NEW HAVEN, CT.-
Time Will Tell: Ethics and Choices in Conservation showcases the important relationship between curators and fine-art conservators as they consider techniques for and approaches to caring for museum objects in their collections. The exhibition, organized by the Yale University Art Gallery
, demonstrates that no aspect of conservation is simple or straightforward. Each of the objects chosen for this exhibition highlights a specific conservation choice and the decision-making process that goes into its treatment and display. The aim of the exhibition is to show the public some of the complex issues that conservators and curators consider when deciding the best course of treatment for an object, says Ian McClure, the Susan Morse Hilles Chief Conservator at the Gallery.
As a constantly evolving science, fine-arts conservation faces conflicts across time, since what appears to be well advised and ethically acceptable to one generation might prove misconceived to the next. Laurence Kanter, the Gallerys Lionel Goldfrank III Curator of Early European Art, adds, The relationship between conservators and curators is a dialogue, a two-way street. Elucidating this relationship is the purpose and aim of the show, demonstrating two important points: that works of art are not simply cleaned and put on view and that studying works of art without understanding their physical makeup is an inadequate approach to scholarship.
Time Will Tell: Ethics and Choices in Conservation arose in part from the idea of displaying the recently acquired ancient Roman Figure of a Woman, either during or after its intended conservation treatment, and grew to encompass many of the critical issues conservators and curators face. Affectionately known to Gallery staff as the Green Lady, due to the greenish algae that marred its surface, the marble statue introduces visitors to problems of evaluating authenticity and restoration. Because of the otherwise excellent condition of the statue and its exceptionally fine carving, the Green Lady will become a highlight of the Gallerys collection. However, in addition to having its surface cleaned, the statue has at least two generations of intrusive restoration to be reconciled. The most jarring of these is a reconstructed right arm that is inaccurately positioned and inconsistent in scale from the original. Conservators and curators together must decide how to reverse the damage that has been done (both by the elements and by previous restoration efforts), how to prevent further damage, and how to display the portrait in its best light, without misleading additions.
Other dilemmas confronting curators and conservators involve aesthetic choices that seem directly opposed to the intuitive practice of conservation. Whereas the conservators role is commonly viewed as returning an object to its original state, in some cultures restoration is prized for its visibility. A thirteenth-century Chinese container in the exhibition features multiple layers of repairs and additions, including an eighteenth-century lid and a dragon-shaped pewter handle added in the twentieth century. The additions, which transformed the objects use from a vessel that may have held water for rinsing brushes to an incense container, are emblematic of Japanese tea culture, a tradition in which an objects function may change over the centuries. The challenge for todays curators and conservators is to respect the integrity of the object.
Often objects will take on new life after they have been conserved. Time Will Tell features a painting, previously dismissed as a derivative provincial production, that may actually be an important early work created between 1305 and 1310 by the Italian painter Ugolino di Nerio, Duccio di Buoninsegnas most gifted and original follower. This identification was only made possible by recent conservation treatment. Technical examination by conservators and curators has also revealed that a Renaissance cassone chest, once thought to be a pastiche assembled in modern times from unrelated fragments, may in fact be an important object from the workshop of Paolo Uccello, the only one of its kind by the artist known to survive largely intact. Although restorations added to it early in its history, as well as more recent additions, compromise the integrity of the original object, it is difficult to know whether removing or revising them might result in other, more dramatic compromises.
As Lisa R. Brody, Associate Curator of Ancient Art, points out, Discussions among conservators and curators behind the scenes at the Gallery constantly inform our research and our exhibitions. We hope that this exhibition will bring some of those discussions and their significant results into the public eye. McClure adds, The objects we selected for the exhibition are drawn from a broad range of media, not only painting, which is the first thing the public thinks of in connection with conservation. We also wanted to point out unusual connectionsthe way we might treat an African mask has close similarities to a seventeenth-century Dutch painting, or an eighteenth-century harpsichord to a twentieth-century kinetic light box.
Presenting many rarely seen items from the Gallerys permanent collection, along with an eighteenth-century harpsichord lent by Yales Collection of Musical Instruments, Time Will Tell: Ethics and Choices in Conservation offers new insight into the art and science of object care. The exhibition reveals that there are no simple answers to the questions conservators and curators face, and only time will tell how successful their solutions are.