The First Art Newspaper on the Net Established in 1996 United States Tuesday, July 29, 2014


Case of Los Angeles' stolen Rembrandt drawing intrigues art world with ownership issue
This file image shows the Los Angeles Sheriffs department displaying the recovered $250,000 quill pen Rembrandt drawing known as "The Judgment" at a news conference in Marina Del Rey, Calif. On the surface it looked like an open-and-shut case: A pair of thieves drop by an art exhibition at a high-end hotel and, while one distracts a curator, the other snatches a valuable, centuries-old Rembrandt drawing and runs out the door with it. Then, apparently finding the small pen-and-ink work by the Dutch master too hot to fence, the thieves have second thoughts. They abandon it, undamaged, at a church on the other side of town. AP Photo/Gus Ruelas.

By: John Rogers, Associated Press

LOS ANGELES, CA (AP).- On the surface it looked like an open-and-shut case: A pair of thieves drop by an art exhibition at the Ritz-Carlton and, while one distracts a curator, the other snatches a valuable, centuries-old Rembrandt drawing and bolts with it. Apparently finding the small pen-and-ink work by the Dutch master too hot to fence, the thieves have second thoughts. They abandon it, undamaged, at a church on the other side of town. Then the real mystery begins.

Three weeks after recovering the framed, 11-by-6 inch drawing called "The Judgment," authorities aren't sure whether it really is a Rembrandt or if it even belongs to the art dealer that displayed it with other works at the Ritz-Carlton Hotel in Marina del Rey.

"They have to show us something to prove that they own it, and they haven't been able to do that," said Steve Whitmore, a spokesman for the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department. He said authorities are keeping the alleged Rembrandt under lock and key until the ownership issue is resolved.

Officials with the Linearis Institute, which says it owns the work that it values at $250,000, did not respond to phone calls and email messages. However, the institute's attorney, William Klein, said Linearis purchased "The Judgment," from a legitimate seller. He said the institute's officials just don't want to say who that was.

"Things like that really are trade secrets," Klein told The Associated Press. "We don't believe we need to reveal trade secrets to get back what is ours."

He acknowledged the institute has no trail of paperwork (called provenance in art-world speak) to prove "The Judgment" really is a Rembrandt. But he added that officials at Linearis believe it is and it shouldn't matter what authorities think. Art appraisers and other experts have said they cannot find "The Judgment" listed in any catalog or database chronicling the works of Rembrandt, who created hundreds of paintings, drawings and etchings before his death in 1669.

The Sheriff's Department is continuing to investigate the theft, although Whitmore said Linearis officials have told authorities they are not interested in having the people who snatched the drawing prosecuted.

"Which I find curious," he said.

Klein said Linearis is most interested at this point in getting its drawing back, although he added that if investigators happen to catch the thieves, "We'd like the Sheriff's Department and the District Attorney's office to do anything they need to do that's in the interests of justice."

Meanwhile, he said he's hoping to work out a compromise that will allow the drawing's return. If he can't he says he'll take the Sheriff's Department to court. Even in the art world, where questions about who owns what and how they got it arise frequently, the Rembrandt mystery has evoked curiosity.

It's not as unusual as one might think for a low-level thief to drop in on an exhibition and grab something, said Anthony Amore, who is head of security for the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston and co-author of the book "Stealing Rembrandts." He noted that just a month before the Rembrandt theft someone walked into a San Francisco art gallery and carried out a $200,000 Picasso. Police quickly arrested a New Jersey man they say has been linked to at least a half-dozen other art thefts since June.

Works by Rembrandt and Picasso are especially popular targets, Amore said, because everybody has heard of those artists and knows their works sell for huge amounts of money. In the last 100 years, he said, at least 81 Rembrandts have been stolen. What is unusual, Amore continued, is that the Los Angeles thieves got away, only to dump the drawing two days later.

"No, that never happens," he said. "That's what's incredibly intriguing."

So is the Linearis Institute's acknowledgment that it bought a work by one of the world's best known artists without any proof he really drew it.

"Provenance is the key to authenticating a piece and something like this would have to have some sort of provenance behind it," Amore said of the paperwork tracing a piece's ownership, often back to the time it was created.

"It's not impossible, but it's unusual for an institute, or anybody, to purchase something worth a quarter of a million dollars with no bonafides behind it," he said.

Confirming at this late date if Rembrandt really did the small drawing of a man kneeling before a judge could be difficult but not impossible, said veteran appraiser Mark Winter of Art Experts Inc. of Florida. Doing so would require a side-by-side comparison of the work with an acknowledged Rembrandt drawing from the same period, as well as a search of Rembrandt books and other documents, which could be scattered all over the world. Still, he said, every now and then someone confirms something as the artist's work.

For years, he noted, Rembrandt's "Self Portrait with Gorget," which hangs in the Germanisches Nationalmuseum in Nuremberg, was thought to be a copy of the artist's work that had been done by a friend. Then, in the 1990s, further study of documents and the painting revealed it was the real deal.

"I do not know the particular history and whereabouts of this drawing," Winter said. "But potentially yes, it is possible it could be by Rembrandt's hand."

Copyright © 2011 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.



Last Week News

September 12, 2011

Jessica Lange shows her photos in Europe for the first time at the Niemeyer Center in Avilés

The Art of the Anatolian Kilim: Highlights from the McCoy Jones Collection at the De Young Museum

Virginia Museum of Fine Arts exhibition by Xu Bing explores the production and culture of tobacco

MoMA PS1 presents major exhibition looking at art from the past years from a post-9/11 perspective

Alchemy & Inquiry: Philip Taaffe, Fred Tomaselli and Terry Winters at James Cohan Gallery in Shanghai

Montreal Concert Hall designed by Diamond and Schmitt Architects opens to the public

Melbourne's National Gallery of Victoria Director Gerard Vaughan announces retirement

The Centro de Arte Contemporáneo de Málaga presents the first exhibition in Spain of Monica Bonvicini

American fine art photographer Todd Hido exhibits at Kaune, Sudendorf Gallery

English artist Rose Wylie opens "Picture on the wall..." at Galerie Michael Janssen

Summer's finest estate offerings are ready to harvest at Nest Egg's Sept. 24 Antiques Auction

Award-winning Belgian-Palestinian designer and silversmith Nedda El-Asmar exhibits at the Mosaic Rooms

Phillips de Pury & Co. to sell major photographic works by leading artists to help save Venice

Chris Johnson: A self-taught product of San Francisco's graffiti culture exhibits at Malmo Konsthall

Mark Wolfe Contemporary Art opens exhibitions of new works by Jacob Tillman and Sarah Thibault

New work by DC artist Ellington Robinson at Project 4 Gallery

The Eloquence of Trees: South Korean artists Jeong Han Yun and Choon Hyang Yun at Bill Lowe Gallery

Details: Bergen Kunsthall opens group exhibition

Recent works and new productions from fifteen international artists and designers at Bielefelder Kunstverein

Exhibition by pioneer of digital art Manfred Mohr opens at bitforms gallery

September 11, 2011

First major Tony Cragg exhibition in 20 years opens at the Nasher Sculpture Center in Dallas

Sotheby's Beyond Limits 2011: New works by Hirst, Quinn and Kusama at Chatsworth selling exhibition

The Morgan Library & Museum presents seventeen master drawings by Ingres

Edward Kienholz, Five Car Stud 1969-1972, revisited at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art

Major exhibition poses tough questions and reasserts Fluxus attitude

Major Southern Commissions of the 1930s-1940s at D. Wigmore Fine Art in New York

Color in Flux: Exhibition on the occasion of the 20th anniversary of the Weserburg

Prehistoric clay disks found at Noatak National Preserve in Northwestern Alaska

LACMA announces inaugural Art + Film Gala honoring Clint Eastwood and John Baldessari

Shakespeare: Staging the World exhibition announced at the British Museum

Gods, heroes & myths still speak of their ancient power at Bonhams sale of antiquities in London

First major solo exhibition of Brian McCutcheon's work opens at the Indianapolis Museum of Art

Associated Press photographer Anja Niedringhaus chronicles wars in Berlin show

Winning bid for huge diamond seized in Ohio: $2.8 Million

"The Fifth Column" a group exhibition featuring works by seven international artist

New York State Museum opens "New York Remembers" exhibition

Previously unseen drawings and sketches by Nigel Hall at the Royal Academy of Arts

Remembering 9/11 on view at International Center of Photography

September 10, 2011

Israel's national museum returns art to Jewish artist's heirs decades after it was looted

The Walters Art Museum announces major gift of 300 works from John Bourne of Santa Fe

A private German collection and the Gabrielle Keiller collection lead Christie's antiquities sale in London

Poussin masterpiece from the celebrated 'Sacraments' series acquired by the Kimbell Art Museum

Christie's New York announces the auction of a major selection of the remarkable Peter Norton Collection

Legendary Pop diva Anita Mui's jewels and watches to be offered exclusively at Sotheby's

Under a difficult financial situation, Kunstverein Hamburg announces charity auction to save its existence

John Ritter's politically and emotionally charged works at Lyons Wier Gallery Project Space

Exhibition at DC Moore Gallery of new paintings by Eric Aho explore the idea of the covert

Stephenson's Sept. 16 auction includes final inventory of Philadelphia's beloved Glatz Jewelers

Bob Dylan's "Asia Series" art exhibition coming to New York City's Gagosian Gallery

National Park Service secures Petrified Forest; adds 26,000 acres of private land

Photo of Confederate General Robert E. Lee fetches $23K for charity at online auction

Design competition seeks to improve National Mall

Robert Lobe's sculptures take root in Prospect Park's Pastoral Landscape

Guest-curated exhibition showcases an artist exhange between Egypt and the United States

Tate announces one of the most successful years ever

Cincinnati Art Museum celebrates record attendance: Third highest on record

New York arts world commemorates September 11 in music, film

September 9, 2011

Museum of Desires: MUMOK exhibition places the collection's potential in a new light

ABC Art Berlin Contemporary "About Painting" exhibition features some 130 artists

Sotheby's announces first dedicated sale of fine Classical Chinese paintings in New York

Mary Brogan Museum of Art & Science's Borrowed Italian painting: ownership dispute

American colorist Ronnie Landfield's Structure and Color opens at Stephen Haller Gallery

'Game-changer' in evolution from analysis of 2 million-year-old South African bones

Harper's Bazaar: A Decade of Style at the International Center of Photography

Snap up an iconic work by Banksy or Shepard Fairey at Bonhams Urban Art sale

Sculptures and a large-scale installation by Mike Kelley at Gagosian Gallery Britannia Street

Recent oil paintings by John Beerman on display at the Tibor De Nagy Gallery in New York

Bob Levy's slot machines hit the jackpot at Dan Morphy's $1.8 million auction

Jane Hammond combines painting and photography for new exhibition at Galerie Lelong

Greece: Authorities say Couple who had Peter Paul Rubens stolen work were 'amateurs'

Tate Modern to power ahead with art in oil tanks

Sydney's Museum of Contemporary Art opens Primavera 2011: Exhibition by young Australian artists

Milwaukee Art Museum exhibition honors Santiago Calatrava's masterpiece

Bonhams to sell 14th century roof beam from Muslim Spain

Zineng Wang joins Christie's Asian 20th Century & Contemporary Art as Specialist, Southeast Asia Region

The Bloomberg Commission: Josiah McElheny: The past was a mirage I'd left far behind

September 8, 2011

Christie's announces sale of the legendary jewels from the collection of Elizabeth Taylor

Sotheby's London to sell an exceptional private collection of 20th century Italian art

Sotheby's Hong Kong to hold Fine Chinese Ceramics and Works of Art Autumn Sale

Acclaimed Hong Kong collection of Ming loyalist art on view at Metropolitan Museum this fall

Curators make hard choices at 9/11 Memorial Museum memorializing the attacks

China warns museums to tighten security after series of embarrassing thefts

The Brooklyn Museum installation Ten Years Later: Ground Zero Remembered now on view

German Artist Christian Jankowski premieres new film in exhibition at Lisson Gallery

Portland Museum of Art's chief curator accepts director position at Shelburne Museum in Vermont

Artists working in various media open exhibition at Nature Morte Gallery in Berlin

Rare scented chess set & a Spassky signed board for sale at Bonhams chess & games auction

Installation works by leading artists Liam Gillick and Susana Solano opens at Irish Museum of Modern Art

Sotheby's London to host exhibition of Fine Archaic Chinese Bronzes from Compton Verney

G Fine Art begins 10th anniversary season with Maggie Michael: There is No Rising or Setting Sun

Finest collection of 1960s DC war comics to be offered at Heritage Auctions

The Baltimore Museum of Art presents exhibition of Baker Artist Awards 2011 Winners

Kunsthaus Zurich extension to open in 2017

Smithsonian American Art Museum announces Bresler endowment to support curator position

Architecture of the former Soviet Union dominates new exhibition at Blain/Southern

September 7, 2011

Exhibition by photographer Franco Fontana opens at the Modern Art Institute in Valencia

J. Paul Getty Museum acquires Abbey Bible, considered a pinnacle of Gothic illumination

The annual "No Dead Artists" show opens at the Jonathan Ferrara Gallery in New Orleans

Exhibition of new work by German photographer Roland Fischer at Von Lintel Gallery

Exquisite Charles Willson Peale miniature portraits for sale at Heritage Auctions

Christie's announces important American furniture, folk art & decorative arts sale

Sotheby's to host "Turkophilia Revealed", a stunning exhibition of Ottoman art

Harvard exhibition investigates connections between renaissance art and science

Bonhams offers a rare and unique Zand Dynasty 18th century Persian gilded celestial Globe

Exclusive collectibles from all areas of history and military history offered at Hermann Historica oHG

Ransom Center exhibition explores forces behind censorship in United States between two world wars

Ugo Rondinone's "Kiss Now Kill Later" exhibition at Galerie Eva Presenhuber in Zurich

Modern and Contemporary South Asian paintings sale announced at Sotheby's in New York

Hull-House Museum Opens "Unfinished Business: Arts Education"

Arab museum: Events reflect effects of September 11

Marco Brambilla presents first ever video art selection in 68th Venice film festival

Sotheby's wine season opens with two sales offering a plethora of Chateaux and vintages for all taste

Affordable art boosts ranks of Singapore collectors

John Hoover, Alaska artist of Native imagery, has died

Most Popular Last Seven Days



1.- Archaeologists discover Roman 'free choice' cemetery in the 2,700-year-old ancient port of Rome

2.- Romanians must pay 18 million euros over Kunsthal Museum Rotterdam art heist

3.- Hello Kitty designer Yuko Yamaguchi defends cute character as cat turns 40 years old

4.- eBay and Sotheby's partner to bring world class art and collectibles to a global community

5.- Exhibition on Screen returns with new series of films bringing great art to big screens across the globe

6.- Marina Abramović reaches half way point of her '512 Hours' performance at the Serpentine Gallery

7.- The Phillips Collection in Washington introduces a uCurate app for curating on-the-go

8.- United States comic icon Archie Andrews dies saving openly gay character

9.- New feathered predatory fossil, unearthed in China, sheds light on dinosaur flight

10.- Exhibition at Thyssen Bornemisza Museum presents an analysis of the concept of the 'unfinished'



Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 

Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Rmz. - Marketing: Carla Gutiérrez
Special Contributor: Liz Gangemi - Special Advisor: Carlos Amador
Contributing Editor: Carolina Farias

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org theavemaria.org juncodelavega.org facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site