The First Art Newspaper on the Net Established in 1996 United States Friday, July 25, 2014


Curators make hard choices at 9/11 Memorial Museum memorializing the attacks
A Port Authority Police Department uniform hat, badge number 899, and Port Authority Pipe Band hat belonging to victim Liam Callahan. REUTERS/Lucas Jackson.

By: Jonathan Allen

NEW YORK, N.Y. (REUTERS).- Curators are making hard choices at the museum memorializing the September 11, 2001 attacks at the site of the World Trade Center's toppled twin towers, aiming to convey the horror of the event without trespassing into ghoulishness.

"We're not here to traumatize our visitors," said Alice Greenwald, director of New York's 9/11 Memorial Museum that is due to open in its underground home at the Ground Zero site next year on the 11th anniversary of the attacks.

"Monumental artefacts are one thing, but we also have a human story to tell," Greenwald said.

Some of the most potentially disturbing exhibits are being set aside from the main exhibition spaces in special alcoves to allow visitors a chance to decide whether or not to view it.

It is here that museum curators have placed material such as images of people plummeting from the burning towers after the buildings were struck by airliners hijacked by al Qaeda militants, and a recording of the measured voice of a flight attendant aboard one of the planes moments before her death.

For museum curators, deciding whether to include examples of some victims' painful final moments was one of their toughest dilemmas as they sought to pay tribute to the nearly 3,000 people killed without piling more grief onto the living.

It's a familiar problem for people aiming to memorialize wars and atrocities.

"We're not just a history museum, we're also a memorial institution and so the tension that happens between commemoration and documentation is a flash point," Greenwald said in an interview at the museum's offices overlooking the ongoing construction of a facility that will occupy seven stories below ground at the World Trade Center site.

Greenwald is no stranger to these debates. For almost two decades she helped create exhibits at the National Holocaust Museum in Washington memorializing the murder of millions of people at the hands of the Nazis during World War Two.

'THE 9/11 STORY'
Greenwald and her colleagues are aware that there are countless objects that might overwhelm a visitor.

There will be photos of the 19 al Qaeda hijackers, although Greenwald said they will be presented as "criminals."

Another difficult question for curators was whether to include disturbing pictures of victims who jumped or fell from the towers. Excluding such pictures would be a serious omission, Greenwald said. The photos will be located in an alcove clearly marked with a warning and none of the people pictured are identifiable, she added.

"It is one of the aspects of the 9/11 story that if you didn't include it, you're not telling the story," she said.

In choosing audio recordings of the last words spoken by some victims, the museum avoided some of the most distressing calls to the 911 emergency phone number. "That's a form of human remains," Greenwald said. "We will include nothing that feels like a moment when we shouldn't have been there."

Instead, curators chose recordings with the permission of victims' families that show what Greenwald called the "exceptional nature" of many of those killed in the attacks.

This includes the remarkably composed voice of Betty Ong, a flight attendant on American Airlines Flight 11, as she relays details of the bloody hijacking to colleagues on the ground in the minutes before the plane crashed into the North Tower.

The museum has acquired hundreds of items belonging to victims, survivors and first responders.

The significance of a horribly crushed fireman's helmet is obvious. Other items might be more subtle in their importance: dust-caked shoes, a crumpled wallet, clothing, a never-finished knitting project, a blackened doll -- all commonplace items that have taken on the air of relics.

The museum has been sculpted out of the vastness of the World Trade Center's foundations, and incorporates part of the slurry wall, originally built to hold back the waters of the Hudson River and which survived the buildings' collapse.

There will be a memorial exhibition for the 2,982 people killed in the September 11 attacks and in the 1993 bombings of the World Trade Center that were a prelude to the later event. The exit of the museum has been designed so that visitors emerge at the heart of the 9/11 Memorial -- cascading waterfalls set into the footprints of the fallen towers surrounded by bronze panels bearing the names of the dead.

"For every heart-wrenching story you have 10 stories about the goodness of human beings," Greenwald said. Referring to future visitors to the museum, she added, "They're going to come out with a lot to think about."

(Editing by Will Dunham)

© Thomson Reuters 2011. All rights reserved.



Last Week News

September 7, 2011

Exhibition by photographer Franco Fontana opens at the Modern Art Institute in Valencia

J. Paul Getty Museum acquires Abbey Bible, considered a pinnacle of Gothic illumination

The annual "No Dead Artists" show opens at the Jonathan Ferrara Gallery in New Orleans

Exhibition of new work by German photographer Roland Fischer at Von Lintel Gallery

Exquisite Charles Willson Peale miniature portraits for sale at Heritage Auctions

Christie's announces important American furniture, folk art & decorative arts sale

Sotheby's to host "Turkophilia Revealed", a stunning exhibition of Ottoman art

Harvard exhibition investigates connections between renaissance art and science

Bonhams offers a rare and unique Zand Dynasty 18th century Persian gilded celestial Globe

Exclusive collectibles from all areas of history and military history offered at Hermann Historica oHG

Ransom Center exhibition explores forces behind censorship in United States between two world wars

Ugo Rondinone's "Kiss Now Kill Later" exhibition at Galerie Eva Presenhuber in Zurich

Modern and Contemporary South Asian paintings sale announced at Sotheby's in New York

Hull-House Museum Opens "Unfinished Business: Arts Education"

Arab museum: Events reflect effects of September 11

Sotheby's wine season opens with two sales offering a plethora of Chateaux and vintages for all taste

Marco Brambilla presents first ever video art selection in 68th Venice film festival

Affordable art boosts ranks of Singapore collectors

John Hoover, Alaska artist of Native imagery, has died

September 6, 2011

Raphael, Dürer and Grünewald paint the Madonna at Gemaldegalerie Alte Meister in Dresden

Stadel Museum discovers an important work by French academic painter Jean-Léon Gérome

Unique Roman gladiator ruins that flourished about 1,700 years ago unveiled in Austria

Thomas Gainsborough Linley portraits reunited at Dulwich Picture Gallery

Sotheby's Islamic World arts sale to feature exceptional ceramics from the Collection of Harvey B. Plotnick

Bonhams offers two masterpieces by celebrated Russian painter Vasili Polenov, unseen for 80 years

Sotheby's London to offer two landmark portraits by Johann Zoffany of the celebrated actor David Garrick

Italian cops nab alleged vandal of famous fountain; "exemplary punishment" requested by Mayor

Israel's ancient rebel caves, a hidden adventure published in an obscure journal

Film "Shame" directed by British video artist Steve McQueen brings sex addiction tale to Venice

Crazy Horse sculptor's 85-year-old widow, Ruth Ziolkowski, carries on mountain dream

1775 public notice known as a "broadside": Colonists asked pacifists to pay

Governor-General's railway carriage on show for the first time at the Powerhouse Museum

Mat Collishaw to feature "Bullet Hole" at the 12th Istanbul Biennial

Matthew Monahan, Untitled at Galerie Fons Welters

Bonhams to sell Aston Martin owned by Shane Filan of Irish pop group Westlife

Sotheby's Hong Kong to hold magnificent jewels and jadeite autumn sale in October

Martin Luther King Memorial architect says inscription will stay

Two arrested in Portugal after rhino horn heist

September 5, 2011

Salvador Dalí retrospective opens at Moscow's Pushkin State Museum of Fine Arts

LACMA presents first retrospective of revolutionary Chicano conceptual artists, Asco

Exhibitions focus on the vital relationship of the Van Abbemuseum with artists and art lovers

11 in 2011, Museo de Arte de Ponce enters the age of video art with first online exhibit

Reading Public Museum to feature works from its permanent collection of American Impressionists

Work by acclaimed artist Alice Neel anchors collection acquired by Rowan University Art Gallery

Chinese artist Ai Weiwei wins fans in L.A. with Los Angeles County Museum of Art exhibition

Florentine artist Walter Romani's Il Demone del Tramutamento at Palazzo Piccolomini

Iconic image of Kate Moss by Corinne Day to sell at Bonhams, exhibition opens at Gimpel Fils

Thorvaldsens Museum and the National Gallery of Denmark exhibit in Moscow

Brazilian photographer Breno Rotatori exhibits at FOAM as part of the Brasil Festival Amsterdam

Keynote lectures, panel debates and discussions announced for Frieze Talks 2011

Medieval English alabaster sculpture from the Victoria and Albert Museum on view at the Tyler Museum

Stroom De Haag presents Hans van Houwelingen 'Until it stops resembling itself'

States of Fragility: A solo exhibition by Anj Smith at Ibid Projects

Newly restored films by legendary avant-garde artist Jack Smith shown in Europe for the first time

GV Art Gallery acts as a hub for collaborations between artists and scientists

Influential street artist Swoon transforms Institute of Contemporary Art lobby

September 4, 2011

Selected works from the François Pinault Collection on view at SongEun ArtSpace

Exhibition tells the story of an unusual collaboration between two very different artistic temperaments

Henri Cartier-Bresson: The Geometry of the Moment Landscapes at Kunstmuseum Wolfsburg

Exhibition of Louise Bourgeois's work at Fondation Beyeler addresses key themes

Recent paintings and drawings from 2008 to 2011 by Daniel Richter at Kestnergesellschaft

Real or abstract photography? Shirana Shahbazi exhibits at Fotomuseum Winterthur

San Francisco Fall Antiques Show celebrates its 30th anniversary with a host of hidden treasures

Exhibition provides rare opportunity to view drawings and texts by Andrea Palladio

Most important new reference book on Chinese export porcelain published by Jorge Welsh Books

A celebration of Helaine Blumenfeld's spiritual marble and bronze sculptures at Italy's Pietrasanta

Dan Gunn creates a new work especially for the Museum of Contemporary Art in Chicago

Exhibition by artists from Georgia at Lunds konsthall is certain to have a political dimension

Gavel lifts on Chicago's world famous Lee Roy Hartung Collection      

Heritage to launch Estate Auctions, in September, featuring the best of the nation

Artists collaborate on a human-size "speaker" structure at The Showroom

New book shows how Mark Dion creates a monumental curiosity cabinet

American Craft Week: A nationwide celebration of handmade in America

10 years, 21,000 bone fragments, no 9/11 closure

Recent work from Bay Area artist Timothy Buckwalter at Mina Dresden Gallery

Museum acquires two African objects via Apollo Society selection

September 3, 2011

Special exhibition of landscapes by Max Beckmann on view at Kunstmuseum Basel

Christie's New York presents the fall sale of impressionist & modern art in September

Sotheby's London biannual sale of old master, modern and contemporary prints announced

Sotheby's Hong Kong to hold modern and contemporary southeast Asian paintings autumn sale

New Vincent Van Gogh exhibition at Denver Art Museum to trace artist's evolution

Fine Chinese ceramics and works of art for Sale in two sessions at Sotheby's this September

Charlotte's Mint Museum launches major Romare Bearden retrospective on centennial of his birth

Happy Ending: major solo exhibition by American artist Greg Miller at Scream London

New York's 9/11 light tribute still dazzles; despite its popularity, the tribute's future is uncertain

World record for much loved Scottish artist Robert Gemmell Hutchison at Bonhams sale

Raphael Dallaporta, winner of Foam's Paul Huf Award 2011, opens exhibition in Amsterdam

Installation of nineteenth-century modern objects and furniture on view at Brooklyn Museum

Ten years after the 9/11 attacks, New York's World Trade Center rises from ground zero

BJ Price 'High in the Depths' art exhibition at Amsterdam's Whitney Gallery

"Off Site" exhibition by a group of artist at Rod Barton

David Buckingham: Hung Like Elvis at Kit Schulte Contemporary Art

Mixed decisions on Hungarian looted art lawsuits

2 Greeks charged regarding stolen Rubens work

Battleship Missouri marks end of WWII anniversary

September 2, 2011

Christie's holds high expectations for series of Asian art sales to be held in New York

Newseum in Washington is first museum to show FBI evidence from 9/11

Lee Friedlander: "America by Car & The New Cars 1964" opens at Timothy Taylor Gallery

Bonhams Scottish Colourist sale makes 3 million pounds in Edinburgh with Peploe making over 500,000

American contemporary artist Jeff Koons to lend major works to Paris Tableau

Exhibition in Berlin unite most of the legendary Blue and Red Mauritius stamps

New collection of works by Eduardo Arranz-Bravo at Franklin Bowles Galleries

World War II portraits of Jewish 'counterfeiters' donated to Holocaust museum

Chinese-Asian works of art buoyant at Bonhams auction in San Francisco on August 30th

Angela Brady is second woman to become Royal Institute of British Architects President

Benghazi museum shows scars, triumphs of Libya revolt-artists free for the first time

Demuth Museum to open exhibition by father and son artist duo: "The Newswangers"

Tom Dale's "Memorial Drag Strip" is his inaugural exhibition at Poppy Sebire Gallery

Sotheby's Hong Kong to hold important watches sale in October

"Exercise Your Mynd-BK Adams I Am Art" on view at the Smithsonian's Anacostia Community Museum

Greek police recover stolen Rubens painting

Royal Academy announces new Poet-in-Residence

Most Popular Last Seven Days



1.- Archaeologists discover Roman 'free choice' cemetery in the 2,700-year-old ancient port of Rome

2.- Romanians must pay 18 million euros over Kunsthal Museum Rotterdam art heist

3.- Hello Kitty designer Yuko Yamaguchi defends cute character as cat turns 40 years old

4.- eBay and Sotheby's partner to bring world class art and collectibles to a global community

5.- Exhibition on Screen returns with new series of films bringing great art to big screens across the globe

6.- Marina Abramović reaches half way point of her '512 Hours' performance at the Serpentine Gallery

7.- The Phillips Collection in Washington introduces a uCurate app for curating on-the-go

8.- United States comic icon Archie Andrews dies saving openly gay character

9.- New feathered predatory fossil, unearthed in China, sheds light on dinosaur flight

10.- Exhibition at Thyssen Bornemisza Museum presents an analysis of the concept of the 'unfinished'



Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 

Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Rmz. - Marketing: Carla Gutiérrez
Special Contributor: Liz Gangemi - Special Advisor: Carlos Amador
Contributing Editor: Carolina Farias

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org theavemaria.org juncodelavega.org facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site