The First Art Newspaper on the Net Established in 1996 United States Wednesday, July 30, 2014


Newspaper's Revelation Rocks Civil Rights Photographer Ernest C. Withers' Family
Andrew Withers, from left, Frances Williams and Rosalind Withers-Guzman, all children of photographer Ernest Withers, react to a story about their father being an FBI informant during the civil rights movement in Memphis, Tenn., on Thursday, Sept. 16, 2010. The Withers children spoke in a museum housing many of their father's photographs. AP Photo/Lance Murphey.

By: Adrian Sainz, Associated Press Writer

MEMPHIS (AP).- The startling revelation that a revered civil rights photographer also was an FBI informant who tipped investigators about the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. and others has left his children denying he was a snitch and spurred some movement veterans to try to explain why he might have helped the feds.

This was to be the season when the late civil rights photographer Ernest C. Withers would be honored for his historic work, with his photos displayed at a museum bearing his name.

Instead, an investigation by The Commercial Appeal unmasked him as an informant who regularly tipped authorities about civil rights movement participants from at least 1968 to 1970.

"Personally, and as a family, we do not believe what has been alleged. It still has to be proven," Withers' youngest daughter, Rosalind Withers, told The Associated Press in an interview at the unfinished museum on Memphis' Beale Street, set to open later this year. She said the report provoked shock and disbelief.

The newspaper reviewed thousands of pages of federal documents obtained under the Freedom of Information Act, providing a glimpse into the FBI's surveillance of civil rights leaders.

D'Army Bailey, a former Memphis judge and activist, said colleagues knew the FBI was watching.

"It's a very serious and disturbing thing, it's not a surprising thing," Bailey said, adding that he suspects Withers wasn't the only one passing information on to the FBI.

"If you take it all the way back to slavery, there was never a successful slave revolt because the house Negroes would go and tell the boss man what the field Negroes were planning," Bailey said. "And this is all part of the same pattern. It teaches us a lesson that the more things change, the more they stay the same."

Ernest Withers, often called "the original civil rights photographer," died in 2007 at the age of 85.

His crisp black-and-white pictures chronicled the seminal Emmett Till murder trial in 1955, racial integration at the University of Mississippi in 1962 and the 1968 sanitation workers' strike in Memphis that brought King to the city where he was assassinated.

Withers marched with King, and was beaten by police while covering Medgar Evers' 1963 funeral. Relatives tell how white bystanders would hurl insults or spit at him as he covered civil rights marches.

But the FBI documents obtained by The Commercial Appeal present a story of spying and secrecy.

The newspaper did not have access to Withers' informant file because it is sealed. The Justice Department twice denied The Commercial Appeal's requests for that file and won't acknowledge it exists, the newspaper reported.

Instead, the government released 369 pages related to a 1970s public corruption probe that targeted Withers, who pleaded guilty in 1979 to extorting kickbacks from a nightclub owner while he was a Tennessee Alcoholic Beverage Commission agent. Those pages included redacted references to informants, but in one instance the FBI failed to hide a single reference to Withers' informant number, ME 338-R.

The newspaper then studied more than 7,000 pages of other FBI reports released 30 years ago under FOIA for references to the number. Those reports pinpoint specific actions by Withers and show he was one of several informants.

Withers proved "most conversant with all key activities in the Negro community," according to an FBI report cited by the newspaper,

It's not clear if Withers was paid for his information. However, retired Marquette University professor Athan Theoharis, an expert who reviewed the newspaper's findings, said Withers fits the profile of a paid informant who was closely supervised by area agents.

"It would be shocking to me that he wasn't paid," Theoharis told the newspaper.

During the sanitation workers' strike, Withers met with two FBI agents in Memphis, the newspaper found. A report indicates informant ME 338-R — Withers — supplied them a newsletter listing names and photographs of community leaders who likely organized the strike.

The day before King's April 4, 1968, assassination, the informant passed on details about a high-level strategy session at the Lorraine Hotel between King and young militants who had a role in the strike. Withers also revealed details from King's funeral in Atlanta, reporting that two Southern Christian Leadership Conference workers planned to return to Memphis "to resume ... support of sanitation strike," the newspaper reported.

In response to those nuggets and others in the story, some activists of the era acknowledged they were approached by the FBI or thought they were shadowed by the agency at one time or another.

The Rev. Jesse Jackson, then a close aide to King, said no one suspected Withers was an informant. Although Withers had access to the leaders, he was not in any "decision-making, influencing position."

"He was a basic photographer who was always around," Jackson said. "He was a man we had high regard for."

Warner Dickerson, a former teacher who now heads the NAACP's Memphis office and knew Withers well, said the photographer was "part of the 'hood, disadvantaged and denied."

Dickerson said Withers had selfish motives and committed a "subtle betrayal," but he expressed sympathy for the man who had children to raise.

"I don't think he was a mean person, I don't think he sold the race out," Dickerson said. "You cannot ignore the fact that he needed money ... It wasn't like he gave information to the FBI who used that to murder my people.

"I'm not quick to judge people," Dickerson added. "You have to walk in their shoes sometime before you can understand what motivates them to do that."

To his children, Withers was just a photographer, a charitable family man and a believer in King's message of racial equality.

Andrew Jerome Withers, Rosalind Withers and Frances Williams vow to do their own FOIA request and talk to the FBI themselves in efforts to clear their father's name.

"It will not diminish his legacy," said Andrew Withers, known to friends as "Rome." ''If you take a survey of Memphis, ask the people in the streets, you'll probably get 10 out of 10 that say 'I can't believe it.'"

Perhaps their biggest concern, and one that was echoed by movement veterans like Memphis resident Maxine Smith, was that Withers is not alive to respond to the revelations.

"We know that his good name will overcome anything that has come to him in his death," Rome Withers said. "He would be awfully mad for somebody to bring up an issue that has no proof."

___

Associated Press Writer Lucas Johnson in Nashville contributed to this report.


Copyright 2010 The Associated Press.

Ernest C. Withers | The Commercial Appeal | The Associated Press |


Last Week News

September 17, 2010

Do or Die: The Human Condition in Painting and Photography at the Wallraf-Richartz Museum

Newspaper's Revelation Rocks Civil Rights Photographer Ernest C. Withers' Family

Sotheby's Sets Record for Any Single Print Sold at Auction

New House Record at Christie's for the Most Expensive Item Sold Online

Sotheby's Asia Week Sales in New York Total $27,649,251

New Works in Bronze and Steel by John McCracken at David Zwirner

Smithsonian American Art Museum Announces E. Carmen Ramos as Curator for Latino Art

Former Director of the Nelson-Atkins Ted Coe has Died

Mark Twain: A Skeptic's Progress Opens at the Morgan Library

Dr. Michael W. Schantz appointed to Serve as Executive Director of The Heckscher Museum of Art

Rare Chinese Woodblock Prints on Display at The Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art

Peter Blum Gallery Shows Works of Art by Matthew Day Jackson

Virtual Fire by Thyra Hilden and Pio Diaz to Rage in the Colosseum for Art

Ellen Lesperance Named 2010 Betty Bowen Award Winner

Copy of Annie Leibovitz's 'John and Yoko' Up for Auction

Rare Arcimboldo Painting Acquired by the National Gallery of Art

Michael Dweck's American Mermaids Opens at acte2galerie in Paris

Sotheby's Presents Its Strongest Arts of The Islamic World Sale Ever Staged

Art Institute Showcases Seventeen Major Works of Pre-Columbian Art from Mexico

Shortlist Announced: Taylor Wessing Photographic Portrait Prize 2010

The City Bakery Opens Birdbath Café at New Museum on the Bowery

New Works, Inspired on Childhood Games, by Adam Fuss at Cheim & Read

Fossil of Giant, Bony-Toothed Bird from Chile Sets New Record for Wingspan

Tate Appoints Jessica Morgan as The Daskalopoulos Curator, International Art

Spectrum Jesus by Keith Coventry Scoops UK's Biggest Painting Prize

Official: Missing Painting Found by New York City Doorman

New Work by Renowned Sculptor and Glass Artist Dale Chihuly at Marlborough

Exhibition Explores a Foundation for Chinese Contemporary Art

Bold and Powerfully Inventive Artist Salvator Rosa Featured in Exhibition

Crystal Bridges Museum Hires Rod Bigelow as Deputy Director

Public Art Fund Presents a New Project by Ryan Gander Entitled The Happy Prince

Major Bruno Di Bello Retrospective Opens at Fondazione Marconi

Bauhaus Archive Commemorates Hajo Rose's 100th Anniversary with Exhibition

Saint Louis Art Museum Receives Major Gift from Danforth Family

Extending the Runway: Tatiana Sorokko Style Makes U.S. Debut

Hitler's Car Gift to Nepal King to Get a New Life

September 16, 2010

Fossil of Giant, Bony-Toothed Bird from Chile Sets New Record for Wingspan

Michael Dweck's American Mermaids Opens at acte2galerie in Paris

Art Institute Showcases Seventeen Major Works of Pre-Columbian Art from Mexico

Tate Appoints Jessica Morgan as The Daskalopoulos Curator, International Art

Official: Missing Painting Found by New York City Doorman

Crystal Bridges Museum Hires Rod Bigelow as Deputy Director

Bold and Powerfully Inventive Artist Salvator Rosa Featured in Exhibition

Major Bruno Di Bello Retrospective Opens at Fondazione Marconi

Public Art Fund Presents a New Project by Ryan Gander Entitled The Happy Prince

Spectrum Jesus by Keith Coventry Scoops UK's Biggest Painting Prize

Saint Louis Art Museum Receives Major Gift from Danforth Family

Extending the Runway: Tatiana Sorokko Style Makes U.S. Debut

New Works, Inspired on Childhood Games, by Adam Fuss at Cheim & Read

Bauhaus Archive Commemorates Hajo Rose's 100th Anniversary with Exhibition

Hitler's Car Gift to Nepal King to Get a New Life

The City Bakery Opens Birdbath Café at New Museum on the Bowery

Shortlist Announced: Taylor Wessing Photographic Portrait Prize 2010

Exhibition Explores a Foundation for Chinese Contemporary Art

MoMA Exhibition Explores Design and the Modern Kitchen

Turmoil in Tibet: Early 20th Century Images at Bonhams

Gabriel Orozco Presents an Expanded Version of His Show at Centre Pompidou

Platinum Prints & Classic Snaps by Elliott Erwitt at Magnum Print Room

Table Commissioned by East Indian Royalty Headlines Austin Auction's Sale

Karl Lagerfeld's Photos on Display at Maison Europeene de la Photographie

The Turner Prize Goes to BALTIC Centre for Contemporary Art in 2011

Competitive Bidding Drives Prices Past Estimates at Saffronart's Autumn Online Auction

First Solo U.S. Exhibition for Italian Designer Antonio Pio at Industry Gallery

Drawings and Three-Dimensional Objects by Al Taylor at David Zwirner

Roman Signer: Four Rooms, One Artist Opens at Swiss Institute

Crystal Bridges Announces Works by Warhol, Lichtenstein

Exhibition of Works by Inner Circle of Max's Kansas City Artists Opens

Warner Bros. Presents Gift to Smithsonian; New Digital 3-D Theater

Sotheby's Presents Its Strongest Arts of The Islamic World Sale Ever Staged

Sale of Prints by Modern and Contemporary Masters Expected to Realise £5.3 Million

Miami's Museum Park Sees First Signs of Development

World-Renowned Architectural Firm Pelli Clarke Pelli to Design New University of Iowa Auditorium

Invincible WW2 Fighter Pilot's Medals for Sale at Bonhams

Pele's Final International Match Worn Shirt from 1971 to Sell at Bonhams

September 15, 2010

Exhibition of Forty Prints at Fundación BBK in Bilbao Shows Henri Matisse's Intimate Side

MoMA Exhibition Explores Design and the Modern Kitchen

Gabriel Orozco Presents an Expanded Version of His Show at Centre Pompidou

Karl Lagerfeld's Photos on Display at Maison Europeene de la Photographie

Platinum Prints & Classic Snaps by Elliott Erwitt at Magnum Print Room

Exhibition of Works by Inner Circle of Max's Kansas City Artists at Steven Kasher Gallery

Crystal Bridges Announces Works by Warhol, Lichtenstein

The Turner Prize Goes to BALTIC Centre for Contemporary Art in 2011

A Selection of Drawings and Three-Dimensional Objects by Al Taylor at David Zwirner

Warner Bros. Presents Gift to Smithsonian; New Digital 3-D Theater

First Solo U.S. Exhibition for Italian Designer and Architect Antonio Pio at Industry Gallery

Turmoil in Tibet: Early 20th Century Images at Bonhams

Roman Signer: Four Rooms, One Artist Opens at Swiss Institute

Table Commissioned by East Indian Royalty Headlines Austin Auction's Sale

Competitive Bidding Drives Prices Past Estimates at Saffronart's Autumn Online Auction

Major International Collaboration Yields Never Before Seen Forbidden City Treasures

Dan Colen's First Major Solo Exhibition in New York at Gagosian

Israel Museum Awards Michal Heiman First Shpilman International Prize

First Solo Exhibition by Michael Patterson-Carver in London at Timothy Taylor Gallery

New York City Exhibit Captures Photographer's Vision of the City

Scholars to Present New Findings on Henri Rousseau's Media and Methods

First Major Museum Exhibition of Works by Elad Lassry Opens in St. Louis

Bonampak Lineage Might Have Come from Plan de Ayutla, Chiapas

Home of "Ice Giants" Thaws, Shows Pre-Viking Reindeer Hunts

After 75 Years, Boeing Co. will Demolish Historic Plant 2

Bonhams Launch Irish Art Department with First Sale in February

Chinese Emperor's Seal Expected to Make Millions at Bonhams

Ninth Edition of the Most Prestigious Art Show in the Americas Announced

Bonhams & Butterfields to Offer the J.D. Collection of Saint-Gaudens $10 Eagles

Global Positioning System? Mapquest? Not for Fans of Hand-Drawn Maps

Art Institute of Chicago Appoints Daniel Walker Chair of Two Departments

Christie's New York to Offer Extraordinary Collection of Unique Daguerreotypes

Art Detroit Now Presents Detroit Gallery Week

Transport: A Major Thematic Exhibition by Marc Newson at Gagosian

The Menil Collection to Publish Jasper Johns Catalogue Raisonné

September 14, 2010

Vatican Apostolic Library Reopens to Scholars After Three-Year and $11.5 Million Restoration

After 75 Years, Boeing Co. will Demolish Historic Plant 2

Ninth Edition of the Most Prestigious Art Show in the Americas Announced

Bonhams Launch Irish Art Department with First Sale in February

Chinese Emperor's Seal Expected to Make Millions at Bonhams

Christie's New York to Offer Extraordinary Collection of Unique Daguerreotypes

Transport: A Major Thematic Exhibition by Marc Newson at Gagosian

Global Positioning System? Mapquest? Not for Fans of Hand-Drawn Maps

The Menil Collection to Publish The Catalogue Raisonné of the Drawings of Jasper Johns

Bonhams & Butterfields to Offer the J.D. Collection of Saint-Gaudens $10 Eagles

"Notorious & Notable" Fashion Exhibit Pays Homage to New York Style Icons

Bay Area Artist Nellie King Solomon Exhibits at Brian Gross Fine Art

Gallery's Detective Work Shows Two Portraits Painted at the Same Time

Works by Ryan Leigh, Sam Knowles and Nick Bailey at Simon Oldfield Gallery

Exhibition Presents Photographs of José A. Figueroa's "Other" Life in Cuba

The Biography and Complete Catalog Raisonné on William Bouguereau Out this Week

Roman Bronze Helmet, Found with a Metal Detector, to Be Offered at Christie's

Medal Awarded to Carpathia Crew for Rescue of Titanic Survivors to Sell

Picasso Graphics Museum Celebrates 10th Anniversary, Changes Name

Strong Group of Works by The Glasgow Boys to Open Sotheby's London Sale

Origins and Mysteries of the Inca's Gold Explored at Pinacothèque de Paris

New Works by Christof Mascher at Galerie Michael Janssen

Art of the 1980s: A Düsseldorf Perspective at Kunstsammlung Nordrhein-Westfalen

Elements, Objects and Groupings by Jean-Pascal Flavien at Galerie Michel Rein

Tom Leighton "Appropiation of Space" Opens at Cynthia Corbett Gallery

Sotheby's Announces Third Offering From The James S. Copley Library

80 Coloured Ink Paintings Made by Josephine King at Riflemaker

Yul Brynner's Photographic Oeuvre Shown for the First Time

Art Institute of Chicago Appoints Daniel Walker Chair of Two Curatorial Departments

Columbia University Buys 1st Amendment Crusader's Papers

September 13, 2010

Landmark Exhibition of Siqueiros Landscape Paintings at the Museum of Latin American Art

A Remarkable Roman Bronze Helmet, Found with a Metal Detector, to Be Offered at Christie's

Pablo Picasso Graphics Museum Celebrates 10th Anniversary, Changes Name

Medal Awarded to Carpathia Crew for Rescue of Titanic Survivors to Sell at Bonhams

Tom Leighton "Appropiation of Space" Opens at Cynthia Corbett Gallery

Origins and Mysteries of the Inca's Gold Explored in New Exhibition at Pinacothèque de Paris

Sotheby's Announces Third Offering From The James S. Copley Library

Art of the 1980s: A Düsseldorf Perspective at Kunstsammlung Nordrhein-Westfalen

Gallery's Detective Work Shows Two Portraits Painted at the Same Time

Works by Ryan Leigh, Sam Knowles and Nick Bailey at Simon Oldfield Gallery

Strong Group of Works by The Glasgow Boys to Open Sotheby's London Sale of Scottish Pictures

"Notorious & Notable" Fashion Exhibit Pays Homage to New York Style Icons

Bay Area Artist Nellie King Solomon Exhibits at Brian Gross Fine Art

Elements, Objects and Groupings by Jean-Pascal Flavien at Galerie Michel Rein

Solo Exhibition of Photographic Project by Andrzej Maciejewski Opens at Sticks Cultural Centre

New Art Collection Arrives at Four Seasons Hotel in Washington

Second Solo Exhibition for Eric Fertman at Susan Inglett Gallery

Pedro Barateiro's "Theatre of Hunters" at Kunsthalle Basel

First Museum Exhibition in Switzerland of Work by Eccentric Landscape Artist Carl Wilhelm Kolbe

Jack Rutberg Fine Arts Presents U.S. Debut Exhibition by Spanish Artist Jordi Alcaraz

Twenty Works on Canvas and Paper by Joan Mitchell at Manny Silverman Gallery

New Works by Jennifer Steinkamp at Lehmann Maupin

Retrospective Exhibition Marks the Centennial of Morris Graves' Birthday

Faith Ringgold's Paintings of the 1960s are the Focus of an Exhibition

The Meadows Museum Presents El Greco's Monumental Painting, Pentecost

A Year in the Painting Life of Joan Snyder at Cuningham Gallery

Duncan Miller Gallery Shows Both Sides of Ansel Adams Dispute

"Nueva York" Turns Lens South to New York Hispanic Roots

Tate Announces First Major Retrospective of Joan Miró in Fifty Years

Hot Dogs, Lobbies, Football and Ouagadougou at PDNB Gallery

European Abstraction Post World War II Opens at Bechtler Museum of Modern Art

Tallest Free-Standing Bronze in London to Be Installed on Tuesday

British Museum Gets $38 Million Gift from John Sainsbury

September 12, 2010

Comprehensive Nam June Paik Retrospective Opens at Museum Kunst Palast in Dusseldorf

Tate Announces First Major Retrospective of Joan Miró in Fifty Years

The Meadows Museum Presents El Greco's Monumental Painting, Pentecost

Duncan Miller Gallery Shows Both Sides of Ansel Adams Dispute

"Nueva York" Turns Lens South to New York Hispanic Roots

New Works by Jennifer Steinkamp at Lehmann Maupin

Tallest Free-Standing Bronze in London to Be Installed on Tuesday

Twenty Works on Canvas and Paper by Joan Mitchell at Manny Silverman Gallery

Faith Ringgold's Paintings of the 1960s are the Focus of an Exhibition

European Abstraction Post World War II Opens at Bechtler Museum of Modern Art

Retrospective Exhibition Marks the Centennial of Morris Graves' Birthday

A Year in the Painting Life of Joan Snyder at Cuningham Gallery

Hot Dogs, Lobbies, Football and Ouagadougou at PDNB Gallery

British Museum Gets $38 Million Gift

Le Mont Rouge: Large Contemporary Sculpture Installed at the University of Utah

Neuberger Museum of Art Presents 40-Year Survey of Pat Steir's Exploration of Drawing

Fine Chinese Paintings Autumn Sale 2010 Announced at Sotheby's

Sotheby's Hong Kong Announces Autumn Contemporary Asian Art Sale

Dusseldorf's Quadriennale 2010 Opens with Joseph Beuys Exhibition

Large-Scale Installation by Sol LeWitt at Gladstone Gallery in Brussels

Exhibition of Paintings and Works on Paper by Lari Pittman at Regen Projects

Artists Explore Otherworldly Depths of the Imagination in New Exhibition

Gasser Grunert Gallery Presents Tim Rodas "Games of Antiquities"

Contemporary Art Foundation Announces New Director of Development

Side by Side: Oberlin's Masterworks at the Phillips Collection

Exhibition Focuses on Berlin's Weimar Era in Jeanne Mammen: City of Women

Science, Religion and Politics: The Royal Society at the National Portrait Gallery

New Embroidery Paintings and Sculpture by Angelo Filomeno at Galerie Lelong

Works by David Kapp and Tom Burckhardt at Tibor de Nagy Gallery

New Works by Chinese Artist Liao Yibai at Mike Weiss Gallery

'Easy Riders' On Display in Massey Gallery Exhibition

Most Popular Last Seven Days



1.- Archaeologists discover Roman 'free choice' cemetery in the 2,700-year-old ancient port of Rome

2.- Romanians must pay 18 million euros over Kunsthal Museum Rotterdam art heist

3.- Hello Kitty designer Yuko Yamaguchi defends cute character as cat turns 40 years old

4.- eBay and Sotheby's partner to bring world class art and collectibles to a global community

5.- Exhibition on Screen returns with new series of films bringing great art to big screens across the globe

6.- Marina Abramović reaches half way point of her '512 Hours' performance at the Serpentine Gallery

7.- The Phillips Collection in Washington introduces a uCurate app for curating on-the-go

8.- United States comic icon Archie Andrews dies saving openly gay character

9.- New feathered predatory fossil, unearthed in China, sheds light on dinosaur flight

10.- Exhibition at Thyssen Bornemisza Museum presents an analysis of the concept of the 'unfinished'



Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 

Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Rmz. - Marketing: Carla Gutiérrez
Special Contributor: Liz Gangemi - Special Advisor: Carlos Amador
Contributing Editor: Carolina Farias

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org theavemaria.org juncodelavega.org facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site