from the Nicholas Roerich Museum

Exhibition commemorates the 25th anniversary of the National Gallery of Art’s photography program

British aviation pioneer Claude Grahame-White's office room now open for public viewing

Bonhams Aston Martin sale offers Peter Ustinov's rare 1962 Aston Martin DB4 Series IV

The Shelley & Donald Rubin Foundation announces the appointment of Sara Reisman as Artistic Director

Indian miniatures lead Roseberys first Islamic & Indian Arts Auction

Sculpture by Willard Boepple, Isaac Witkin, and James Wolfe explored at Tower 49 Gallery

Do/Tell: Group exhibition on view at the Institute of Contemporary Art in Philadelphia

Hayward Gallery presents the first UK solo show of Neha Choksi

Bonhams to auction the Baron von Eldik collection in Virginia house sale

Exhibition of works by Pam Lins on view at Rachel Uffner Gallery

Exhibition of works by Michael Wutz opens at Satellite Berlin

TENT Rotterdam announces the opening of three new exhibitions

First solo museum exhibition in the United States for emerging Israeli artist opens

French tug-of-war over remains of Lourdes saint

Merkel joins Holocaust survivors to mark Nazi camp's liberation

Most Popular Last Seven Days

1.- Christie's to highlight several private collections in Jewellery sale

2.- Mystery of 'Salvator Mundi', the world's most costly painting

3.- High prices and world records achieved at Old Masters auction

4.- Newly identified Leonardo portrait on show in London

5.- Rare Edouard Cortes painting appears at Rehs Galleries after 114 years

6.- Understanding Jewellery: The definitive jewellery app

7.- Academy Art Museum offers only East Coast Richard Diebenkorn exhibition

8.- Egypt uncovers Old Kingdom cemetery containing colourful wooden coffins

9.- Garry Winogrand: Color is the first exhibition dedicated to the artist's rarely seen color photographs

10.- Sotheby's welcomes visitors to their newly-expanded & reimagined galleries

Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .


Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher:Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez

Royalville Communications, Inc
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
to a Mexican poet.

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful