The First Art Newspaper on the Net Established in 1996 United States Saturday, November 22, 2014


Book Asks Who's Greater, Michelangelo or Leonardo?
LONDON (REUTERS).- A new book focuses on a 16th century competition that set out to discover who was the better artist -- Michelangelo or Leonardo Da Vinci, and says the outcome profoundly influenced the Renaissance titans' legacies.

Jonathan Jones, a British art critic who has been a Turner Prize judge, said the contest was familiar to art historians but to his knowledge had not been treated as the subject for a book.

"The Lost Battles: Leonardo, Michelangelo and the Artistic Duel that Defined the Renaissance," published by Simon & Schuster," hits stores on Thursday and describes a dramatic and defining moment in art history.

The decision by Florence officials that Michelangelo was the victor helped launch the younger artist's career and set him on a path to glory with key commissions in Rome.

Leonardo, meanwhile, was sidelined despite having a more established reputation, and ended up in the French court, which would have been looked down upon by Italy's art patrons.

"You are not left in much doubt that it was a competition," Jones said in a telephone interview. "The Florentine Renaissance was obsessed with competition."

And so, at the turn of the 16th century, the Florentine government commissioned the artists to produce rival battle frescos -- Leonardo's "Battle of Anghiari" and Michelangelo's "Battle of Cascina" -- for a hall in the civic palace.

Neither painting was completed and both are lost, although they survive partially through engravings and sketches. But Jones is in little doubt Michelangelo emerged from the contest with his reputation enhanced while Leonardo suffered a setback.

By presenting Michelangelo as a genius who was working on a great battle painting, the Florentine state helped him secure an even more important commission, the Sistine Chapel, Jones said.

"It was a very important thing that he had trashed Leonardo in this competition and was seen as the greatest artist in history," Jones added. "That was because he had this competition and had won it.

"Yet Leonardo, who was arguably the most famous of them all, doesn't get any of those commissions (to rebuild Rome). He was seen as not delivering in the contest."

History Kinder to Leonardo
Jones argues that the fiercely competitive atmosphere of Renaissance art helped spur it to ever greater heights, even if it did damage some careers while helping to launch others.

He also believes that had Leonardo's battle picture been championed in the same way as that of his rival, the history of Italian art may have taken a darker, more disturbing turn.

"It (the lost battle picture) probably was his masterpiece and was almost like the antithesis of the Renaissance," he said. "If he (Leonardo) had been the model for the artist, over the next 200-300 years a lot of things might have been different."

While the two-year contest that ended in 1506 cast Leonardo as the loser, Jones believes history has been kinder to him.

"I've changed my mind so many times in writing this book," Jones said, asked who he thought was the greater of the two.

"These were both incomparable geniuses. There is no question that Michelangelo did win, but Leonardo has won historically, just about.

"Michelangelo has been consistently revered, but since Leonardo's notebooks started to be edited and translated and popularized in the 19th century, and we get a sense of Leonardo as a scientist and not just an artist, Leonardo has probably pipped Michelangelo to the post.

"Leonardo, in my heart, ultimately wins."
(Reporting by Mike Collett-White, editing by Paul Casciato)

Renaissance | Michelangelo | Leonardo Da Vinci | Simon & Schuster |




Last Week News

March 30, 2010

Princess Diana's Family Offers Painting by Peter Paul Rubens in $30 million Sale at Christie's

Hirshhorn to Present First Yves Klein Retrospective in 30 Years

Door to Afterlife from Ancient Egyptian Tomb Found by Archaeologists

Superman Comic Sells for $1.5 Million, Setting New Record

Seven New Oil Paintings by Malcolm Morley at Xavier Hufkens

"Herbert G. Ponting: The Conquest of the South Pole" at Flo Peters Gallery

Masterpieces by the Scottish Colourists to Lead Sotheby's London Sale

The Cars' Ric Ocasek Exhibits in NY for the First Time at Cinders Gallery

New Work from Contemporary Chinese Artists Lu Chunsheng and Jia Aili at Iniva

New Book Shows Explosions, Fires, and Public Order by Sarah Pickering

Leang Seckon's First European Solo Exhibition Opens at Rossi & Rossi

Photographer Cuny Janssen Presents Latest Project at Foam

Asian Arts Sale at Freeman's Boasts Great Results

Exhibition Explores Authority, Learning, and Categorization

First Exhibition for Peter Lemmens at Galerie van der Mieden

Storm King Announces Fiftieth Anniversary Celebration

Mutiny Diary of Indian National Congress Founder for Sale at Bonhams

Zimbabwe Police Shut 2nd Art Exhibit on Violence

Fashion Photographer Peter Gowland Dies at 93

March 29, 2010

Japanese Architects Kazuyo Sejima and Ryue Nishizawa Win 2010 Pritzker Architecture Prize

Andy Warhol Photo Exhibition Explores His Public and Private Lives

Imagining Home: Selections from the Heinz Architectural Center

Christie's to Offer an Important Private Collection of Rhinoceros Horn Carvings

The Ambivalence of the Concrete by Gerhard Rühm at MUMOK

Works of Art from the Estate of Nancy M. Daly Highlight Auction

Thomas Heatherwick's Spun Chair at Haunch of Venison in London

The Beautiful Time in Lubumbashi: Photography by Sammy Baloji

Canon and Getty Images Gallery Celebrate 100 Years of Hollywood

Centre national de l'audiovisuel Explores the Subject of Tourism

Tamy Ben-Tor & Miki Carmi's Disembodied Archetypes at Zach Feuer Gallery

Three Key Projects by Susan Meiselas to be Featured at the Hood Museum

L.A. Art Collector Caps Two Year Pursuit of Artist with Exhibition of New Work

An Exhibition in Beijing at Hadrien de Montferrand Gallery for the Winner of the Prize FID 2010

Artbygeneve the New Platform for Contemporary and Modern Art

New Series of Paintings by Melanie Daniel at the Tel Aviv Museum of Art

Jakob Kolding's Stakes is High Opens at Stedelijk Museum Bureau Amsterdam

45-Carat Art Nouveau Dazzler the Centerpiece of Austin Auction's Sale

Firmament Watched at Huasteca Archaeological Site

Mary Colman St. John Appointed CFO at Aperture Foundation

March 28, 2010

Picasso's Themes and Variations Offers Unique View into Artist's Creative Process

Suite of 127 Silkscreen Plates by Josef Albers on View at Peter Blum

Wager Begun on Twitter Results in NOMA Winning a Masterpiece from Indianapolis

Asia Week Sales Total $22.6 Million at Sotheby's New York

Spanish Ministry of Culture Organizes Meeting of Photography Collectives

The Royal Collection of Graphic Art Photographs on View in Copenhagen

Art in Hamburg in the 1920s Opens at Hamburger Kunsthalle

Mural Paintings at Castillo de Chapultepec Now on the Web

"Alice Neel: Painted Truths Debuts" at the Museum of Fine Arts, Houston

Exhibitions by Maria Friberg and Dean Kessmann at Conner Contemporary

Sackler Gallery Presents Contemporary Chinese Artist Hai Bo

Staatliche Kunsthalle Baden-Baden Opens Exhibition of Works by Stefan Müller

Artium Presents the Exhibition "Desde Ayacata", by Juan Hidalgo

Peabody Essex Museum Opens Maya Exhibition

Joan Jonas's Reading Dante III at Yvon Lambert New York

New Series of Paintings by Ilya and Emilia Kabakov at Sprovieri Gallery

"Linus Bill: The Greatest Hits Vol. 1" on View at Foam in Amsterdam

London Original Print Fair Announces Highlights and Exhibitor List

Cool(e)motion Spotlights Climate Change in a Unique Way

Large Model of H.M.S. Leviathan to be Sold in Aid of Rotherham Sea Cadet Corps in Maritime Sale

March 27, 2010

Singer/Songwriter Sam Leach Wins Both the Archibald and the Wynne Prizes

Never Before Seen Work by Photographer Catherine Opie at Gladstone Gallery

Turner's Masterpiece Modern Rome - Campo Vaccino to Be Offered For Sale

Aztec and Roman Empires Confronted at the Getty Villa

New Works by Sarah Morris on View at Gallery Meyer Kainer

Technicolor Donates Archive to George Eastman House

Playboy Celebrates 50th Anniversary of Iconic Bunny with Exhibition

Artexpo New York Showcases Exciting, Emerging and Established Artists

New York's Fenimore Museum Unveils Sargent's Women

Kimbell Art Museum Mourns the Death of Foermer Director Edmund Pillsbury

Denmark's Famed Little Mermaid Begins Trip to the World Expo

Marty Lederhandler, Associated Press Photographer for 66 Years, Dies

American Academy of Arts and Letters Announces 2010 Award Winners

JFK Library to Show Salinger Letter to Hemingway

New Films from Germany at MoMA's Survey of German Cinema

Rihanna Picture Featured in Exhibition by Young Talent at the Walker Art Gallery

Expanded Pixar Exhibition to Open at Transformed Oakland Museum of California

Glenn W. Ekey Named Director of Development for Miami Art Museum

Cab Drivers Know their Monet from their Mascherano

Pop-Up Museum Offers Flash of English Eccentricity

March 26, 2010

Prado Museum Rediscovers Paintings from Its Collection with Opening of New Galleries

United Kingdom Arts Institutions to Government: Don't Ax Funds

Nolan's Ned Kelly Masterpiece Breaks Australia's Auction Record

Commission Unveils Design Concept for National Eisenhower Memorial

Sotheby's to Sell Newly Discovered Ottoman Ivory and Turquoise-Inlaid Box

South African Art Sale Exceeds Expectations at Bonhams

Discursive Painting from Albers to Zobernig at MUMOK

Guggenheim Exhibition Explores Memory, Trauma and Return to the Past

High Museum Explores Salvador Dalí's Late Work in August 2010

Ian Johnson's 'TimeScale' on View at Gooden Gallery in London

VMFA Appoints Geza von Habsburg as Guest Curator of Faberge Collection

Major Retrospective Exhibition of the Work of Rupert Bunny Opens in Melbourne

Discover America's Roots In First-Ever Charles Deas Retrospective

Modigliani Drawing Brings $84,000 at Swann Galleries' Auction

Ballet Dancer Dame Margot Fonteyn's Dress for Sale at Bonhams

National Gallery of Canada Realigns Its Organization

MoMA's 2010 Party in the Garden to Honor Ronald and Jo Carole Lauder

Chinesca Culture Offering Found in Tepic

Stolen Henry Moore Sculpture Found in Toronto

London Art Event Seeks to Help Asian Elephants

March 25, 2010

Painting by Paul Klee Stolen from NYC in 1989 is Found by Montreal Gallery Owner

Christie's to Offer Valuable Collection of Illuminated Manuscripts

Henry Moore's Butterfly Moved to a Factory for Restoration

Qatar Museums Authority Unveils Jean Nouvel Design for New Museum

Major Works by Maxfield Parrish to Highlight Christie's Sale

First Major Exhibition in the U.S. for Tatiana Trouvé at Gagosian

Christian Boltanski to Create Monumental Installation at Park Avenue Armory

Thomas P. Campbell Welcomed to AFA Board of Trustees

Dallas Museum Announces Results of Groundbreaking Visitor Study

New Exhibition Gives an Insight into the Collection Frieder Burda

Monumental Commission for MoMA on View at the 53rd Street Entrance

Spectacular Sale of Photographs from Various Owners at Christie's

Max Mara Art Prize for Women 2010 Winner Announced

Weston's Nautilus Shell Leads Sotheby's Spring Photographs Auction

London Science Museum Goes Climate Science Neutral

City Organizations Partner with AGO and No.9 to Bring Contemporary Art to Inner-City Students

Barbara Thumm Gallery Announces Representation of Anna Oppermann's Estate

Raskols and Sing-Sing by Stephen Dupont at Jack Bell Gallery

New York Dealer Offers "Schindler's List" for Sale

Rock Photographer Jim Marshall Dies at 74

Most Popular Last Seven Days



1.- Most expensive photograph by David Wojnarowicz sold at Bonhams New York

2.- The Vatican's Sistine Chapel dazzles thanks to a revolutionary new lighting system

3.- Alberto Giacometti's 1950 bronze sculpture 'Chariot' sells for $101m at Sotheby's New York

4.- Christie's to offer 21 seminal works from Cindy Sherman's Untitled Film Stills series

5.- Alberto Giacometti sculpture set to fetch $100 million at Sotheby's New York auction

6.- Archaeologist Daniele Manacorda's proposal to restore Colosseum's area sparks Italy debate

7.- Exhibitions at the Metropolitan Museum of Art and National Gallery of Art honor El Greco

8.- Solo exhibition of the work of Spanish painter Antonio Cazorla opens at Bernarducci Meisel Gallery

9.- Paris' Museum of Modern Art opens exhibition of the work of Sonia Delaunay

10.- 'Rembrandt and the Dutch Golden Age' opens at the Museum of Fine Arts in Budapest

Related Stories



Renaissance Seattle Hotel and Seattle Art Museum Celebrate Legacy of Pablo Picasso

Senegal's "Renaissance Woman" Faces Cover-Up

Musée National de la Renaissance Opens Exhibition Exploring Body Care and Cosmetics



Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 

Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez - Marketing: Carla Gutiérrez
Special Contributor: Liz Gangemi - Special Advisor: Carlos Amador
Contributing Editor: Carolina Farias

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org theavemaria.org juncodelavega.org facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site