The First Art Newspaper on the Net   Established in 1996 United States Sunday, May 27, 2018

Small United States cities struggle to pay for 9/11 memorials that have blossomed across the country
People look at sculptures after the unveiling of a 9-11 memorial, Sunday, Sept. 11, 2011 in Pembroke Pines, Fla. Hundreds of little memorials to Sept. 11 have bloomed across the country in the intervening years since the terror attacks. But in some towns like this one, what began as a simple tribute to the dead turned into an expensive headache as the cost of building the memorial kept rising and the economy deteriorated. AP Photo/Wilfredo Lee.

By: Meghan Barr, Associated Press

PEMBROKE PINES, FL. (AP).- The memorial started with a steel beam salvaged from the World Trade Center — a small piece of the terrorist attacks that the city of Pembroke Pines, Florida was determined to honor in its own way.

Nobody from the Fort Lauderdale suburb died on September 11, 2001. But plans for its memorial grew ever more elaborate, at one point projected to cost more than $1 million.

"It was a glass-enclosed, air-conditioned house," recalled the city's mayor, Frank Ortis. "With a reflection pool and water running down, hurricane-resistant glass. Obviously we couldn't do that."

Hundreds of small memorials to Sept. 11 have blossomed across the country in the 10 years since the attacks. But in many towns, as in Pembroke Pines, what began as a simple tribute to the dead turned into an expensive headache as the cost of building such memorials ballooned and the economy deteriorated.

Still short of money, some cities dramatically scaled down the scope of their projects, paid the outstanding bill with public money or abandoned a memorial altogether. Others remain unfinished with no completion date in sight.

The numbers are minuscule compared with what it cost to build the major national memorials: $700 million for the National September 11 Memorial & Museum in New York City and at least $60 million for the Flight 93 memorial near Shanksville, Pennsylvania. But like these small towns, even the Flight 93 memorial is still struggling to raise enough money to build its original design; organizers need to raise about $10 million to finish the memorial's first phase and maintain it in the future.

Jerry Sanford, a former New York City firefighter, has been soliciting money since 2004 for a granite memorial in the shape of an American flag to be displayed in North Naples, Florida. Through private donations, he has raised about $600,000 — but he still needs $800,000 more to pay for the granite.

Sanford had been hoping to unveil the memorial in time for the 10th anniversary, but now he doesn't know when it will be completed.

"Times are very different now," he said. "The unemployment is rampant. People are out of work. The economy is bad."

There was a nationwide rush to build Sept. 11 memorials in the first few years after the attacks that has since subsided, said Erika Doss, a professor at the University of Notre Dame and author of the book "Memorial Mania: Public Feeling in America."

"Once the recession hit, the economic possibilities of doing so went away," said Doss, who discovered about 400 memorials to 9/11 while researching her book. "People still wanted to do it, but it became more and more difficult."

It is impossible to say how much money has been spent on the proliferation of memorials of all kinds across the U.S., from makeshift roadside crosses to massive monuments' because most are funded through a combination of private and public money.

Memorials were not always popular in this country. After World War II, monuments were eschewed in favor of "living memorials" like auditoriums and swimming pools named in memory of veterans, Doss said. A construction boom began in the 1980s when the Vietnam Veterans Memorial opened on the National Mall to much fanfare, Doss said.

"It has ushered in lots and lots of other groups demanding that they be represented by a memorial in the public sphere," she said. "People think if they can make a memorial, they can come to terms with what happened."

In Oklahoma City, the memorial to the 1995 bombing of the federal building that killed 168 people receives visitors from all 50 states every month of the year, said Kari Watkins, the executive director.

"They want to remember, and they're looking for the reason why," she said. "They're searching."

After the 9/11 attacks, Dennis Stout, then the district attorney in San Bernardino County, California, began an effort to build a pair of memorials to the victims, one east of Los Angeles and a twin in New York, truly coast-to-coast.

His nonprofit group, called the Freedom's Flame Sept. 11 Memorial, had a solid start, raising more than $200,000 in its first two years. It picked a design, which depicts people escaping down a staircase at the twin towers while rescuers climb up. They paid for renderings.

But when Stout failed to win re-election, the donations dried up. Now, nearly a decade after the effort began, there is still no memorial. The money is largely gone, too, spent partly on organizing a temporary, traveling memorial exhibit made up of limestone cladding from the Pentagon, a damaged fire truck from the New York fire department, and the World Trade Center steel. Today they have only around $20,000 left in the bank, out of nearly $262,000 raised.

Stout says he has not given up. He is also realistic, however, about his chances of building the two monuments, which had an estimated cost of $15 million.

"It's a wonderful idea," he said. "But, as you are well aware, there are wonderful ideas that don't get finished every day."

Residents complained about a memorial that was set to open Sunday in the horse racing village of Wellington, Florida, where officials failed to raise enough money to pay for it and were forced to use about $300,000 from the town budget. Along with a steel beam from the towers, this memorial features a glass-paneled pergola and a fountain with a gas-lit "eternal flame" that will burn day and night.

Matt Willhite, the vice mayor who has championed the project from the beginning, acknowledged that the town has no discernible connection to the terror attacks, but he does not think that is the point.

"The comments have been made: 'Well, why would we pay to put this thing in our city?'" he said. "I say, well, why not in Wellington? It's become my life lately, trying to perpetuate the memory of these people."

In Englewood, NewJersey, which lost two people in the twin towers, Police Chief Michael Cioffi felt compelled to create a memorial in the center of town about two years ago because he was worried that people were starting to forget. He wanted to bring back that sense of unity that enveloped the U.S. immediately after Sept. 11, a time when American flags flew everywhere, when the country was united, he said.

"It might just bring back a memory," Cioffi said. "It might keep the fire burning."

Yet Cioffi's project has financial troubles of its own: He still cannot come up with the $30,000 needed to pay for the granite.

In Pembroke Pines, commissioners finally voted in May to spend about $167,000 on a steel gazebo near city hall that will shelter the World Trade Center beam. Even with private donations, the city still was forced to borrow about $80,000 from its general obligation fund, which pays for road repairs, parks and libraries, among other things.

Officials are hoping they can recoup that money with a new round of fundraisers. The memorial was opened to the public on Sunday.

"I think it'll be easier to fundraise once they see it," Ortis said. "Some people say we should just forget about it and go on. We didn't think so."

Copyright 2011 The Associated Press.

9/11 | World Trade Center | Pembroke Pines | Jerry Sanford | Freedom's Flame Sept. 11 Memorial |  |

Last Week News

September 14, 2011

Gagosian Gallery announces the death of The Father of Pop Art: Richard Hamilton

Sotheby's in New York announces sale of part III of The Collection of Allan Stone

Lost British street artist Banksy mural "Every Picture tells a lie" uncovered on Berlin galley wall

A host of dragons, buffalo, lions and horses, lead caravan of Chinese art at Bonhams

National Gallery of Art launches second edition of the Gemini G.E.L. Online Catalogue Raisonné

Sanford Biggers: Cosmic Voodoo Circus exhibit on view at SculptureCenter

In Living Color vivid post impressionist works highlight Bonhams' October prints auction

Freeman's sells $3.5 million Qing Dynasty Jade Seal, Asian Art auction realizes $8.1 million

New Orleans Museum of Art names Russell Lord new Curator of Photographs

Christie's in New York to offer rare Inglenook from Francis Ford Coppola's cellar

Valencian Institute for Modern Art exhibition opens with the work of José Manuel Ciria: The Last Decade

Exhibition of new works by artist Gordon Cheung opens at Alan Cristea Gallery

Pavel Schmidt presents Kafka cycle at the Carpenter Center for the Visual Arts      

One of Britain's best-loved illustrators John Burningham at The Fleming Collection

Rice University's Rice Building Workshop designs café for the Menil Collection

Credit, Faith, Trust, an exhibition of new and recent works from James Casebere at Lisson Gallery

Lesley Heller Workspace opens group show of young female artists and solo exhibition by Loren Munk

Jewellery belonging to Thomas Jefferson's great, great granddaughter offered at Bonhams

Leslie Hindman Auctioneers fine art auction realizes 2.7 million

Deborah Solon and Alissa Ford join Heritage Auctions' Fine Arts department

September 13, 2011

Exhibition of Modern artworks in dialogue with Contemporary art at Kunstmuseum Bern

Sotheby's Contemporary Art evening sale to be headlined by Lucian Freud's Boy's Head of 1952

Personal handwritten letters by James Dean to be auctioned at Christie's for the first time

First painted portrait of American Vogue's Anna Wintour acquired by the National Portrait Gallery

Case of Los Angeles' stolen Rembrandt drawing intrigues art world with ownership issue

Miquel Barceló: Elefandret sculpture installed at Union Square in New York City

Ketterer Kunst in Munich announces sale of German Avant-Garde paintings in October

Milwaukee Art Museum acquires masterpiece of American art by John Singleton Copley

Swann Galleries to offer strong selection of American and European Works

Dagger owned by Ottoman Princess and poet married to Grand Vizier for sale at Bonhams

Two new installations by Chinese artist and film maker Yang Fudong premiere at Parasol Unit

Heritage Auctions' Long Beach September numismatic auctions total $34 million combined

Amelia Earhart goggles, photos pull in more than $31,000 at Clars Auction Gallery

1875 Gorham carved match safe 'Masterpiece,' one of only two known, expected to bring $20,000+

Ceramic vase bought for Perth Museum and Art Gallery

Edgar Allan Poe Museum in Baltimore could close

Bellagio Gallery of Fine Art presents "A Sense of Place: Landscapes from Monet to Hockney"

Bonhams sells case of Romanee Conti for 126,500 in Fine Wine sale

Historypin app lets people create a "time machine"

September 12, 2011

Jessica Lange shows her photos in Europe for the first time at the Niemeyer Center in Avilés

The Art of the Anatolian Kilim: Highlights from the McCoy Jones Collection at the De Young Museum

Virginia Museum of Fine Arts exhibition by Xu Bing explores the production and culture of tobacco

MoMA PS1 presents major exhibition looking at art from the past years from a post-9/11 perspective

Alchemy & Inquiry: Philip Taaffe, Fred Tomaselli and Terry Winters at James Cohan Gallery in Shanghai

Montreal Concert Hall designed by Diamond and Schmitt Architects opens to the public

Melbourne's National Gallery of Victoria Director Gerard Vaughan announces retirement

The Centro de Arte Contemporáneo de Málaga presents the first exhibition in Spain of Monica Bonvicini

American fine art photographer Todd Hido exhibits at Kaune, Sudendorf Gallery

English artist Rose Wylie opens "Picture on the wall..." at Galerie Michael Janssen

Summer's finest estate offerings are ready to harvest at Nest Egg's Sept. 24 Antiques Auction

Award-winning Belgian-Palestinian designer and silversmith Nedda El-Asmar exhibits at the Mosaic Rooms

Phillips de Pury & Co. to sell major photographic works by leading artists to help save Venice

Chris Johnson: A self-taught product of San Francisco's graffiti culture exhibits at Malmo Konsthall

Mark Wolfe Contemporary Art opens exhibitions of new works by Jacob Tillman and Sarah Thibault

New work by DC artist Ellington Robinson at Project 4 Gallery

The Eloquence of Trees: South Korean artists Jeong Han Yun and Choon Hyang Yun at Bill Lowe Gallery

Details: Bergen Kunsthall opens group exhibition

Recent works and new productions from fifteen international artists and designers at Bielefelder Kunstverein

Exhibition by pioneer of digital art Manfred Mohr opens at bitforms gallery

September 11, 2011

First major Tony Cragg exhibition in 20 years opens at the Nasher Sculpture Center in Dallas

Sotheby's Beyond Limits 2011: New works by Hirst, Quinn and Kusama at Chatsworth selling exhibition

The Morgan Library & Museum presents seventeen master drawings by Ingres

Edward Kienholz, Five Car Stud 1969-1972, revisited at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art

Major exhibition poses tough questions and reasserts Fluxus attitude

Major Southern Commissions of the 1930s-1940s at D. Wigmore Fine Art in New York

Color in Flux: Exhibition on the occasion of the 20th anniversary of the Weserburg

Prehistoric clay disks found at Noatak National Preserve in Northwestern Alaska

LACMA announces inaugural Art + Film Gala honoring Clint Eastwood and John Baldessari

Shakespeare: Staging the World exhibition announced at the British Museum

Gods, heroes & myths still speak of their ancient power at Bonhams sale of antiquities in London

First major solo exhibition of Brian McCutcheon's work opens at the Indianapolis Museum of Art

Associated Press photographer Anja Niedringhaus chronicles wars in Berlin show

Winning bid for huge diamond seized in Ohio: $2.8 Million

"The Fifth Column" a group exhibition featuring works by seven international artist

New York State Museum opens "New York Remembers" exhibition

Previously unseen drawings and sketches by Nigel Hall at the Royal Academy of Arts

Remembering 9/11 on view at International Center of Photography

September 10, 2011

Israel's national museum returns art to Jewish artist's heirs decades after it was looted

The Walters Art Museum announces major gift of 300 works from John Bourne of Santa Fe

A private German collection and the Gabrielle Keiller collection lead Christie's antiquities sale in London

Poussin masterpiece from the celebrated 'Sacraments' series acquired by the Kimbell Art Museum

Christie's New York announces the auction of a major selection of the remarkable Peter Norton Collection

Legendary Pop diva Anita Mui's jewels and watches to be offered exclusively at Sotheby's

Under a difficult financial situation, Kunstverein Hamburg announces charity auction to save its existence

John Ritter's politically and emotionally charged works at Lyons Wier Gallery Project Space

Exhibition at DC Moore Gallery of new paintings by Eric Aho explore the idea of the covert

Stephenson's Sept. 16 auction includes final inventory of Philadelphia's beloved Glatz Jewelers

Bob Dylan's "Asia Series" art exhibition coming to New York City's Gagosian Gallery

National Park Service secures Petrified Forest; adds 26,000 acres of private land

Photo of Confederate General Robert E. Lee fetches $23K for charity at online auction

Design competition seeks to improve National Mall

Robert Lobe's sculptures take root in Prospect Park's Pastoral Landscape

Guest-curated exhibition showcases an artist exhange between Egypt and the United States

Tate announces one of the most successful years ever

Cincinnati Art Museum celebrates record attendance: Third highest on record

New York arts world commemorates September 11 in music, film

September 9, 2011

Museum of Desires: MUMOK exhibition places the collection's potential in a new light

ABC Art Berlin Contemporary "About Painting" exhibition features some 130 artists

Sotheby's announces first dedicated sale of fine Classical Chinese paintings in New York

Mary Brogan Museum of Art & Science's Borrowed Italian painting: ownership dispute

American colorist Ronnie Landfield's Structure and Color opens at Stephen Haller Gallery

'Game-changer' in evolution from analysis of 2 million-year-old South African bones

Harper's Bazaar: A Decade of Style at the International Center of Photography

Snap up an iconic work by Banksy or Shepard Fairey at Bonhams Urban Art sale

Sculptures and a large-scale installation by Mike Kelley at Gagosian Gallery Britannia Street

Recent oil paintings by John Beerman on display at the Tibor De Nagy Gallery in New York

Bob Levy's slot machines hit the jackpot at Dan Morphy's $1.8 million auction

Jane Hammond combines painting and photography for new exhibition at Galerie Lelong

Greece: Authorities say Couple who had Peter Paul Rubens stolen work were 'amateurs'

Tate Modern to power ahead with art in oil tanks

Bonhams to sell 14th century roof beam from Muslim Spain

Sydney's Museum of Contemporary Art opens Primavera 2011: Exhibition by young Australian artists

Milwaukee Art Museum exhibition honors Santiago Calatrava's masterpiece

Zineng Wang joins Christie's Asian 20th Century & Contemporary Art as Specialist, Southeast Asia Region

The Bloomberg Commission: Josiah McElheny: The past was a mirage I'd left far behind

Most Popular Last Seven Days

1.- New Rembrandt found after being bought at London auction

2.- Exhibition at Fotohof focuses on groups in society who are at risk of marginalisation

3.- John Brennan collection of Rock n Roll memorabilia offered at RR Auction

4.- A Bob Dylan guitar fetches $495,000 at auction

5.- Exhibition in San Francisco focuses on the latter half of René Magritte's career

6.- 'Mad' king Ludwig II of Bavaria lost gift to composer Richard Wagner gets rare show

7.- New Royal Academy of Arts opens in celebration of its 250th anniversary

8.- Researchers uncover Anne Frank's 'dirty jokes'in her diary

9.- New York art sales near $3 billion in two weeks as uber-rich hunt trophies

10.- Berlin's Ethnological Museum returns grave-plundered artefacts to Alaska

Related Stories

World Trade Center Steel Columns to Be Installed at 9/11 Museum

A Look at Architect Michael Arad's 9/11 Memorial Waterfalls

Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .


Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher:Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez

Royalville Communications, Inc
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
to a Mexican poet.

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site
Tell a Friend
Dear User, please complete the form below in order to recommend the Artdaily newsletter to someone you know.
Please complete all fields marked *.
Sending Mail
Sending Successful