The First Art Newspaper on the Net Established in 1996 United States Wednesday, July 30, 2014


Lines of Art Blur Between Rembrandt and his Pupils at Exhibition
Lee Hendrix, senior curator of drawings at the J. Paul Getty Museum, poses in front of a mural showing the interior view of Rembrandt's studio at the Getty Center in Los Angeles. An exhibition based on 30 years of research and called "Drawings by Rembrandt and His Pupils: Telling the Difference" will be on display at the Getty from Dec. 8 to Feb. 28. AP Photo/Jae C. Hong.

By: Sue Manning, Associated Press Writer

LOS ANGELES, CA (AP).- Before he died 340 years ago, Rembrandt van Rijn lost his house, studio and most of his money. He even sold his wife's grave to pay bills.

Since then, he's also been stripped of credit given to him for hundreds of drawings and paintings.

Experts say many works, once believed to be Rembrandt's, were done by students who would sit at his side, use the same model and come up with similar drawings or paintings.

At one time, Rembrandt was credited with 611 paintings. In the 1930s, scholars said only about half were his. Now comes a study of about a thousand ink drawings once thought to be the Dutch master's. Between a third and a half of them were done by his students, said Lee Hendrix, senior curator of the J. Paul Getty Museum's Department of Drawings.

An exhibition based on 30 years of research and called "Drawings by Rembrandt and His Pupils: Telling the Difference" will be on display at the Getty from Dec. 8 to Feb. 28. There will be more than 40 pairings, showing Rembrandt's drawings next to those by pupils such as Govert Flinck, Ferdinand Bol, Gerbrand van den Eeckhout, Carel Fabritius and Nicolaes Maes.

The display will take place in several rooms and will feature original student-teacher drawings paired side by side. Labels will point out the differences in technique, texture, light and angle, while enlarged photos will focus on the differences.

Few of the drawings are owned by the same museum. So about four years ago, Hendrix and Peter Schatborn, emeritus head of the Rijksprentenkabinet of the Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, started asking for loans around the world.

They asked 33 museums for about 100 drawings — and every one said yes, Hendrix said, calling it unprecedented.

Six drawings from the Getty collection will be part of the show.

"Some exhibitions, you close up the catalog and put in on the shelf. This is taking the work of many scholars over 30 years, putting it all together in one accessible place, clearly presenting it and changing the perspective on a vast body of art," Hendrix said.

Authenticating a drawing isn't as easy as turning it over to forensic investigators. There's no DNA, no fingerprint work, cotton swab tests or test tube chemical that will produce the truth.

"For paintings, there are many scientific instruments that help. For drawings, there aren't," Hendrix said. Ink is just fireplace soot, an organic substance.

So the scholars had to use visual characteristics to identify a core group they knew belonged to Rembrandt or Flinck or van den Eeckhout and work from there. Tedious stuff and the job is far from finished, Hendrix said.

They started with a six-volume catalog of over 1,000 drawings attributed to Rembrandt and put together by Otto Benesch in the mid-1950s.

If a drawing is determined to be that of one of Rembrandt's students, it can take a financial toll on the collector — private or public.

"It has affected the market," Hendrix said. "It's always a problematic thing to say to a private collector your work is not a Rembrandt. Before you go to auction or go to a private dealer to buy a Rembrandt drawing, you should talk to a lot of people and be really careful. Not every one of them (drawings) has been published."

The Getty exhibit includes lectures, a symposium, classes, discussions, demonstrations, a workshop, a documentary, a concert, audio clips, four books and coordinating exhibits of Rembrandt paintings at five other Southern California museums.

Rembrandt, who lived from 1606 to 1669, was a genius who realized great wealth from his work, Hendrix said, but he lost it all because he spent too much and saved too little. He taught nearly 50 students in his studio during 40 years, but was evicted in 1658. The building would eventually be turned into a shrine to him.

Rembrandt is Hendrix's "favorite artist ever." She speaks the language, has spent time in his studio and was one of the scholars involved in the weeding out the study.

"With Rembrandt, you never come to the end of it. There is always some aspect that is mysterious. Just his perception of light — he was so sensitive in recording it. He sees humanity. For example, he was in his 20s when he started drawing old people. Can you imagine a macho, young male artist today spending his time drawing old people?" Hendrix asked.

One of the four books prepared for the exhibit, a 300-page catalog also called "Drawings by Rembrandt and His Pupils: Telling the Difference," pairs the drawings as they will be displayed in the show. Every drawing in the book — except one — is original size.

No one knows exactly how many drawings by Rembrandt or his pupils survived the last four centuries because they are so small and portable (easily stuck between the pages of a book), artists seldom signed them, they were seldom sold, they weren't made into paintings and many were auctioned off in lots after Rembrandt was evicted.

"Very few of them had value as works of art," Hendrix noted. "They were tools in the creative process. Rembrandt kept lots and lots of drawings, both his own and his pupils. He kept them in albums." When his bankruptcy took place, the albums were sold and the drawings were mixed and muddled.

Hendrix figures some have yet to surface. And because of the large number of drawings that do exist, she figures the attrition rate was probably very high.

Today, a Rembrandt drawing costs millions. The works of his students don't carry such price tags, but they are valuable, Hendrix said. The most successful pupil was Eeckhout.

The Getty is the only place the exhibit will be shown.



Copyright 2009 The Associated Press.


J. Paul Getty Museum | Rembrandt van Rijn | Lee Hendrix |


Last Week News

December 3, 2009

Royal Academy Presents New Work from More than 30 Leading Contemporary Artists

Many Premier Art Institutions in Paris Closed Due to Strike

Christie's Hong Kong Autumn 2009 Auction Series Totals US $212.5 Million

"ARTIST ROOMS 2010 Tour" Announced - 21 Exhibitions from Llandudno to Fort William

CityCenter in Las Vegas Features Unparalleled Fine Art Collection

Museo del Prado Focuses New Temporary Exhibition on Dutch Painting

ARCOmadrid_ 2010 to Showcase the Quality and Diversity in Contemporary Art

Andrew Wyeth Leads $32.3 Million Sale of American Art at Christie's

Rare Exhibition in Indianapolis Brings Together Spanish Sacred Art

Looted Artifacts Being Returned to Italy from New York City

First U.S. Survey of Contemporary Films from Lithuania to be Screened at MoMA

Spectacular Collection of Dresses on View at the National Gallery of Victoria

Peter Forakis, Originator of Geometry-Based Sculpture, Dies at 82

William Ansley Contemporary Art Glass Collection to be Auctioned

Nelson-Atkins Mourns Loss of Board Chair Harry C. McCray, Jr.

Museum in San Diego Announces New Qualcomm Grant to Continue Free Admission

High to Premiere New Exhibition of Works by American Photographer Peter Sekaer

Utah Museum of Fine Arts Appoints New Director of Development and External Relations

Sale of George Washington Letter Could Set Record

Bonhams Latest Canadian Art Sale Tops $1M

December 2, 2009

New Medieval and Renaissance Galleries Open at the Victoria & Albert Museum

Art Basel Miami Beach Galleries and Organizers Expect Collectors

A Child's Portrait, Looted During the War, is Returned to Its Owner

Andrew W. Mellon Foundation Awards the Frick Collection a $1 Million Grant

Two Newly-Discovered Still Lifes by Adriaen Coorte Soar Above Estimate

Sotheby's Week of Russian Art Sales Totals $31.9 Million

Large-Scale Sculpture by David Altmejd Acquired by Dallas Museum of Art

"Synecdoche", Watershed Work by Byron Kim, Installed at the National Gallery of Art

Huntington Names Its First Curator of American Decorative Arts

Art Madrid Announces 5th Edition to Open in February 2010

Museu d'Art de Catalunya Celebrates 75th Anniversary with Exhibition

Hauser & Wirth to Present Works by Jakub Julian Ziolkowski at Art Basel Miami

Ukrainian Museum Claims It Owns a Portrait of a Venetian Doge by Titian

Pirate Exhibit in Norfolk Taps into Pirate Craze

"Wisdom of the Mountain: Art of the Omie" at the National Gallery of Victoria

Norman Rockwell Headlines December American Paintings, Drawings, and Sculpture Sale

Conner Contemporary Art Announces Leo Villareal Commissioned by Tampa Museum

Brilliant Prices Achieved at Sotheby's Contemporary Art Sale in Milan

New York Academy of Art Names Peter Drake Dean of Academic Affairs

China Appeals to Rival Taiwan with Ancient Treasures

December 1, 2009

Max Ernst Museum Presents 150 Works of Art by US Filmmaker David Lynch

Sotheby's London Sale Of Rediscovered Fabergé Totals $11.6 Million

Royal Society Launches New Interactive Timeline "Trailblazing"

Baltic Center for Contemporary Art Announces Partnership with Sky Arts

Miami Art Museum Names John Wetenhall Interim Director

Sotheby's Sale to Feature Rare Group Of Medieval Gargoyles

Display Celebrates Anniversary of Jane Bown's Relationship with 'The Observer'

Museum of Anthropology in Vancouver Introduces New Brand

Anish Kapoor to Make Rare Appearance to Sign Copies of New Monograph

Andrew Wyeth Painting on View for Limited Time at the Dayton Art Institute

Ellen Harvey's Solo Project "The Room of Sublime Wallpaper" to be Shown at NADA

Life According to Wilhelm Sasnal at the CAC Málaga in Spain

Paris Evolution Sale: from Dinosaurs to Space Diapers

Freeman's Announces Books, Manuscript, Maps, Prints & Posters Auction

Clothes Show Live Announces Shortlisted Entries

From Russia with Love: Bonhams Attracts 1.9 Million for Russian Art Sale

Attendance Boom at the New Ars Electronica Center

Classical Paintings Shine at Christie's in Hong Kong

Duke of Northumberland Buys Back Ancestral Plate in 1 Million Meissen Sale

Bonhams to Make Its Impression on the Recovering Art Market

November 30, 2009

Russian Art Week Sales Expected to Reach $81 Million for Auction Houses in London

Rhode Island Museums Consider Relocating Sarcophagus

Tomoo Gokita, the Clayton Brothers and Erik Parker Join STAGES for Miami Show

Van Ham to Auction Numerous Works by Established Photographers

First Major Survey of the Work of American Artist Zoe Leonard at MUMOK

Walk-In Sculpture, Tekrar Level Four, by David M. Abir, at PULSE Miami

Bozar Presents an Extensive Multidisciplinary Mexico Festival

"A" is for Aivazovsky as Bonhams Russian Sale Boasts a Cyrillic Who's Who

Solo Exhibition for Navid Nuur at Kunsthalle Fridericianum

Elms Lesters Painting Rooms to Show New Prints by Jose Parla

Group Exhibition at Siemens Sanat Shows Melancholy of Compassion

Free Bob Dylan Photograph to be Offered with "A Complete Unknown" Book

Durban Segnini Gallery Presents Works by Venezuelan Artist Milton Becerra

Biennial of Young European Creation Completes First Stage at Montrouge

Chazen Museum of Art Announces Contemporary Mechanical Sculpture Exhibition

National Museum of Cultures in Mexico Receives Donation from Cyprus

Red Dot Art Fair to Run Concurrent to Art Basel Miami Beach

Next Art4Barter to Open December 4 at Ven and Vaida Gallery

New Date for CIRCA Puerto Rico '10 & Cooperation with Art Beijing'

Some One Hundred French and International Galleries Invited to ArtParis + Guests

November 29, 2009

Kunsthalle Dusseldorf Eats the Universe with Exhibition of Art Made with and Involving Food

One of the Greatest of All Illuminated Manuscripts to be Exhibited at the Morgan

Museum Rethinks its Collection and Presents the Museum of the 21st-Century

Major Picasso Exhibition Featuring Unique Paintings at Heather James Fine Art

Iconic Ansel Adams Print Going Up for Auction at Swann Auction Galleries

Canadian Photographer Edward Burtynsky Presents "Oil" at Huis Marseille

Ei Arakawa Invites Artists for Exhibition at Kunsthalle Zurich

Bonhams New York Presents First Coins and Banknotes Sale

Michael Lee-Chin Crystal Cited as Architectural Marvel

Catch Only West Coast Presentation of Luc Tuymans at SFMOMA

Dual Exhibitions by Acclaimed Polish Artists to Open at Modern Art Oxford

Koudelka's Legendary Photographs of the Prague Invasion to be Shown in Miami

Raffles College of Design Fashion Grads Compete for Akira Internship

Hannah Maybank Opens Third Solo Exhibition at Gimpel Fils

December UBS 12 x 12 at Chicago's MCA Presents Carrie Schneider

London-Based Pakistani Artist Brings Unique Artworks to Dubai

Yuriko Lochan Creates a New "Self" Portrait in Her Solo Exhibition at Alliance Francaise

Kessling Vs. Kessling 2009 at the Modern Artists Gallery

Exhibition at Cantor Arts Center will Celebrates Donors' Vision and Generosity

Chichen Itza Gets Greener

November 28, 2009

Tokyo Opera City Art Gallery Shows Exhibition by Influential Designer Verner Panton

Sotheby's to Sell, "Elephant" (Purple), a Unique Work by Jeff Koons

Pinacotheque de Paris to Show Edvard Munch or the "Anti-Scream"

Posters Everywhere: Product Advertising through the Medium of the Poster

Bologna's International Art Fair, Arte Fiera Art First, Announced

Sale of Masterworks from Band Estate Carries Heffel Auction to $20.8-Million Sale

Lenin Statue Vandalized by Ukrainian Nationalists in Kiev

Serpentine to Celebrate 40th Anniversary with Richard Hamilton Exhibition

Frans Hals Museum to Show Exhibition of the First Woman to Become Masterpainter

800 Unpublished Drawings from the Venetian 19th-Century to Go on View

Stadel Museum Examines Works by Frankfurt Artist Who Died at Age 23

Sotheby's Swiss Art Sale Highlights Works by Giacometti, Hodler and Vallotton

ArtSway Announces Exhibition of New Work by Dave Lewis

First Full-Scope Solo Exhibition of William E. Jones in Europe Announced

Green Art Gallery in Dubai to Open Nazif Topcuoglu Exhibition

Fotomuseum Winterthur Opens Exhibition of Photographs by Graciela Iturbide

Group Show of Color Photographs Opens at Michael Hoppen Gallery

Exhibition to Inaugurate New de la Cruz Collection Contemporary Art Space

Michael Landy: The New National Gallery Associate Artist

Prague Museum Depicts Country's Communist Past

Most Popular Last Seven Days



1.- Archaeologists discover Roman 'free choice' cemetery in the 2,700-year-old ancient port of Rome

2.- Romanians must pay 18 million euros over Kunsthal Museum Rotterdam art heist

3.- Hello Kitty designer Yuko Yamaguchi defends cute character as cat turns 40 years old

4.- eBay and Sotheby's partner to bring world class art and collectibles to a global community

5.- Exhibition on Screen returns with new series of films bringing great art to big screens across the globe

6.- Marina Abramović reaches half way point of her '512 Hours' performance at the Serpentine Gallery

7.- The Phillips Collection in Washington introduces a uCurate app for curating on-the-go

8.- United States comic icon Archie Andrews dies saving openly gay character

9.- New feathered predatory fossil, unearthed in China, sheds light on dinosaur flight

10.- Exhibition at Thyssen Bornemisza Museum presents an analysis of the concept of the 'unfinished'

Related Stories



The J. Paul Getty Museum announces acquisition of Northern Renaissance masterpiece

Getty Museum and Getty Research Institute acquire Ed Ruscha photographs and archive

From Start to Finish: De Wain Valentine's Gray Column at the J. Paul Getty Museum

Getty Museum Displays Stories to Watch: Narrative in Medieval Manuscripts

Getty Museum Displays a Selection of Chinese Photographs Produced Since the 1990s

Getty Museum Displays First Survey of Felice Beato's Long and Varied Photography Career

J. Paul Getty Museum's Statue of Love Goddess Aphrodite Transfer Ends Italy Dispute

Getty Announces Exhibition that Recreates a Day in the Life of an 18th Century Parisian Townhouse

Getty Museum Head of Preparation Bruce Metro Retires Following 30-plus Year Career

Getty Museum Reopens Suite of Sculpture & Decorative Arts Galleries



Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 

Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Rmz. - Marketing: Carla Gutiérrez
Special Contributor: Liz Gangemi - Special Advisor: Carlos Amador
Contributing Editor: Carolina Farias

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org theavemaria.org juncodelavega.org facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site