The First Art Newspaper on the Net Established in 1996 United States Saturday, December 20, 2014


Grosz Heirs File Suit Against MoMA for Artworks Unlawfully Taken During Nazi Era
George Grosz, The Poet Max Herrmann-Neisse. Photo: Courtesy Rowland & Petroff.
NEW YORK, NY.- The heirs of George Grosz, a famous Weimar period artist and relentless critic of the Nazis and German military establishment, filed suit in New York on Friday, April 10, 2009 against the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) for refusing to return three artworks created by Grosz and left behind by him when he fled Germany in 1933 to avoid Nazi threats against his life. The artworks, Portrait of the Poet Max Herrmann-Neisse, Self-Portrait with Model, and Republican Automatons, were left behind in Germany with his Galerist Alfred Flechtheim. Eventually Flechtheim was also forced to flee Germany due to Nazi persecution and the artworks were lost after Flechtheim's death.

Suit against MoMA was filed only after MoMA refused further discussion with the Grosz heirs, refused to toll the statute of limitations, and refused to mediate or arbitrate the dispute. Under the Washington Conference principles museums are to seek "fair and just" solutions to Nazi-era claims, and under the AAM and AAMD guidelines museums also should waive technical defenses such as the statute of limitations and laches and seek alternative avenues of dispute resolution, such as through mediation or arbitration. MoMA refused all of these suggested alternatives, leaving the Grosz heirs with no other alternative but to file suit.

The Max Herrmann-Neisse painting, one of the best examples of Grosz' portraits, was created by George Grosz in 1927 and was consigned by Grosz to the Galerie Alfred Flechtheim in Berlin. The Flechtheim Galerie exhibited the painting on several occasions including at the MoMA in 1931. However, in 1933 the Flechtheim Galerie went into liquidation and Alfred Flechtheim fled Germany due to Nazi persecution.

In early 1933, George Grosz left Germany after being threatened by the Nazis and took up a teaching position in New York with the Art Students League. As a strident Nazi opponent Grosz exited Germany just prior to Hitler's appointment as Chancellor. Shortly thereafter Grosz'apartment and atelier in Berlin were ransacked by Nazi storm troopers and approximately 285 Grosz artworks, including those on display in museums, were either confiscated or destroyed.

While he was in exile in America, the Nazi government ordered all of Grosz' property left behind in Germany confiscated, including the Max Herrmann-Neisse painting, and revoked his German citizenship. Although steps were taken against Grosz' property as early as 1933, including the seizure of his bank account, the confiscation of his property and revocation of Grosz' German citizenship was published by the Nazis on March 9, 1938.

Alfred Flechtheim died on March 11, 1937 in London, having also been exiled from Germany. Flechtheim's wife, Betty, stayed on in Germany not having raised the necessary funds to pay Jewish taxes in order to obtain permission to leave. She eventually committed suicide in 1941 after having been given notice that she would be sent to a concentration camp.

During all this time, the Max Herrmann-Neisse painting stayed in Berlin. On April 4, 1937, shortly after Flechtheim's death, and subsequent to to the closure of Flechtheim's Galeries, Charlotte Weidler, an art dealer and curator for the Carnegie Institute, claimed she had "inherited" paintings from Flechtheim including the Max Herrmann-Neisse painting.

However, the Max Hermann-Neisse painting belonged to George Grosz who had never given up its ownership.

After WWII, in 1949 Weidler brought the painting to New York where she sold it to MoMA in 1952 through a dealer in Nazi-confiscated art, named Curt Valentin. At the time, George Grosz was living in New York but was not informed of the sale. Records indicate that MoMA never inquired as to the seller or the painting's further provenance.

When Grosz first learned that the Max Herrmann-Neisse painting was hanging in the collection of the MoMA in 1953, he wrote to his brother-in-law Otto Schmalhausen that "Modern Museum exhibited a painting that was stolen from me (I am powerless against that) they bought it from someone who stole it." Despondent due to Nazi persecution and the loss of his artistic legacy, Grosz died a broken man.

Weidler had also been involved in a very similar case involving the collection of Paul Westheim. After the publisher and art collector Paul Westheim fled Germany during the Nazi takeover, he left his art collection behind with Charlotte Weidler. Weidler left Germany as well in 1939 and stored the Westheim artworks in her sister's apartment in Berlin. Following the war Westheim asked Weidler what had become of his collection, and Weidler told him that his art collection was a total loss. This was not true.

Following Westheim's death in 1963, Weidler sold paintings from Westheim's collection that he left with her. Westheim's collection lost in Nazi Germany was well documented in publications and in German restitution claims. Among the Westheim paintings sold by Weidler was "An die Schoenheit"(To Beauty), by Otto Dix, which Weidler sold to the German art dealer Dr. Ewald Rathke. However, Rathke found out that Weidler was not the owner and forced Weidler to compensate Westheim's wife.

Besides the loss of the Max Herrmann-Neisse painting to Charlotte Weidler without compensation, Grosz also lost other artworks which he had consigned to Alfred Flechtheim and which were sold without Grosz' authorization in a sham auction in Amsterdam after Flechtheim's death. Among the artworks sold in the Amsterdam auction were Self-Portrait with Model and Republican Automatons, also now in the possession of MoMA.

Asked to comment on the events leading to the suit against MoMA, Marty Grosz said "We are very respectful of the MoMA, one of the leading modern art museums in the world. Unfortunately they were not willing to apply the principles of the Washington Conference and reach a "fair and just solution" in this case. MoMA left us with no alternative but to file suit. We were quite willing to resolve the matter amicably, but they refused."





Last Week News

April 14, 2009

Italian Earthquake in the Abruzzo Region Damages Art Treasures, Churches and Monuments

Smithsonian Photography Initiative Announces Its New Blog "The Bigger Picture"

Sotheby's Sales of Impressionist and Modern Art to be Held on May 5 & 6 in New York

Musee Rodin Presents Gillian Wearing, Confessions / Portraits, Vidéos

The Film Society of Lincoln Center to Present On the Edge: New Independent Cinema from China 2009

Live Music Returns to MoMA's Sculpture Garden in July and August

Pulitzer Prize Photographs to Open at the Overby Center for Southern Journalism and Politics

Modern Works' Titles Reveal Links to Classical Roots

Depleted Uranium OK for Iraqis and US Troops, but Not for North Carolina

Moscow Museum of Modern Art Presents Tatiana Selvinskaya "Playing Classics"

Argentinean Artist Alberto Montoreano to Show Paintings at Schody Gallery in Warsaw

Exhibitions Continue Exploration into Frye Collection

Rock Prophecies: Feature-length Chronicle of Conflicted Photographer Robert M. Knight

Performance, Video, Music, and Audio Features by Contemporary New York Artists Included in Metropolitan Exhibition

The American Institute of Architects Announces the 2009 COTE Top Ten Green Projects

The Window, Carlos Soríns Poignant, Bergman-Inflected Drama, has U.S. Theatrical Premiere at Film Forum

Artists Vie for Honors in Arts & Crafts Guild Competition

"America's Funniest Home Videos" Brings Laughter to the Smithsonian

Announcing the Establishment of The Július Koller Society

April 13, 2009

Governor Schwarzenegger Returns Holocaust-Era Artwork to Heirs of Jewish Family

Nagoya/Boston Museum of Fine Arts Celebrates 10th Anniversary

Peter Zumthor of Switzerland Becomes the 2009 Pritzker Architecture Prize Laureate

New Morgan Exhibition Examines the Artistry and Innovation of Twentieth-century Stage Design

The Boston Athenaeum Presents "Portrait Week" in April

New Museum Presents Works by Fifty International Artists for First Edition of "The Generational"

Tomas Saraceno Looks to the Sky to Envision New Horizons

Sensitive Vision: The Prints of Beth Van Hoesen to Open at the Portland Art Museum

Oriental Theme on Tap for Spring Fundraiser La Table des Artistes: Chinoiserie on April 24

Robert Hull Fleming Museum to Open Quadricentennial Exhibition

Raymond Martinez Returns to the London Art Scene with Exhibition at the Gallery in Cork Street

Brooklyn Museum Celebrates Sufism with an Islamic Art Installation

"Fashion Forward: Photographs by Louise Dahl-Wolfe" At National Museum of Women in the Arts

The Georgia Museum of Art at the University of Georgia Launches Virtual Museum in Second Life

Seattle Art Museum to Present an Intimate Tribute to the Late Andrew Wyeth

National Gallery of Canada will Consult Photographic Community on Future of Canadian Museum of Contemporary Photography

Michener Art Museum To Host Jim Henson's Fantastic World In New Gallery Space

Employment Opportunity at the Nevada Museum of Art, Museum Looking for Curatorial Assistant

Fashion Retailer Barbara Freeling Presents An Artful Approach to Dressing

April 12, 2009

MoMA Explores Relationship Between Built Environment and Surrounding Landscape

Como Shows Exhibition by Masters of Russian Avant-garde: Chagall, Kandinsky and Malevich

Monumental Roy Lichtenstein Sculpture Acquired by the Smithsonian American Art Museum

Matisse, Giacometti, and Miro to Highlight Christie's Spring Evening Sale of Impressionist and Modern Art

American Masters Exhibition Returns to the Salmagundi Club

Jimson Weed Returns from the White House and Georgia O'Keeffe: Beyond Our Shores

300 Portraits of Fourth-century Christian Saint Fabiola to be Shown at NPG in UK

Montclair Art Museum Announces Exhibition to Explore Influence of Cézanne on American Art

Snite Museum of Art Opens Italian Drawings Seminar Exhibition

Collectors and Decorators to Attend Antibes Antiquity Dealers Exhibition

First Museum Survey of the Artistic Work by Kalup Linzy on View at Studio Museum in Harlem

Seattle Art Museum Honors Titus Kaphar, Inaugural Fellowship Recipient, with a Solo Exhibition

Chazen Museum of Art Announces Exhibition of Kawase Hasui Color Woodcuts

London Auction to Offer Photographs from the Realms of Cutting-edge Contemporary Art and Fashion

Fleisher Art Memorial Celebrates 20th Anniversary Founder's Award Gala By Honoring Three Philadelphia-Based Artists

Artwithoutwalls - A New Arts Organization Launches

Exhibition Explores Glamour and Influence of Paris Fashion in the Late 19th and Early 20th Centuries

Peabody Essex Museum Launches Photography Program with Surfland: Photographs by Joni Sternbach

Milwaukee Art Museum Announces Art in Bloom Award Winners

New York State Museum Celebrates Earth Day on April 25

April 11, 2009

The Blessed Angelico - The Dawn of the Renaissance Opens at Palazzo dei Caffarelli

Exhibition To Explore The Power of Paint at The Phillips Collection

In-finitum To Open at The Fondazione Musei Civici di Venezia

The Huntington Library Presents Treasures through Six Generations

Gerry Judah Recreates Scenes of Ruined Settlements at Wolverhampton Art Gallery

Vegetable City: Luc Schuiten's Vision of a Sustainable Future Opens in Brussels

Sound of Music and Crossroads Opens at Turner Contemporary

School of Visual Arts Presents "Mentors": Works By Emerging Photographes

Galerie Max Hetzler Temporary Presents French Painter Yves Oppenheim

Solo Exhibition of Luis Gispert at MOCA at Goldman Warehouse

Of Other Spaces at Bureau for Open Culture in Columbus

Liverpool Biennial Appoints New Curator for 'International' Exhibition

Dia Art Foundation Announces Exhibition of Work by Antoni Tapies at Dia Beacon

John Paul Jones: A Retrospective at Cal State Fullerton Main Art Gallery

Hood Museum of Art Presents Wearing Weatlth and Styling Identity - Tapis from Lampung, South Sumatra, Indonesia

Scott McFarland: A Cultivated View Opens at Canadian Museum of Contemporary Photography

Call For Artists: The 13th Annual No Dead Artists Juried Exhibition

The New York Photo Festival To Open in May

National Endowment for the Arts Announces Recovery Grants to State and Regional Arts Agencies

April 10, 2009

Focus on Andrea Mantegna: Mark the Evangelist, c. 1450 Opens at the Stadel Museum

Portrait-making, Rodin and his Models at Musée Rodin

Kunst Haus Wien Presents Picasso - Myths, Fables and Models

Van Gogh Museum Bids a Festive Welcome to the 200,000th Visitor

The Biennale de Lyon 2009 - The Spectacle of the Everyday

Anderson Ranch Arts Center Presents Interpreting the Political Landscape Exhibition

The Poetics of Space Opens at Kemper Museum of Contemporary Art

The Palmer Gallery Features a Rotating Series of Exhibitions

Baltic Centre Presents A Duck for Mr. Darwin: Evolutionary Thinking & the Struggle to Exist

Three New Exhibitions Open at the Taubman Museum of Art

Tradition/Innovation: American Masterpieces of Southern Craft & Traditional Art Opens

"Heroes of Horticulture" Photography Exhibition, Archival Photos of Reynolda To Open at Reynolda House

Recent Acquisitions Opens at Saint Louis Art Museum

Performing Localities: Recent Guatemalan Performance Art on Video at Iniva at Rivington Place

Braque Painting Recovered 39 Years After Theft

Isa Genzken: Open, Sesame! at Whitechapel Gallery

Delaware Center for the Contemporary Arts Announces National Juried Exhibition of Metal Works

The Communism of Forms: Sound + Image + Time - The Strategy of Music Video

Reflections/Refractions: Self-Portraiture in the Twentieth Century Opens at The National Portrait Gallery

April 9, 2009

First Display of Art from the University of Iowa Museum to Open at the Figge Art Museum

Ten Curators in the Running for a Share in 75,000 Pound Prize for Contemporary Craft at Collect 2009

Design Plans for British Museum's New Development Revealed

Development Team of Boston Museum Bids on New Downtown Site

Sotheby's Spring Sale of Russian Art in New York will be Held on April 22

Gandhara: Pakistan's Buddhist Legacy, Legends, Monasteries and Edens Opens at Martin Gropius Bau

Laurie Anderson and Lou Reed Perform Together May 1 in Benefit Concert to Support the ICA/Boston

Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, to Lend Gauguin Masterwork to Sister Museum in Nagoya, Japan

Nassau County Museum of Art Announces Exhibition of Opulent Splendor of France's Second Empire

Sprawling Multipart Project by Artist Angelo Plessas Opens at Jeu de Paume

Barceló's Sea: In the Human Rights and Alliance of Civilisations Room of the UN in Geneva

Royal Collection Announces a Special Exhibition at the Summer Opening of Buckingham Palace

Photographs of Frida Kahlo to be Featured in Exhibition at Albright-Knox

KC Artists Focus of Exhibition Interchange on View at Kemper Museum's Kemper East

The Miniature Worlds of Bruce Metcalf to Open at Bellevue Arts Museum this Summer

The Heckscher Museum of Art Presents the Luminous Landscapes of April Gornik

Discover Toronto for Free with ROMwalks

The Art of Floral Arranging Takes Center Stage at Detroit Institute of Arts

New Currents in Contemporary: UNC-Chapel Hill Master of Fine Arts Thesis Exhibition

Most Popular Last Seven Days



1.- Colossal statue of Amenhotep III unveiled on the west bank of the Nile in Egypt

2.- British royals crown New York visit with gala dinner

3.- Missing artwork rediscovered in "Stuart Little" sells for over 200,000 euros at auction

4.- Rossetti's Venus Verticordia soars at Sotheby's in London to sell for £2.88 million

5.- Russian magnate buys, then returns Nobel prize to American geneticist James Watson

6.- Egyptian Museum unveils four newly renovated halls of the famed Tutankhamun gallery

7.- 'The Secret of Dresden: From Rembrandt to Canaletto' on view at the Groninger Museum

8.- Cooper Hewitt Smithsonian Design Museum reopens after three-year renovation

9.- More than 200 queries about works by possible heirs received on Nazi-era art hoard

10.- Attorney, artist and filmmaker reflects on the seven lessons learned at 2014 Art Basel Miami Beach

Related Stories



Important Judaica and Israeli & international art bring a combined $7.9 million at Sotheby's New York

Tunisia to auction ousted despot's treasures

Andy Warhol's Mao portraits excluded from the Beijing and Shanghai shows next year

China criticises French Qing dynasty seal auction

Christie's announces auction marking the first half century of the popular and luxurious interiors shop Guinevere

Nine new exhibits debut at San Diego International Airport

Rembrandt masterpiece "Portrait of Catrina Hooghsaet" back on display at National Museum Cardiff

Amber: 40-million-year-old fossilised tree resin is Baltic gold

Egyptian artist Iman Issa wins the Ist FHN Museu d’Art Contemporani de Barcelona Award

The main chapel of the Basilica of Santa Croce open for visits after five year restoration



Museums, Exhibits, Artists, Milestones, Digital Art, Architecture, Photography,
Photographers, Special Photos, Special Reports, Featured Stories, Auctions, Art Fairs,
Anecdotes, Art Quiz, Education, Mythology, 3D Images, Last Week, .

 

Founder:
Ignacio Villarreal
Editor & Publisher: Jose Villarreal - Consultant: Ignacio Villarreal Jr.
Art Director: Juan José Sepúlveda Ramírez - Marketing: Carla Gutiérrez
Special Contributor: Liz Gangemi - Special Advisor: Carlos Amador
Contributing Editor: Carolina Farias

Royalville Communications, Inc
produces:

ignaciovillarreal.org theavemaria.org juncodelavega.org facundocabral-elfinal.org
Founder's Site. The most varied versions
of this beautiful prayer.
Hommage
to a Mexican poet.
Hommage
       

The First Art Newspaper on the Net. The Best Versions Of Ave Maria Song Junco de la Vega Site Ignacio Villarreal Site