The First Art Newspaper on the Net Established in 1996 United States Wednesday, September 17, 2014


Citizens of Turkey See Ottoman Empire Legacy in New Light
The Ottoman-era Sultan Ahmed or Blue Mosque, one of the landmarks of Turkey's largest city and the country's cultural and economic capital, is seen under a cloudy sky in Istanbul, Turkey. For most of the last century, Turks were told to look askance at the Ottoman Empire. Today, the legacy of the Ottomans is enjoying a makeover. AP Photo/Ibrahim Usta.

By: Christopher Torchia, Associated Press Writer

ISTANBUL (AP).- This month, a troupe of 100 musicians, dancers, acrobats and robed actors is performing an Ottoman-style spectacle near Topkapi Palace, once home to the sultans. An exhibition of Ottoman poetry is on display at Istanbul's international airport. Ottoman cuisine, a fusion of flavors from old imperial lands, is in vogue.

It's quite a turnaround. For most of the last century, Turks were told to look askance at the Ottoman Empire. Nostalgia for the 1453 conquest of Constantinople and other early triumphs was fine — but the excesses of the sultans were the stuff of decay, no model for modern Turkey.

Today, the legacy of the Ottomans is enjoying a makeover.

Turkey is a regional power that no longer sees itself as a junior partner of the West. Its diplomats and entrepreneurs reach out to Iraq, Iran, Syria and other lands once ruled from the Ottoman court. The roots of this confident campaign lie partly in the protocol, pluralism and Islamic piety of the imperial past.

These selective views, the old and the new, mirror a contemporary clash over Turkey's identity. It pits old secular elites in state entities such as the courts and military against an educated class of devout Muslims that has controlled the government since election in 2002.

"This is a point of real contestation: what is the Ottoman Empire for Turkey?" said Donald Quataert, author of "The Ottoman Empire, 1700-1922" and a longtime researcher into the lives of Ottoman peasants and workers. "They've been arguing about this for 100 years. It's been going back and forth."

At one time, the Ottoman sultans commanded vast swaths of territory from Istanbul, which spans the European and Asian continents. Their armies marched as far as the gates of Vienna. The rise of European powers compounded their decline, and the empire dissolved in war and chaos at the beginning of the 20th century. The mass killing of Armenians, deemed a genocide by many international experts despite Turkish objections, happened in the last years of Ottoman rule.

Any discussion of its legacy must include Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, a war hero who founded the Turkish republic in 1923 as colonial powers gobbled up former Ottoman territories. He abolished the caliphate and its traditions of dress and language, viewed as symbols of stagnation. Secularism was the creed, the West was the model.

Today, Ataturk's image adorns state offices, shops and many private homes. Roads and sports stadiums bear his name. A huge mausoleum in the capital, Ankara, harbors his remains, and most visiting foreign dignitaries are expected to pay tribute. It is a crime in Turkey to insult the memory of Ataturk, whose name means "father of the Turks."

Many Turks, including those who resent how he curtailed religious expression, believe Ataturk saved Turkey in a time of crisis. But increasingly, even staunch supporters admit unquestioning devotion is out of sync with democracy.

"The changes of the republic, like many other things in this country, were imposed from the top and not designed by the public itself, and this is a bad habit of our people," said Ahmet Hicyilmaz, a publicist in Istanbul.

Ataturk's unrelenting nationalism allowed little room for minority rights, seen as a dire threat to state unity. Ottoman advocates, however, note the sultans were generally tolerant of Christians and other minorities in a tactic that may have extended the empire's life.

On Sunday, for the first time since the fall of the empire, Orthodox Christians led by their spiritual leader, Patriarch Bartholomew I, held a Mass at an ancient monastery cut into the side of a mountain near the Black Sea. The Byzantine-era monastery of Sumela was abandoned in 1923.

Turkish nationalists have objected to Bartholomew using the term "ecumenical" to describe his Istanbul-based patriarchate, fearing it implies a Vatican-style state on Turkish soil. But Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan referred to Ottoman times when asked about the matter by a journalist during a May visit to Greece.

"When it comes to the question of ecumenical, if the term did not bother my ancestors, than it does not bother me," Erdogan said, using an Ottoman-era term for ancestor — "ecdad" — instead of the modern Turkish term, "ata."

Erdogan, a fierce critic of Israel, has cited the Ottoman Empire as evidence that Turks are not anti-Semitic. Many of Turkey's Jews trace roots to Spain, where Jews fled persecution in the 15th century and were welcomed by the Ottomans.

"Republican history taught the Ottoman era in a very backward and negative light," Suat Kiniklioglu, a member of the Turkish parliament's foreign affairs committee, wrote in an email to the Associated Press. "We are now correcting the imbalance on our historical perceptions."

The Islamic-oriented government, however, objects to the term "neo-Ottoman," which has been used by some commentators to describe Turkey's outreach to former colonies. Turkey says it has no hegemonic intent.

Even Kurdish rebels fighting the Turkish state for autonomy are looking to imperial history to press their case. A recent rebel statement quoted a top leader, Murat Karayilan, as saying Kurds always enjoyed autonomy under Ottoman rule.

Now that the Ottomans are back in favor, there is the danger of glossing things over. Many Turks know Piri Reis, an admiral and mapmaker, as a key figure in Ottoman marine history. Fewer know that he was beheaded after a falling out with authorities.

Historian Ilber Ortayli, head of the museum at Topkapi Palace, said the Ottoman empire was the "basic identity" of the Turkish people, excluding some minority groups. He said Turks were studying the period in earnest, though the road to full understanding was long.

"We didn't learn it well," he said. "Our knowledge is full of mistakes and black holes."

___

Associated Press writer Erol Israfil contributed to this report.


Copyright 2010 The Associated Press.

Ottoman Empire Legacy | Turkey | Donald Quataert |


Last Week News

August 16, 2010

Funerary Masks of Six Maya Rulers on View at the National Museum of Anthropology

Tate Collection Archivist Says Uncovers Real-Life Quasimodo

Florence and State Spar Over Michelangelo's Masterpiece 'David'

Jimi Hendrix Items on Show in His Former London Home

Frank Auerbach Painting Emerges After 30 Years in Private Hands

Bob Dylan to Exhibit at the National Gallery of Denmark

Old Irish Bones may Yield Murderous Secrets in Pennsylvania

Aperture Foundation Announces New Exhibition: "Paul Strand in Mexico"

Orthodox Flock to Once-Banned Holy Site of Sumela Monastery in Turkey

Josef Koudelka's Testimony of the Prague Invasion Opens in Buenos Aires

Jackie O's Pearl Necklace Makes Over the Odds at Bonhams

Richard Deacon at the Museum of Modern and Contemporary Art of Strasbourg

MoMA to Present a Weeklong Run of Goran Paskaljevic's Honeymoons

Art Gallery to Save Energy of 80 Households a Year, with "Green Gallery"

US Sound and Media Artist, Stephen Vitiello in Sydney for 20th Kaldor Public Art Project

Clarke Auction's Eighth Fine Auction Opens at Spectacular New Larchmont Location

Amon Carter Museum of American Art Receives Federal Digitization Grant

Tourcoing Fine Arts Museum Announces Eugène Leroy Exhibition

Le Fresnoy to Show "ABC: Contemporary Art from Belgium"

Meeting Points: Ronit Agassi, Gary Goldstein at the Tel Aviv Museum of Art

The Indian Empire: Significant Works from the Portvale Collection on View in Sydney

The Woodland Garden Photographs of Theodore Nierenberg to Be Shown at the Bruce Museum

Christopher Henry Gallery Presents the London Biennale 2010

Daniel M. Finley Appointed President and Chief Executive Officer of the Autry National Center

Three Contemporary Art Exhibition Concepts to Be Realized Through Major Award to Curators

Freeman's Auctioneers to Sell the Estate of Joseph S. Sorger

August 15, 2010

Turkey's Culture Minister Announces Discovery of Two Tunnels Leading to Ancient Tomb

Aperture Foundation Announces New Exhibition: "Paul Strand in Mexico"

Orthodox Flock to Once-Banned Holy Site of Sumela Monastery in Turkey

Josef Koudelka's Testimony of the Prague Invasion Opens in Buenos Aires

The Reassembled Archaeological Collection of Max von Oppenheim

Museum of Contemporary Art Announces "The Art Auction"

Archaeologists Discover the Tomb of a Teenager Buried for Over 1600 Years

In September, All Eyes will Be on Kees van Dongen Exhibition

Seattle Art Museum Presents Behind the Scenes: The Real Story of Quileute Wolves

Titanic Salvage Company Wins Award from Virginia Court

High Museum to Offer Half-Price Tickets for Dalí Exhibition

Iconic Ear Pendants by JAR Highlight Christie's October Jewels Sale

Arkansas Arts Center to Present Exhibition of Mexican Art Since 1910

Sacred Artifacts Returned to Northern California Tribe

A Special Exhibition Commemorates the 75th Anniversary of Social Security

Tip: Shepard Fairey Offers Behind-the-Scenes Studio Tour

Ohio-Based Artist Berry van Boekel Exhibits at Country Club

New Amazon Monkey Species Discovered in Colombia

Walker Art Center's Senior Graphic Designer Emmet Byrne Promoted to Design Director

Single-Owner Collection of Whimsical Tobacco Jars to Highlight Summer Auction at Bonhams & Butterfields

MoMA to Celebrate Experimental Filmmaker Barbara Hammer with Exhibition

August 14, 2010

Winner of Bravo's Work of Art, Abdi Farah, to Have Solo Exhibition at the Brooklyn Museum

In September, All Eyes will Be on Kees van Dongen Exhibition

Seattle Art Museum Presents Behind the Scenes: The Real Story of Quileute Wolves

Titanic Salvage Company Wins Award from Virginia Court

High Museum to Offer Half-Price Tickets for Dalí Exhibition

Iconic Ear Pendants by JAR Highlight Christie's October Jewels Sale

Arkansas Arts Center to Present A Century of Revolution: Mexican Art Since 1910

HBO Archives to Celebrate 75th Anniversary of Documentary Series

Romantics Display Opens at Tate Britain Following Major Re-Hang

Archaeologists from Cardiff University Discover Ancient Roman Buildings

Works by Rackstraw Downes on View this Winter at the Portland Museum of Art

London Show Explores Skin as Human Body's Frontier

Tacheles: Berlin's Alternative Scene Fights for Survival

Century-Old Scotch Pulled from Antarctic Ice at the Canterbury Museum

New Research Suggests Orangutans Not so Solitary

8-Year-Old Painting Prodigy "Mini Monet" is New Art World Star

Installations Highlight the Contemporary Art of the Dallas Museum of Art

President Obama Forcefully Endorses Mosque Near Ground Zero

Nevada Museum of Art Opens Fletcher Benton: The Artist's Studio

The Royal Collection Announces A Victorian Christmas at Windsor Castle

Auction Offers Pieces of Country for Conservation

Maine Ram Island Ledge Lighthouse with Million-Dollar View for Sale

Photographer Returns to Trace Liverpool Families

The AIA Recognizes Nine Projects with the 2010 CAE Educational Facility Design Awards

August 13, 2010

Extremely Rare 2,200-Year Old Gold Coin Uncovered by Excavations at Tell Kedesh

HBO Archives to Celebrate 75th Anniversary of the March of Time® Documentary Series

Romantics Display Opens at Tate Britain Following Major Re-Hang of the Clore Galleries

Archaeologists from Cardiff University Discover Ancient Roman Monumental Buildings

Works by Rackstraw Downes on View this Winter at the Portland Museum of Art

London Show Explores Skin as Human Body's Frontier

Tacheles: Berlin's Alternative Scene Fights for Survival

'Lucy' Species Used Stone Tools, Fossil Study by California Academy Says

Mumbai's Taj Hotel Reopens Sunday After 2008 Attacks

MoMA Launches Free iPhone App, Now Available on App Store

Christina Aguilera Lends Her Voice to Support the Arts

Money Fair in Boston Showcases $100,000 Bills, Rare Coins

NYC Seeks to Reclaim Notable Central Park Drawings

Museum of Modern Art Celebrates Pioneering Filmmaker Ida Lupino

New York City on Track for Record Number of Tourists in 2010

Bonhams to Sell Replica Spitfire for the Royal British Legion

Aspen Art Museum's Summer Benefit Gala artCRUSH Raises $1.5 Million

Renowned International Artists to Display New Works at Beyond/In Western New York

Award-Winning 'Cathy' Comic Strip Ending After 34 Years

BLM Wraps Up Meetings on Colorado River Art Proposal

Dr. Shirley Thomson, Former Director of the National Gallery of Canada, Died

Nashville Last Stop for Masterpieces Before Works Return to Paris

South Korean Fashion Designer Andre Kim Dies at Age 74

Muslim Gravestones Removed from Jerusalem Cemetery

National Museum of American History Accepts Red Hat Society Donation

August 12, 2010

More than a Dozen Multi-Million Dollar Cars Lead RM's Silver Anniversary Monterey Sale

'Lucy' Species Used Stone Tools, Fossil Study by California Academy of Sciences Says

Mumbai's Taj Hotel Reopens Sunday After 2008 Attacks

MoMA Launches Free iPhone App, Now Available on App Store

Christina Aguilera Lends Her Voice to Support the Arts

Money Fair in Boston Showcases $100,000 Bills, Rare Coins

Renowned International Artists to Display New Works at Beyond/In Western New York

Fundació Antoni Tàpies Presents a New Selection of Works from the Collection

Very Original Features: Is this United Kingdom's Oldest Home?

Martin Luther has Wittenberg, Germany in a Stir 500 Years On

Smithsonian Extends Chance to Glimpse Rare Blue Diamond

Contemporary Art Museum St. Louis Appoints Dominic Molon as Chief Curator

Two Tableaux Vivants After Regent Portraits by Jan de Bray

Asia's Most Sought after Wine in Pristine Condition with Perfect Provenance

Artistic Explorations by 22 Artists at Benrimon Contemporary

Relic from Darwin's Epic Beagle Voyage for Sale at Bonhams

Rare Communion Silver Bought for Birmingham

Work Begins on Deluxe 17,000-Square-Foot Addition to Dan Morphy Auctions Gallery

It Bag, Watch Out: France's Duvelleroy Folding Fan is Back

Hannah Eidinow's New Street Theatre Commission for the Vauxhall Collective Comes to Edinburgh

Winslow Homer Classic Portrait Featured in American Treasures Stamp Series

SFMOMA to Present Exposed: Voyeurism, Surveillance and The Camera Since 1870

Clare Twomey's First Solo Exhibition in the United States Will Be at The Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art

August 11, 2010

Museum Wiesbaden Restitutes Painting by Dutch Baroque Painter Pieter de Grebber

Rock and Roll Hall of Fame to Feature Elvis 1956 Photographs by Alfred Wertheimer

Oil-Inspired Spread for August Issue of Vogue Italia Stirs Muck

Scarlett's "Gone With the Wind" Dresses in Bad Shape, Need Repairs

Sean O'Harrow Named Director of University of Iowa Museum of Art

Sotheby's Hong Kong to Offer Lots Estimated in Excess of $205 Million

Cabinet Secrets: Exhibition of Prints and Drawings at Tel Aviv Museum of Art

Alberta Artist Materializes Childhood Memory in Elaborate Installation

9/11 Museum Going Up in New York City Offers Raw Experience

New Exhibit by Ritsue Mishima Puts Aberdeen Art Gallery in a Spin

Palazzo Strozzi Announces "Bronzino: Artist and Poet of the Court of the Medici"

Bruce Museum Acquires Sculpture by Gaston Lachaise

Onassis Foundation to Hold a Major Conference on the Greek Cultural Legacy

White House Backdrop is Fine Art

Antiques Dealers Fair Limited to Launch New Boutique Fine Art and Antiques Fair in Leicestershire

Fire at Majdanek Destroys Shoes of Nazi Victims

Mississippi Museum of Art Presents Art by Choice Exhibition, Sale and Auction

Royal Scottish Academy Awards £21,000 to Scottish Artists

Falmouth Acquires Gotch Masterpiece at Record Price

Most Popular Last Seven Days



1.- Scientists at Germany's Karl May Museum weigh returning Native American scalp

2.- Totally Thames launches Florentijn Hofman's first ever UK commission: HippopoThames

3.- Restoring Albrecht Dürer's masterpiece The Arch of Honour of Maximilian I

4.- German Consulate in New York presents the work of forgotten 20th century master painter

5.- Cave carving in Gibraltar may be first known example of Neanderthal rock art

6.- Monet discovered in suitcase taken into German hospital by 'Nazi art' hoarder

7.- Gustav Klimt's 'Portrait Adele Bloch-Bauer II' on view at the Museum of Modern Art

8.- Dreadnoughtus: Meet Argentina's supermassive, 85 feet from nose to tail, 'fear nought' dino

9.- Monet's 'Impressionism' birth dated by Texas State University's 'Celestial Sleuth'

10.- 'Chess' man star attraction at tattoo convention in Peru



Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 

Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez - Marketing: Carla Gutiérrez
Special Contributor: Liz Gangemi - Special Advisor: Carlos Amador
Contributing Editor: Carolina Farias

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org theavemaria.org juncodelavega.org facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site