The First Art Newspaper on the Net Established in 1996 United States Friday, August 29, 2014


Massachusetts Judge Rules In Favor of Museum of Fine Arts, Boston Regarding Kokoschka Work
Two Nudes (Lovers), Oskar Kokoschka (Austrian, 1886–1980), 1913, Oil on canvas, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. Bequest of Sarah Reed Platt. Photograph © Museum of Fine Arts, Boston.
BOSTON, MA.-United States District Judge Rya Zobel (District of Massachusetts) ruled that the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston is entitled to retain ownership of Oskar Kokoschka’s painting Two Nudes (Lovers) (painted about 1913). The ruling came in a lawsuit filed by the MFA on January 22, 2008, in response to a request for restitution of the painting made by Dr. Claudia Seger-Thomschitz. In its January 2008 filing, the MFA asserted its rightful ownership of the painting, bequeathed to the Museum by Sarah Reed Blodgett in 1973. Dr. Seger-Thomschitz of Austria claims to be the heir of a son of Dr. Oskar Reichel. Dr. Reichel, a Jewish doctor and art collector in Vienna, purchased the painting from the artist in 1914 or 1915 and sold the work in 1939 to another Jew, Otto Kallir, a Viennese art dealer (who was then living in Paris). Based on exhaustive provenance research, the Museum concluded that the 1939 transaction was valid.

In her May 28, 2009 Memorandum of Decision and Order in Museum of Fine Arts, Boston v. Seger-Thomschitz, No. 08-10097-RWZ (D. Mass.), Judge Zobel ruled in favor of the Museum, holding that no claim to the painting could be made by Dr. Seger-Thomschitz. The Judge held that because Oskar Reichel’s family could have sought restitution of the painting decades ago (had they believed there was any reason to challenge the 1939 transaction), the applicable statute of limitations barred any claim now. Judge Zobel also held that Dr. Seger-Thomschitz herself waited too long to bring a claim after learning she might have rights to property previously owned by Oskar Reichel. Judge Zobel stated in her ruling that:

[A]lthough the Reichel family never claimed compensation for any of the Kokoschka works that had been transferred to Kallir for sale, it did claim restitution for artwork and property that had been stolen by the Nazis.

[T]he Reichel family never attempted to recover the painting after WWII, and there is no evidence that it believed the transfer was not legitimate.

The evidence is undisputed that the members of the Reichel family had sufficient knowledge of Reichel’s ownership and transfer of the painting.

Dr. Seger-Thomschitz also ―waited more than three years to assert her claim after she was on inquiry notice of her possible right to the Painting…The information necessary to pursue her claim was readily available to both [Dr. Seger-Thomschitz] and her counsel at that time.

[T]he delay in bringing suit will prejudice the MFA because all of the witnesses with actual knowledge of the transfer are deceased.

Any claim by Dr. Seger-Thomschitz that Oskar Reichel was misled when he transferred the painting to Otto Kallir in 1939 was ―pure speculation.

“We are pleased with the court’s ruling acknowledging the MFA’s clear title to the painting,” said Malcolm Rogers, Ann and Graham Gund Director of the MFA. “The MFA conducted a year and a half long comprehensive investigation of the work’s provenance, seeking documentation of the various transactions and changes of ownership in the painting’s almost 100-year history. We are satisfied and grateful that the judge has reaffirmed the Museum’s rightful ownership of the work.”

Background: Two Nudes (Lovers) is a self portrait of Austrian artist Oskar Kokoschka (1886–1980) and his lover, Alma Mahler (the widow of the great composer Gustav Mahler). The artist painted the work in Vienna, Austria, about 1913, then sold it around 1914–15 to Oskar Reichel, who lent the painting to numerous exhibitions. In the 1920s and 1930s, Reichel consigned Two Nudes (Lovers) for sale to Otto Kallir-Nirenstein (later known as Otto Kallir), on several occasions. Kallir was, at that time, the owner of the Neue Galerie in Vienna. In 1938, Kallir emigrated to Paris, where he opened the Galerie St. Etienne. In February 1939, Reichel transferred the painting—along with four other Kokoschka works—to Kallir, who later brought the paintings to the United States and sent money for them to Reichel’s two sons, Raimund and Hans, who were living in South America and the United States. According to the MFA’s extensive provenance research, there was no evidence that Two Nudes (Lovers) was confiscated or looted by the Nazis.

In New York, Kallir opened a branch of his Paris gallery. He sold Two Nudes (Lovers) to another gallery in New York, after which the painting was bought by a third gallery there. The painting was then sold to Sarah Reed Blodgett (known later as Sarah Reed Platt) in late 1947 or early 1948. The MFA was given the painting in 1973 as a bequest from Blodgett’s estate. Since then, the work has been included in multiple publications and been on display almost continuously at the MFA (where it is currently on view in the Rabb Gallery).

Reichel died of natural causes in Vienna in 1943 at the age of 74. In June 1957, a Viennese lawyer representing Reichel’s son, Raimund Reichel, submitted an application to the Austrian authorities of the Fund for Assistance to Political Persecutees, on behalf of himself and his brother Hans. The application included a notarized statement by Raimund asserting that ―a large art collection [owned by my father] was sold by force: 47 pictures by the painter Anton Romako.‖ Raimund never asserted a claim concerning any painting by Kokoschka, including Two Nudes (Lovers), or otherwise sought to invalidate the transfer of the painting to Kallir. Raimund died in Vienna in 1997. In March 2007, more than 68 years after the sale of the painting by Reichel, Dr. Seger-Thomschitz, of Vienna, identified by her counsel as a non-relative ―select niece‖ of Raimund Reichel, made a claim of restitution against the Museum.

Provenance Research: Following this March 2007 claim, the MFA thoroughly reviewed the claim to Two Nudes (Lovers) in accordance with its own Acquisitions Policy as well as the guidelines set forth by the American Association of Museums (AAM), the Association of Art Museum Directors (AAMD), and the Washington Principles of 1998 on Nazi-Confiscated Art. The Museum is committed to determining, on an ongoing basis, whether any work of art in its collection has ever been stolen, confiscated, looted, or otherwise unlawfully appropriated as a result of Nazi persecution without subsequent restitution. A leader in provenance research, the MFA makes ownership information available to the public through its website, mfa.org. During the past decade, the Museum has restituted a number of works of art to their rightful owners based on provenance research.



Last Week News

May 29, 2009

Christie's New York Latin American Art Evening Sale Realizes $11 Million Tonight

From Raphael to Carracci: The Art of Papal Rome Opens at the National Gallery of Canada

Van Gogh Museum Acquires Painting by Pierre Bonnard

Sotheby's Spring 2009 Latin American Art Sale Totals $9,422,625

Quadricentennial Celebration of the Hudson River Valley at Frances Lehman Loeb Art Center

PHotoEspaña 2009: Exhibit Hall Channel of Isabel II Presents Sergey Bratkov (Glory Days)

ICE Recovers Egyptian Artifacts Stolen From a Museum in the Netherlands

Fuller Craft Museum Names Wyona Lynch-McWhite Exective Director

Colorado River Photographs By Karen Halverson Explored in New Exhibition Space

Focus on Color: The Photography of Jeannette Klute at The Bruce Museum

Dallas Museum of Art Appoints Jeffrey Grove as New Curator of Contemporary Art

Panel Discussion with Museum Reach Artists Commissioned by San Antonio River Foundation

Haughtons' Legendary 'International Fair' Celebrates 21 Spectacular Years in New York

Le Ciel Regarde la Terre - Artist: Philippe Pastor

San Francisco Art Institute Presents Sanctuary City/Ciudad Santuario

Smart Light Sydney On View At Customs House

Glass Stress - Collateral Event of the 53rd International Art Exhibition - La Biennale di Venezia

Kunsthaus Baselland Presents Javier Téllez, Michael Bauer and Hagar Schmidhalter

Contemporary Craft Market Flourishes at Collect 2009

May 28, 2009

Madonna and Guy Ritchie Nude Painting Made by Peter Howson Up for Auction at McTear's

Manchester Museum Announces Ansuman Biswas as the Manchester Hermit

Sotheby's Evening Sale of Latin American Art Totals $6.7 Million

Berlinische Galerie Opens Two Exhibitions, One by Klaus Staeck, the other by John Heartfield

Derrick R. Cartwright Named Next Director of the Seattle Art Museum

Edinburgh Art Festival Unveils 2009 Exhibitions Programme

IVAM Opens Confines/Valencia 09: Passages of Contemporary Arts

PHotoEspaña 2009: Mabel Palacín Dilutes the Border Between Reality and Fiction

Sotheby's to Sell the Philippe Guimiot & Domitilla de Grunne Tribal Art Collection

Kunstmuseum Bonn Opens Raimund Kummer: For Your Eyes Only

British Museum Celebrates India with Exhibition and Season Dedicated to Indian Culture

Frye Art Museum Announces Second Round of Fiscal Year 2009 Budget Cuts

Call for Submissions for Singapore Art Show 2009

Imperial War Museum to Open Exhibition Which will Explore the Build-up to and Preparations for War

Richard Schmid Makes Premier Appearance in NYC at Salmagundi Club

American Institute of Conservation Honors the Getty Conservation Institute with its Highest Organizational Award

Artist Easton Selby to Open Root Work in Cheekwood's Temporary Contemporary Gallery

Bust of Argentine Independence Hero Unveiled in Vienna

Archaeologists Excavate Ancient Maya River Port in Southeast Mexico

May 27, 2009

Reina Sofia Museum Rearranges its Collection and Shows it in a Different Way

The Hergé Museum: Cartoon Character Tintin Gets a Museum

Centre Pompidou Dedicates Exhibition to Women: elles@centrepompidou

Talking Art Louvre Abu Dhabi Features the Museum's First Acquisitions

Rodolphe Tessier to Auction a 700-lot Ensemble of Objects Owned by Mime Marcel Marceau

Musée National de la Renaissance Opens Exhibition Exploring Body Care and Cosmetics

Important 20th Century Design at Sotheby's June 12, 2009 in New York

PHotoEspaña 2009: Museu Berardo Opens Exhibition by Photographer Cristóbal Hara

The Founders and The Cutting Edge of South Asian Modern + Contemporary Art at Christie's in June

Abu Dhabi Celebrates the Beginning of Construction for the Louvre Abu Dhabi

Braco Dimitrijevic's Future Post History to be Shown at Ca' Pesaro and Ca' Farsetti as Part of Venice Biennale

Beloved Daughters: Photographs by Fazal Sheikh Opens June 27 at The Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art

Recent Major Acquisitions of British Contemporary Art will go on Display in the BP Exhibition Classified at Tate Britain

Lakefront Festival of Arts Is Back, Better Than Ever

Elizabeth Osborne: The Color of Light Opens in June at the Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts

Mexican Artist Marco Antonio Cruz Wins $50,000 Grange Prize

Royal Institute of British Architects Unveils Manifesto for European Parliament Elections

Park Life: Event Exploring Liverpool's Parks for the People

The American Institute of Architects Select Recipients of the Fourth Annual Jason Pettigrew Memorial ARE Scholarship

Mexico's First Swine-flu Patient Immortalized in Bronze

May 26, 2009

Prado Opens Most Important Retrospective Ever Devoted to the Work of Joaquín Sorolla

Maya Pyramids at Uxmal Glow in the Mexican Night with New Light and Sound System

IMMA Director Curates Spanish Pavilion by Miquel Barceló for the 53rd Venice Biennale

A Bone Seal Engraved with the Name Shaul, from the Time of the First Temple, was Found in Jerusalem

First Individual Exhibition in Spain on the Work of Artist Paul Sietsema

Athens Print Fest to Open with Several Exhibitions Around the City

New Galleries for the Gilbert Collection to Open at the V&A

IVAM Celebrates the Centenary of the Birth of Rafael Pérez-Contel with Exhibition

Seventeen Artists from Around the World to Show their Works at Arsenale Novissimo

Frieze Art Fair 2009 will Present Outstanding Work by More 1,000 Artists

Bellevue Arts Museum to Present a Fresh Perspective on Contemporary Portraiture

'Spirit Red' Captures Adventure of Collecting Native Art

Fourteen Places to Eat: a Narrative: Photographing Rural Culture in the Midwest to Open at the Snite Museum

Artists Creating a Sculpture and Related Jewelry for Display at 40 Venues County Wide

Museum of London Appeals to Public to Help Find Historic Agreement

Paul Strand Exhibition Featuring Vintage Work and Ephemera Opens at Aperture Gallery

Retrospective of Works by Sophie Calle to Open at Centre for Fine Arts in Brussels

Armenian Transnation: Krossing Colateral Event for the 53rd International Art Exhibition in Venice

Accident Prone Artist Admitted to 8 Different Hospital Accident & Emergency Wards

May 25, 2009

Granet Museum Opens Exhibition Focusing on Subtle Links Between Picasso and Cézanne

NRW-Forum Kultur und Wirtschaft Shows U.F.O.: Blurring the Boundaries Between Art and Design

This Summer Tate Liverpool Invites Families to Experiment with Colour in the Colour Lab

Cécile Whiting Is Awarded the 21st Annual Eldredge Prize for Her Book on Pop Art in Los Angeles

It's the Summer of Change at the Art Gallery of Ontario with Two New Exhibitions

Vladimir Dubossarsky and Alexander Vinogradov at Moscow Museum of Modern Art

80 Major Contemporary Works from Dallas Collections Juxtaposed in Intimate Groupings

Major Survey Exhibition of Works by Guy Ben-Ner Opens at MASS MoCA

Il Catalogo Gallery to Open Peter Ruta: Positano and Other Italian Paintings

Park West Gallery Launches Dali, Rembrandt, and Picasso Websites

Robert Adanto's The Rising Tide to Screen at The Queensland Gallery of Modern Art

An Ancient Jar Handle Bearing the Hebrew Name Menachem was Uncovered in Ras el-'Amud

Summer Exhibition at Cape Ann Museum - View from the Terrace: The Paintings of Charles Hopkinson

National Museum of American History's New Exhibition Goes "On the Water"

Flesh-eating Creepy Crawlies Seen Live on Royal Ontario Museum Web Cam

UFO Artwork Draws Thousands to Rio's Beaches

J. Paul Getty Museum Engages Students in Photography with Community Photoworks

Varied Volunteer Opportunities at the Museum of Fine Arts, Houston

Walker Art Center Presents Fake It, For Real: Media Workshop with Tectonic Industries

George Always: Portraits of George Melly by Maggi Hambling to Open at the National Portrait Gallery

May 24, 2009

435 Works of Art Comprise "Teotihuacan: City of Gods" Exhibition Opening This Week

MASS MoCA Opens Long Time Gone by Brooklyn-based Painter George Cochrane

MOCA Announces Balanced Budget for FY09 and Additional Restructuring to Achieve Balanced Budget

Columbia Museum of Art to Unveil Freshly Designed Galleries and Newly Published Catalogue

31st Annual Betty Bowen Award Call for Artist Entries

17th Annual High Museum Atlanta Wine Auction Nets $1.3 Million

California African American Museum Erases Distinction Between Fine Arts and Crafts

Museum to Present a Major Collection of American and European Modernism

Exhibition of Influential Irish Artist Willie Doherty To Debut at The Dallas Museum of Art

Do You Want to Go to the Museum? - Come in Right Now!

Public Sculpture, "Aspiration", by Artist Bob Dombrowski, Installed in Trenton, Georgia

12th Annual "Community Creations" Exhibition Features Work by Young People

John Jones Project Space Brings Together Works on Paper from Three Renowned London Based Art Collections

A Bold New Vision of Design to be Unveiled at the Edinburgh College of Art Degree Show

The Montreal Museum of Fine Arts Celebrates the 40th Anniversary of John and Yoko's Bed-in

Cantor Arts Center Announces Exhibition that Presents Art of Stanford Studio Faculty

UBS Art Gallery Celebrates 120th Anniversary of the National Association of Women Artists with Exhibition

Katonah Art Center to Hold 12th Annual Student Exhibit

Unsurpassed Creativity & Stunning Artistry Anticipated at Academy of Art University 2009 Annual Spring Show

Phillips de Pury & Company New York Design Sale to Offer Highly Select Works

Most Popular Last Seven Days



1.- Neanderthals and humans were both living in Europe for between 2,600 and 5,400 years

2.- First major exhibition to explore the historical legacy of African cultural astronomy opens at LACMA

3.- Carlo Mollino's idealized vision of the female form in new book published by Damiani/Crump

4.- Tate Britain displays works by Frank Auerbach from the collection of Lucian Freud

5.- In grave robber territory, locals abuzz over Alexander-era tomb; Largest of its kind ever discovered in Greece

6.- Lambert Collection opens an ambitious project housed at the Sainte-Anne Prison

7.- Centre for Contemporary Art Singapore announces the first 18 artists in the CCA Residencies progamme

8.- Historic Kings Theatre is transformed into major New York Performing Arts venue

9.- Thirteen's American Masters Series co-produces new documentary about photographer Dorothea Lange

10.- Sotheby's New York to offer 548 Edward Weston photographs as a single lot this September



Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 

Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez - Marketing: Carla Gutiérrez
Special Contributor: Liz Gangemi - Special Advisor: Carlos Amador
Contributing Editor: Carolina Farias

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org theavemaria.org juncodelavega.org facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site