The First Art Newspaper on the Net   Established in 1996 United States Thursday, June 20, 2019

$8.2 million 'Gong Fu Tie' scroll row puts art ambitions of China's rich on display
A visitor to the newly-opened Long Museum West Bund in Shanghai looking at an ancient scroll that cost museum owner and tycoon Liu Yiqian millions of dollars but a row over its authenticity is threatening his goal of an artistic legacy. AFP PHOTO/Peter PARKS.

By: Bill Savadove

SHANGHAI (AFP).- With two museums already in his empire, tycoon Liu Yiqian is a would-be Chinese Getty or Guggenheim, but a row over the authenticity of a scroll that cost him millions of dollars threatens his artistic legacy.

The work, with nine Chinese characters in black ink reading "Su Shi respectfully bids farewell to Gong Fu, Gentleman Court Consultant", is the star exhibit at Liu's newly-opened Long Museum West Bund in Shanghai.

The calligraphy is a mere 28 centimetres long by 10 centimetres wide (11 by 4 inches), but Liu paid $8.2 million to secure it at a Sotheby's auction in New York in September.

A taxi driver turned financier who is now one of the country's wealthiest people, he is among the new Chinese super-rich scouring the globe for artwork, snapping up objects and driving up prices, some even building their own museums to house their collections.

"Like the Gettys and the Guggenheims and the Whitneys... there's a long history of museums in the West and maybe now in China of collectors wanting to make a name for themselves and make a mark on history," said Clare Jacobson, author of "New Museums in China".

But the grand opening has been upset by a public argument with a renowned trio of experts from the state-backed Shanghai Museum who derided the work as a fake.

In the shadowy world of money and art, there are suggestions China's established official museums resent competition from private ones. There are also rumours, denied in the media, that the scroll once passed through the hands of the Shanghai Museum.

Attributed to poet Su Shi, one of the recognised four great calligraphers of the Song Dynasty of 960 to 1279, the scroll is known as the "Gong Fu Tie" after the official named in it.

But the Shanghai Museum researchers, Shan Guolin, Zhong Yinlan and Ling Lizhong, launched an unusual attack after the purchase, saying it was a much later copy.

"Traditional visual identification is already enough to make the judgement that Sotheby's 'Gong Fu Tie' is a counterfeit version," they said in one article. Some brushstrokes appeared "awkward" and unlike the writer's style, they have argued.

They declined to comment to AFP.

Liu stands behind the scroll's authenticity, as does Sotheby's, which along with rival Christie's has been courting Asian buyers, with China now among the largest art markets in the world.

"This is a good thing, debate on the authenticity of 'Gong Fu Tie' helps restore historical truth," Liu told state media, though he added the controversy had left him physically and mentally exhausted.

Liu declined an interview with AFP, citing unhappiness with a New York Times series last year on China's art market, which described it as riddled with fakes and inflated prices and called him a "new collector".

Lavish spending
Liu, 50, made his first fortune speculating in Shanghai's newly established stock market in the 1990s, but now runs a huge conglomerate active in several industries, and his wealth is estimated at $1.6 billion.

He is one of a number of Chinese collectors who have made headlines in global art sales circles.

But some have faced a domestic backlash with accusations of lavish spending and showing off, even as they claim to be returning cultural relics to China.

Critics have openly challenged the motives of real estate developer Huang Nubo, who paid $1.6 million for seven white marble columns from Beijing's Old Summer Palace which will be displayed at his alma mater, Peking University.

"The recovery of relics should be a state action, which ought to be achieved by justice without paying for them," Yao Le, researcher at Jiangsu province's Academy of Social Sciences, said in the Global Times newspaper.

Another tycoon, Wang Jianlin, came under fire after his company spent $28 million on a Picasso, with people saying the money would be better spent helping China's poor.

The scroll at the centre of the latest controversy is housed in a glass case in its own room in the basement of the new museum, a vast building in a government-backed art district.

A small sign headed "Su Shi" reads: "His brushwork is round, rich and full of changes, yet with a touch of innocence and brilliance."

On opening day, a visitor struggled to read the scroll, written in classical Chinese and the complex characters which gave way to a simplified version after the founding of the People's Republic of China by the Communist Party in 1949.

"We can't understand it," said the middle-aged woman, declining to give her name. "For us, it's too troublesome to appreciate."

© 1994-2014 Agence France-Presse

Today's News

April 5, 2014

"Art and Alchemy: The Mystery of Transformation" opens at the Museum Kunstpalast

United States lawsuit targets Swiss expert Oliver Wick over $7.2 million 'Rothko'

Sotheby's Paris to sell moving portrait of Modigliani's confidant, mentor and patron Paul Alexandre

$8.2 million 'Gong Fu Tie' scroll row puts art ambitions of China's rich on display

Christie's offers three major private collections of Impressionist & Modern art in New York

Hebrew manuscripts, including 15th-century Haggadah, on view during Passover at Metropolitan Museum

Former United States president George Bush takes up portraiture of world leaders

Art Gallery of Ontario brings giants of British art Francis Bacon and Henry Moore together for major exhibition

Painted wood relief by Elijah Pierce achieves a record $87,500 at Doyle New York

Yale undergraduates curate Welsh landscape exhibition as part of program

"The Glittering Spindrift Running Before the Wind" sails at Bonhams Marine Auction

Husain's horses are the favourites at Bonhams Contemporary South Asian Sale

German Associated Press photographer Anja Niedringhaus shot dead in Afghanistan

19th century Chinese porcelain screen hits $121,000 at Elite Decorative Arts auction

Southwest weavings, pottery and baskets highlight June Native American art auction

"Shezad Dawood: Towards the Possible Film" opens at Parasol unit foundation for contemporary art

Suddenly We Jumped: Miami-based artist Antonia Wright opens exhibition at Luis De Jesus Los Angeles

Major exhibition showcases paintings and other works of James Spencer Russell

New series of works by Mona Kuhn on view at Flowers Gallery in London

Spring opening at the Irish Museum of Modern Art

Galerie Christian Lethert opens Imi Knoebel's first solo exhibition with the gallery

Art and antiques retailer Mallett reports profit and increased turnover

Most Popular Last Seven Days

1.- Art of early man found in the greatest meteor crater on earth

2.- Exhibition celebrates Helmut Newton's 50-year career through a rare and unseen collection of vintage prints

3.- World's most costly painting on Saudi prince's yacht: report

4.- Sotheby's celebrates the 50th anniversary of the Apollo 11 Moon landing with an auction

5.- Domaine de Chantilly exhibits Leonardo da Vinci's 'Nude Mona Lisa'

6.- New book offers front-row seat to greatest concert in history

7.- The New York Botanical Garden opens its largest botanical exhibition ever

8.- The most famous car in the world: RM Sotheby's presents James Bond Aston Martin DB5

9.- Mexico unearths what may be historic recording of Frida Kahlo

10.- Exhibition of Pierre-Auguste Renoir's paintings marks centenary of his death

Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .


Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher:Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez

Royalville Communications, Inc
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
to a Mexican poet.

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful