The First Art Newspaper on the Net Established in 1996 United States Sunday, November 23, 2014


Swiss-Based Gallery, Artvera’s Gallery, Helps Crack Artwork Forgery Ring in Germany
Rotes Bild mit Pferden by Heinrich Campendonk sold from the Cologne-based auction house Lempertz for 2.88 million Euros.
GENEVA.- The largest scandal involving an artwork forgery ring in Germany just broke and has made front-page news in German media for the past few weeks. Forgers belonging to the same family managed to sell over 20 forged artworks from the so-called “Jägers Collection, ”which probably never existed, for a total sum estimated between 30 and 80 million Euros. They have been jailed since 27 August 2010 in Germany . The effort was spearheaded by the Swiss-based Artvera’s Gallery and the law firm K&L Gates in Berlin , hired in 2006 to represent one of the gallery’s clients who had been cheated in buying a fake Campendonk at an auction. Thanks to evidence produced by Artvera’s, in collaboration with respected experts such as Aya Soika (expert and author of the annotated Pechstein catalogue) and Ralph Jentsch (an expert on George Grosz and on the Alfred Flechtheim Gallery), and thanks to lawsuits filed by the large K&L Gates law firm in Berlin, the public prosecutor opened a criminal investigation that led to the arrest of the three forgers.

“Rotes Bild mit Pferden”: forged Campendonk, sold in 2006 for a record 2.88 million Euros
Back in 2006, the firm Trasteco Ltd, a major client of Artvera’s gallery in Geneva , bought the artwork Rotes Bild mit Pferden by Heinrich Campendonk from the Cologne-based auction house Lempertz for 2.88 million Euros (the final sale price was 2.4 million). The work was sold without the necessary certificate of authenticity issued by the author of the catalogue raisonné, Andrea Firmenich. Since any serious auction house should provide such guarantee, Artvera’s gallery advised its client to request it quite naturally from Lempertz. The auction house promised to produce the certificate, but expert Andrea Firmenich refused to issue it without a chemical analysis of the artwork. The Doerner Institute in Munich conducted the first analysis, and concluded that the painting was a forgery; the result was confirmed by the second analysis conducted by Dr Nicholas Eastaugh, from London/Oxford, in August 2008. All analyses were performed at the expense of the buyer.

Trasteco Ltd filed a civil lawsuit against the auction house in September 2008 in order to be reimbursed of its 2.88 million Euros. During the proceeding, Artvera’s contacted various experts and helped unmask the “Jägers Collection” forgery scandal in a decisive way. To this day, Artvera’s client has not been reimbursed, contrary to allegations published in the German press, and despite the arrest of the criminals and the formal statement by experts about the forgery.*

Provenance, a crucial element in art authentication
Contrary to allegations made by the Lempertz auction house, it never took the initiative for the paintings of the so-called “Jägers Collection” to be examines and authenticated by experts or estate executors of the artists in question. Rotes Bild mit Pferden, attributed to Campendonk and sold to Trasteco Ltd is not an isolated case in the dealings of Lempertz. In fact, five other paintings from the notorious “Jägers Collection” were sold as authentic artworks by the same auction house—two forged Pechstein, Seine mit Brücke und Frachtkähnen and Nu couché avec chat. Contrary to allegations made by Lempertz, these artworks were not professionally authenticated by the son of Max K. Pechstein.

In 1995, the forgers tried to sell their first painting to Lempertz; it was immediately identified as a forgery, thanks to the archive of artist Hans Purrmann. This episode should have raised red flags with Lempertz and encouraged extreme caution, if not increased vigilance regarding works coming from this source. Nevertheless, Lemperta continued for many years to sell the paintings brought in by the same people.

It seems that the German forgers may have sold over twenty forgeries from the so-called “Jägers Collection, signed by the most famous painters (especially German expressionists such as Campendonk and Pechstein, but Léger and Metzinger as well) for a total sum estimated between 30 and 80 million Euros.

The victims of this skilled forgery ring are numerous—experts, well-established art galleries, and prestigious auction houses. While Lempertz continues to deny any wrongdoings and refuses to compensate the victims, other well-known auction houses work actively with clients who were duped, and try to find fair solutions to compensate them.

Had the provenance and the past sellers and buyers been analyzed, this scandal would have been avoided, since provenance plays a crucial role in the art market.

*··········Three analyses, including two scientific ones, have so far concluded that the painting is notauthentic. The Doerner Institute, specializing in the physical and chemical analysis of artworks, showed evidence in March 2008 that the artwork contained particles of a colour pigment, called titanium white, which had not been identified—let alone produced industrially—at the time of the alleged creation of the work. This fact was confirmed by a second analysis performed in August and September 2008 by Dr. Nicholas Eastaugh, renowned British physicist and art historian, who took a sample of the problematic colour pigments on the painting. The Flechtheim expert Ralph Jentsch conducted a third analysis, and concluded that the labels of the Flechtheim Gallery found on the back of the canvas were forged.

Artvera's Gallery | Crack Artwork Forgery Ring | Geneva |




Last Week News

November 16, 2010

Extensive Survey of Impressionist Gardens Opens at Museo Thyssen‐Bornemisza

Saint Louis Art Museum Announces Fiery Pool: The Maya and the Mythic Sea

Surrealism, Botero in Latin America Auctions this Week at Christie's and Sotheby's

Paraguay Denied Authorization for British Natural History Museum's Scientific Expedition

Heritage Auctions Announces Pre-Columbian, Photography, Timepieces and Art Glass Sales

Danish Astronomer's Remains Exhumed from Church of Our Lady Before Tyn

Rarities and Rediscoveries: Great Works of Art at TEFAF Maastricht in March 2011

Renowned Milton Robson Collection Achieves $9.2 Million at RM Auctions Sale

Architect Richard Meier: "It's Easier to Buy an Apartment in Brooklyn than in Tel Aviv"

Georges Rouault: The Sacred and the Profane at the Bilbao Fine Arts Museum

Neo-Expressionist Painting from Berlin on View at the Tel Aviv Museum of Art     

Fine Meissen Porcelain that Survived the 1945 Dresden Bombing for Sale at Bonhams

London's Cultural Strategy: "We Must Continue to Invest in Creativity" Says London Mayor

American Charged with Stealing Stuffed Birds in UK

Edinburgh International Festival Heads East in 2011

Crystal Bridges Masterworks on Display at Philbrook Museum of Art

Opryland Hotel Reopens in Tennessee After Flood Damage

Chinese Mine in Afghanistan Threatens Ancient Find

November 15, 2010

Kunsthalle in Dresden Opens Exhibition of Works by German Artist Eberhard Havekost

Johan Thorn Prikker: Beyond Art Nouveau at Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen

Rare Photographic Albums and Portfolios Break Records at Swann Galleries' Auction

Geert Mul and Maurer United Architects Transform Bus Stop into a Beacon for the Media Era

14th Annual Boston International Fine Art Show to be Held this Week at The Cyclorama

The Valencian Institute of Modern Art Presents Sculptures by Xavier Mascaro     

Mathaf: Arab Museum of Modern Art Announces Details of Its Three Opening Exhibitions

Everson Presents Works by Artists from the Six Nations of the Iroquois Confederacy

The Etchings of Etcher John Taylor Arms on View at the Chrysler Museum of Art

A Selection of Drawings and Paintings by Stephen Farthing at the Royal Academy of Arts

Delaware Art Museum Presents Ultra-Realistic Sculptures by Milwaukee-Based Artist Marc Sijan

Mark Moore Gallery Announced Its Permanent Relocation from Bergamot Station to Culver City

Babe Ruth Home Run Ball Goes for $264,500 at the Louisville Slugger Museum

The Power Plant Appoints Melanie O'Brian as New Curator of Programs

PHotoEspaña Announces Portfolio Reviews to be Held in Colombia and Nicaragua; Launch a New Online Curating Competition

DeCordova Announces Co-Curators for the 2012 Biennial: Associate Curator Dina Deitsch and Abigail Ross Goodman

"American Tapestry" Exhibition Tells 25 Stories through Collected Objects, Art

Celebrity Painter Rosson Crow and Motorcycles at the Contemporary Arts Center

November 14, 2010

Gemäldegalerie Celebrates 400th Anniversary of Caravaggio's Death with Exhibition

LACMA Announces First Ever Thematic Exhibition of Renowned American Sculptor David Smith

Explore The Strange World of Albrecht Dürer at the Sterling and Francine Clark Art Institute

Almost 500 Lots of Russian Art Included in the Russian Art Sale at Christie's

Major Alberto Vargas Retrospective Opens at the San Francisco Art Exchange

Site-Specific Wall Drawing Installation by Renowned Artist Pat Steir at Sue Scott Gallery

First Rank Exhibition Soberly Named Pointillism Opens at Artvera's in Geneva

Collection of 40 Rarely-Exhibited Abstract Prints by Jules Olitski at the Everson Museum of Art

First Retrospective of Designer Hella Jongerius at Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen

Texas-Based Gaston & Sheehan Sells Spoils of Bernard Madoff's Lavish Life in New York

Contemporary Photographer Sally Mann's The Flesh and The Spirit at the Virginia Museum of Fine Arts

Curious George: The Art of Margret and H. A. Rey at the Contemporary Jewish Museum

Oasis of Colour in Contemporary Aboriginal Painting at the Art Gallery of South Australia

New Drawings by Robert Morris at Sprüth Magers in Berlin

Poignant Reminder of Harsh Realities of WWI for Sale at Bonhams

Tropical Forest Diversity Increased During Ancient Global Warming Event

Chaired by Michael Portillo, Art Fund Prize Judging Panel Announced for 2011

Gagosian Opens a New Gallery in Geneva

Expert Handwriting Analysis Concludes "Secret Mark" Not a Forgery

Jesus Wasn't Born in Bethlehem, According to Biblical Scholar

November 13, 2010

Boston's Museum of Fine Arts Unveils New $504 Million Art of the Americas Wing

Collection of American Furniture, Paintings and Works on Paper Acquired by the National Gallery

Sotheby's Announced It will to Offer Important Works on Behalf of the Beaverbrook Foundation

Bortolami Presents Its Second Solo Exhibition of Work by Israel-Born Artist Avner Ben-Gal

Artist David Hockney Applies Brush to Dog Bowls at Bonhams & Butterfields Auction

RISD Museum Showcases the Human Figure in Show About the Use of the Artist's Model Through Time

Most Comprehensive Exhibition of the Work of Thornton Dial to Premiere at the IMA in 2011

Exhibition of Outstanding Works on Paper from IVAM's Collection Opens in Valencia

80 Previously Unseen Works by Stephen Shore in First Exhibition in Berlin at Sprüth Magers

Gratz Family Portraits Reunited at Philadelphia's Rosenbach Museum & Library

Exhibition Explores the Conceptual Process of British Installation Artist Andy Goldsworthy

Pot o' Gold: Family's Old Vase Fetches $83 Million at Small Suburban London Auction House

40-Year Retrospective Exhibition of the Work of Tony May Opens at San Jose Institute of Contemporary Art

Strong, Colorful Surreal Paintings by Philemona Williamson at June Kelly Gallery

Art Basel Miami Beach 2010 Announces Art Public: 9 Public Art Works in Miami Beach

Neglect Threatens Many of Italy's Cherished Ruins

Metropolitan Museum to Undertake Major Redesign and Reconstruction of its Fifth Avenue Outdoor Plaza and Fountains

onedotzero and Wieden + Kennedy Announce 2011 Partnership

November 12, 2010

First Images of the Interior of Teotihuacan Tunnel Captured by Camera on Small Robot

Sotheby's to Offer the Rochefoucauld Grail: Witness of the Legend of King Arthur

London's Natural History Museum Urged to Stay Out of Isolated Latam Area

Spoils of Bernard Madoff's Lavish Life on Auction Block at a Manhattan Hotel this Saturday

International Shortlist for the Third Prix Pictet, World’s Leading Prize in Photography, Announced

Spectacular Tiffany, Frank Lloyd Wright Windows Lead Luxe Array of Fine Art at Morphy's

Chinese Emperor's Personal White Jade Dragon Seal Sells for £2.7 Million at Bonhams

Photographer Mick Rock's Images that Defined Rock n' Roll on View at Idea Generation Gallery

London Exhibition at Wellcome Collection Examines Centuries of Drug History

Masters of Photography Featured in Stieglitz, Steichen, Strand at Metropolitan Museum

Trunk Tells of the Leaving of Liverpool; New Acquisition a Reminder of Child Migrant Story

Nottingham Contemporary's First Year a Complete Success with Record Visitor Figures

Ancient Tablets Reveal Mathematical Achievements of Ancient Babylonian Culture

Exciting, Cutting-Edge Contemporary Video Installations at Philbrook Museum of Art

Hattie McDaniel's Personal Presentation Script from 'Gone with the Wind' on the Auction Block

Acclaimed Pop Artist Romero Britto and American Hero Astronaut Buzz Aldrin Launch an Artistic Vision for Reaching Mars

United Kingdom Government Art Reveals Ministers' Nostalgic Tastes

Ashwellthorpe Triptych to Go on Show at Norwich Cathedral

November 11, 2010

Pop! Christie's Sets New World Auction Record for Lichtenstein Achieving $42.6 Million

Exhibition Places New Acquisitions in the Context of MoMA's History of Collecting

$35 Million Andy Warhol Coke Bottle Lifts Sotheby's Contemporary Art Auction

Metropolitan and Egypt Announce Initiative to Recognize Egypt's Title to Objects from Tut's Tomb

Alexander McQueen's Iconic Designs to be Celebrated in Spring 2011 at the Metropolitan

Legendary Souvenir Chess Piece from 1897 to be Offered at Christie's South Kensington

Winner of the Taylor Wessing Photographic Prize Announced at the National Portrait Gallery

Exceptional Group of Modern and Contemporary Artworks on Offer at artnet Auctions

One of Only 19 Fabergé Snuff-Boxes with Portrait of Emperor Nicholas II Offered by Christie's

Amon Carter Museum of American Art Announces Andrew J. Walker as Director Designate

Sotheby's Auction of Fine Chinese Ceramics and Works of Art Brings £14 Million

Japanese Medicine Container Makes World Record in an International Sale at Bonhams

Sale of Modern and Contemporary Turkish Art at Antik A.S. in Istanbul Totals $ 10.2 Million

Curtain Closes on a Successful Abu Dhabi Art 2010

Two Artists Explore the Ruins of the 20th Century at the Hirshhorn

Ancient Temples Highlight Egyptian Lake Cruise

Disabled Veterans Memorial has DC Groundbreaking

Mark Polizzotti Named Publisher & Editor in Chief at Met Museum

National Gallery of Canada and the Museum of Contemporary Canadian Art Forge a New Partnership

Most Popular Last Seven Days



1.- Greece holds breath as skeleton found in Alexander the Great-era tomb at Amphipolis

2.- Spain mourns the death of art collector Cayetana Fitz-James Stuart, Duchess of Alba

3.- Meet the ancestors: Exhibition at Bordeaux gallery reveals faces of prehistoric humans

4.- Getty Foundation and partners launch free of charge online art collection catalogues

5.- Historic photos of dead Cuban revolutionary Che Guevara resurface in small Spanish town

6.- Exhibition showcases the first two 'Poesie' created by Titian following their restoration

7.- O'Keeffe painting sells for more than three times the previous world auction record for any female artist

8.- Crystal Bridges announces the departure of museum President Don Bacigalupi

9.- artnet Auctions offers a later example of Yayoi Kusama's important Infinity-Nets series

10.- 'Degenerate art' should go back to museums: German advisor Jutta Limbach

Related Stories



Retrospective of the Complete Works by Serge Charchoune at Artvera's Gallery



Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 

Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez - Marketing: Carla Gutiérrez
Special Contributor: Liz Gangemi - Special Advisor: Carlos Amador
Contributing Editor: Carolina Farias

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org theavemaria.org juncodelavega.org facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site